Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, July 11-17,
2000
Where Heroin Lives: A Small New Mexico Town is Devastated
Julia Campbell, ABC News- 7/11/2000
CHIMAYO, N.M.--Venessa Valerio was just 9 years old when she went to her first funeral.
Soon her mother would bury her, too. Venessa and her third-grade classmates walked to the
local Catholic Church to say goodbye to their classmate, Audrey, who had been caught in
the middle of a dispute over heroin, then shot and killed. "[Venessa] came home that
day and she told me I cried and cried," said Venessas mother,
Annette Valerio. "She said to me Why would anybody want to shoot a child?
"Then it happened to her."
A Way of Life, Death
The little girl nicknamed "Nessie," who had dark almond-shaped eyes and hair so
long it tickled the backs of her knees, was shot and killed by a burglar who surprised the
mother and daughter as they returned home one afternoon in 1993. The killer, a
heroin-addicted neighbor a "tecato" in this part of the country
wanted the little girls insulin needles, which she used to help treat her diabetes.
Nessies death came at a time when heroin began to take a deadly grip on this New
Mexico community, set in the red dirt foothills of the Sangre de Cristo mountains. Here in
the Espanola Valley, where Spanish settlers made their home in the cradle of what Tewa
Indians considered holy ground, heroin has become a way of life. It has also become a way
of death. Like never before, heroin is moving out of the inner cities and into
Americas suburbs and rural communities, communities such as Chimayo, which has seen
a surge in heroin-related deaths in recent years.
Lives Lost, Touched
Between 1995 and 1998, 85 people in Chimayo, a village of just 4,100 people, died of
heroin overdoses, one of the highest rates of heroin-related deaths in the nation. The
deaths were attributed to the prevalence in recent years of a high purity "black
tar" heroin that authorities believe is being smuggled across the Mexican-U.S. border
from Nayarit, Mexico, 1,300 miles away. Last month, the U.S. Justice Department announced
it had made nearly 200 arrests of suspected smugglers in 12 cities following a yearlong
investigation into a Mexican trafficking organization. Despite the recent federal
intervention and efforts by residents to rid the community of the drug infestation,
however, hospital visits involving heroin-related emergencies remain high and overdose
deaths in this region rose again slightly last year, which is a sign to some here that the
drug is still in high demand. "We are a small area and we do have a problem and we
know it," said Capt. Quentin McShan, of the New Mexico state police in nearby
Espanola. "We have addicted grandfathers, addicted fathers and addicted grandsons.
Most people in this valley have a relative that has had an addiction problem. It has
touched a lot of lives."
Signs of an Epidemic
Among the clusters of modest adobe dwellings, weaving shops and trailer homes, residents
live in makeshift compounds of extended families. Nobody is quite sure why heroin has
overwhelmed parts of this community. Some point to poverty or boredom or a history of
substance abuse in poorer families here. Whatever the reasons, officials say, there is no
question that heroin has infiltrated this slice of rural America and overwhelmed its
residents. Health officials say that they believe that one person in four is a heroin
addict. Though longtime residents were not likely to admit it a few years ago, signs of
the drug epidemic here have been evident for some time. Crosses dot the roadways where
some have lost family members to accidents involving drugs and alcohol. In the nearby
village of Cordova, a spate of heroin overdoses last year among young users prompted
someone to write "God help us" in chalk on the roadway.
Kicking the Habit
Murray Ryan, an internist with offices near the local hospital in Espanola, has seen
firsthand the growth of the heroin problem in Rio Arriba, a county of 26,000 people.
Patients he once treated for symptoms of the flu as young children, he says, have grown up
and become heroin addicts. One of his patients, a 15-year-old boy he tried to help off
heroin, died in an alcohol and drug-fueled car accident on the road outside his clinic
last year. "The hard drug problem, heroin and cocaine, is just uniquely horrible
here," Ryan said. "I personally think thats 100 percent accessibility.
Five or ten years ago, the 14- or 16-year-olds would have been using marijuana. Since
heroin and cocaine are so casually available here, they instantly go from lighter drugs to
heroin." Joe, one of Ryans patients who asked not to be identified for fear of
retaliation in the heroin dealing community, said he was taking college courses in binary
algebra and microelectronics when he got hooked on heroin four years ago. The high school
honors student says he is struggling to kick the habit for good. He says he is hoping a
judge will let him enter a long-term residential treatment program in lieu of prison for
time he owes for several burglary convictions. "I tried it one time and I liked
it," said Joe, of his heroin addiction. "I started off by snorting it and then
that just led to shooting up." Joe says that he was careful, however, not to
"over inject" because he had watched his mother wallow in heavy heroin addiction
for years.
Always in Your Face
Aside from the shocking violent crimes, like the killings of little Nessie and Erik
Sanchez, the problem has permeated much of the community in smaller ways. Until recently,
the state police said, one in four homes in Chimayo was burglarized each year. On the
community's rural highways, it is not uncommon for state police officers to stop cars for
traffic infractions and discover heroin, as well. "We see lots of heroin," says
State Police Officer Mario Salbridez. "Heroin is the drug of choice up here. It is
the most popular drug we have going." Local employers like Florence Jaramillo, the
owner of the Rancho de Chimayo, a restaurant popular with locals and tourists, who come to
visit the communitys famous and historic Roman Catholic church, El Santuario, have
seen the effects. "We knew it was bad when we would hire people and they
couldnt show up to work," Jaramillo said. Chimayo resident Bruce Richardson was
so disgusted when he found discarded syringes in an irrigation ditch in his backyard that
he gathered them in a pickle jar and brought them to a community meeting. "It was
just always in your face," said Richardson, who is the head of a local crime
prevention group he and others formed to try to combat the problem.
Voices Against Heroin Heard
The residents managed to speak up loud enough in recent months that their legislators took
notice, both in New Mexico and in Washington, where hearings have been held in recent
weeks in both the House and Senate. "My only sister is now dead, and I am left an
only child," Chimayo resident Mario Medina testified before a House committee on
government reform on June 30, saying that she had died of an overdose. "I feel the
best way to stop drug use is to stop the drug before it can come across the Southwest
border," he said. Last spring, the Justice Department ordered federal law enforcement
officials to investigate the problem in Chimayo and surrounding areas. "We started
finding true examples of the fact that this had crossed the line," said Suellen
Strale, a local artist and member of the crime prevention group. "It was no longer
closed up. It overflowed into the community." On Sept. 29, 1999, the day dawned with
what would be the first major step in ridding the community of its heroin problem. Before
the sun rose, at 5:30 a.m., federal, state and local law enforcement agents flooded the
town in helicopters and police cruisers, raiding the homes of 32 of Chimayo's known heroin
dealers. The agents used an aerial map the outraged residents of the village had helped
them plot. "I just said Thank God! Jaramillo said, remembering the raid.
"This is long overdue.
A Small Town's Cry for Help
Until recently, the cries for help in Chimayo largely went unheard outside of north
central New Mexico. For years, many say, nobody wanted to talk about the problem that
plagued nearly every family. "Nobody is going to talk to you," one local
shopkeeper warned a reporter. "Its just too close to home. Youre talking
about our brothers, sisters, our cousins." In Chimayo, where many extended families
live together in clusters of adobe homes on quiet country roads, heroin has affected just
about every family, local officials say. "People are in pain," said Lauren
Reichelt, director of the Rio Arriba Family Care Network in Espanola. Particularly hit
hard, she says, is the areas large community of Native Americans, who were pushed up
into the foothills generations ago by European settlers. "They feel dislocated. When
you lose things that are important to you, when you lose family, when you lose language,
there can be a kind of post-traumatic stress syndrome. I like to say that there has been a
kind of amputation of peoples souls." Some said they were even afraid that if
they spoke publicly about the problem, that the dealers, who stood to lose profits if drug
laws were enforced in the region, would retaliate. Two years ago, two dealers killed a top
Espanola high school student, Erik Sanchez, after stealing his car and throwing him
possibly still alive off a bridge 600 feet above the Rio Grande. They wanted his
car for drug money, authorities later said.
Lesbian Wants Visitation Rights
Julia Campbell, ABC News- 7/11/2000
NEW YORK--When Christine and Janis met and fell in love in the early
1990s, they did what most heterosexual couples do: They partnered and soon discussed
having children. The lesbian couple, though they could not legally marry, moved in
together, and one of them, Christine, soon gave birth to two children, a boy, now 4, and a
girl, 2, through artificial insemination. By all accounts, they were a happy family. That
is, of course, until the breakup. Christine and Janis, of Westchester County, N.Y., have
become embroiled in heated court battle over the custody of the two children in a case
that is emblematic, experts say, of an increasing number of gay and lesbian couples who
must negotiate uncharted legal territory when it comes to custody disputes. "These
are horrible cases on all fronts," said Chris Hwang, a lawyer with the National
Center for Lesbian Rights, which handles a number of family law cases involving lesbians.
A Ruling Brings Tears
A sobbing Janis, overcome with joy, left the Westchester Family Court on Monday after
learning that she would be able to visit the two children that she and Christine raised
together for the first time since November, when the couple broke up. A judge ruled that
Janis, who is neither the biological nor legal parent but who was the familys
"breadwinner," had the right to sue for visitation. Janis will be allowed to
visit with the children every other Sunday for four hours while the court continues to
hear arguments for permanent visitation rights. "I just cant wait to hug and
kiss my kids and not let go of them for four hours," a tearful Janis told reporters
outside the courtroom.
Courts Mixed on Custody Issues
As more and more gay couples, particularly lesbians, are raising children together, legal
experts are starting to see more custody battles make it to court. In Florida and in
California, courts have ruled that lesbian ex-partners should not have visitation rights
with the children they helped raise, no matter the circumstances. Some state courts have
refused to hear such cases on the grounds that current laws do not apply to same-sex cases
involving disputes over visitation rights. But, increasingly, legal experts say, courts
are recognizing that non-traditional families should be considered in the legal process.
Last June, Massachusetts highest court granted visitation rights
to a lesbian who helped raise her ex-lovers son, ruling that the woman was a
"de facto" parent to the boy. Since that case, Kauffman said, more lesbian
parents have had standing to get their cases into court. "That is always the first
hurdle," she said. In April, in a case that legal advocates for gay and lesbian
rights say is the strongest ruling of its kind to date, the New Jersey Supreme Court
declared that a lesbian who helped raise her ex-lovers twins was a
"psychological parent." The court ruled that the woman had the same legal rights
of any parent when deciding custody issues. "There have been a number of cases
addressing this issue, and in some sense, it is all over the map," said Michael
Adams, associated director of the American Civil Liberties Union lesbian and gay rights
project. " There is no clear trend. But given that, until recently, there were no
cases in which parents of this type were granted parental rights, it does show that there
is more recognition of non-traditional parents."
Bitter Breakups
Breakups are no less painful for homosexual couples, said Joyce Kauffman, a Cambridge,
Mass., lawyer, who handles family law cases, including those that involve lesbian parents.
"People dont always behave their best when they are breaking up," she
said. "The sad thing is there is no legal process (for gays and lesbians) to help
people through that process." Kauffman said she and a former partner split custody of
their daughter when they broke up 14 years ago without going to court. "I was
the biological parent and I had the legal right to say no, but I didnt feel I had
the moral right to do that to my daughter," she said of her own situation.
After meeting in the early 1990s, Christine and Janis, the Westchester
County couple, decided to bind their relationship in a unofficial commitment ceremony in
1993. Both participated in the planning for the pregnancies and subsequent births,
according to court papers. The couple also executed reciprocal wills, baptized the
children and named them using both their last names. Janis was the familys primary
wage earner and Christine stayed home with the children. In papers filed with the
Westchester court, Janis argued that she had formed a "parental bond" with the
children in the years the couple lived together.
"Christine chose Janis as a partner and a co-parent," Judge
Joan Cooney said in her ruling Monday. "These children have the right of any other
children to continue a loving relationship with their parents." But when the couple
broke up last fall, Christine refused to allow Janis to visit the children, and later,
during the recent court hearing, accused her former lover of abusing the children. In
turn, Janis presented witnesses who described her as a loving mother, whom the children
called "Momma."
Precedent-Setting Case
Mondays ruling was the first time a New York judge had granted visitation rights to
anyone under similar circumstances, and is expected to be among a handful of
precedent-setting cases when it comes to the issue of gay and lesbian parental rights,
experts say. Monroe Mann, the lawyer for Christine, said he would appeal the decision and
ask for a stay of a court hearing scheduled in August to determine permanent visitation
rights for Janis. "The law in New York is very clear," Mann said. "Only a
parent can get visitation. A parent is defined as either the biological or adoptive parent
and (Janis) is neither."
Director of Rehab Center Quits in Dispute Over Alcohol
Treatment
Karen Matthews, Associated Press, 7/11/2000
NEW YORK--The director of the Smithers clinic, the celebrity rehab center that treated
Truman Capote and Joan Kennedy, has quit in a dispute over his decision to adopt a program
that allows patients to drink in moderation. The resignation of Dr. Alex DeLuca from
the Smithers Addiction Treatment and Research Center comes amid a renewed debate over
whether problem drinkers should be allowed to drink in controlled fashion or should
abstain altogether. Last month, Audrey Kishline, the founder of Moderation Management, a
national organization that promotes moderate drinking for problem drinkers, pleaded guilty
to causing a deadly drunken-driving accident in Washington state. She has renounced the
movement.
DeLuca's decision to include Moderation Management as a treatment
option at Smithers was first reported in last week's New York magazine. He told the
magazine: ''I humbly submit that this is the way alcoholics should be treated.'' DeLuca
resigned Monday under pressure from St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hospital Center, which runs the
clinic. The hospital said in a statement that the Smithers center ''has a long and
proud tradition of treating alcoholism by advocating total abstinence. While we recognize
there may be other alternatives in the treatment of this difficult disease, no change in
our own program policy was ever approved.'' ''Since Dr. Alex DeLuca does not support the
program philosophy, we have accepted his resignation as director of Smithers,'' the
statement said. DeLuca could not be reached for comment Tuesday. A call to the only Alex
DeLuca listed in New York state was not returned. In an interview in Tuesday's New York
Times, DeLuca said he was not advocating that the Smithers center drop abstinence. ''I was
only suggesting that you could engage people in a kinder, gentler manner rather than
telling them that they had to sign up for a goal of achieving abstinence from the
beginning,'' he said.
The Smithers center, whose patients over the years have included writer
John Cheever and baseball star Darryl Strawberry, was founded 30 years ago with a $10
million donation from philanthropist Robert Brinkley Smithers, who also started the
Christopher D. Smithers Foundation. The two organizations are no longer linked, and the
dispute over controlled drinking has deepened a rift between the clinic and the
foundation, which advocates total abstinence for alcoholics and drug addicts. The
foundation took out a full-page ad in The New York Times on Sunday noting that it is not
associated with the clinic and that it believes ''alcoholism is a disease that requires
abstinence-based treatment, and that controlled drinking, under any name, whether it be
`modern management' or `harm reduction,' is not possible where the disease of alcoholism
exists.''
In Washington state, Kishline, 43, pleaded guilty in the March 25
deaths of a man and his 12-year-old daughter. Kishline was driving the wrong way down
Interstate 90, and her blood-alcohol level was more that three times the legal limit. She
faces a possible life sentence. Kishline started Moderation Management in 1993, calling it
an alternative to abstinence-based Alcoholics Anonymous. The moderation program says it is
not for alcoholics, just problem drinkers. Since the accident, Kishline has quit the
movement. Her lawyer has said that Kishline realized that Moderation Management ''is
nothing but alcoholics covering up their problem."
Court: Psychologist Cannot Be Sued by Accused Abuser
Associated Press, 7/12/2000
HARTFORD, Conn.--A psychologist required by law to report suspicions of child abuse
cannot be sued by the accused, regardless of whether the charges are found to be valid,
the state Appellate Court ruled Wednesday. In a unanimous ruling, the court found
mental health professionals who are legally bound to report abuse have no obligation to
conduct an investigation of their own before notifying the state Department of Children
and Families. Any person who reports such information in good faith is immune from
civil or criminal liability under state law, the court found. Leaving them open to action
by the accused ''would carry with it the impermissible risk of discouraging such
professionals in the future from performing abuse evaluations of children altogether,''
the court ruled.
The ruling upheld a decision by a trial judge to dismiss a lawsuit
filed by Francisco J. Morales against psychologist Carol M. Kagel. In December 1995,
Morales' then-wife, Sarah Louis Morales, called Kagel about sexual behavior exhibited by
her 4-year-old son. When questioned by his mother, the boy allegedly said his father had
abused him. During the conversation Kagel, who practices in Avon, told Mrs. Morales
that she was required under state law to report the allegations of abuse to DCF. Francisco
Morales, implicated by Kagel's report, sued the psychologist in November 1997. The lawsuit
charged Kagel with recklessness, negligence, defamation and the intentional infliction of
emotional distress because she did not hear his side of the story before calling
authorities. Without doing her own investigation, Morales claimed, Kagel could not have
had enough information to report in ''good faith'' a suspicion of child abuse. It was not
immediately clear whether Morales was ever charged with any criminal act. His lawyer, John
F. Morris, did not return repeated telephone messages seeking comment.
Sex Offender's Sentence Fulfills One Victim's Vow
Elizabeth Neff, Chicago Tribune- 7/12/2000
Shortly after being abducted at knifepoint and forced into a car in the parking lot of
Woodfield Shopping Center in Schaumburg, Angela Bartucci made a silent promise that has
changed her life and countless other lives throughout the state. "I made a vow to
myself that if I lived through this nightmare, whoever victimized me would never hurt
anyone else," Bartucci told a hushed courtroom Tuesday in Rolling Meadows shortly
before the man who sexually attacked her was given life in prison without parole. After
Judge Joseph J. Urso sentenced Robert Koppa, who has a lengthy history of sexual and
violent crimes against women, Bartucci clutched her chest and whispered, "Yes!"
It was the final scene of an ordeal that started with the attack four years ago and
led Bartucci and members of her family to enlist public support on petitions that
ultimately helped persuade legislators to change state law. Their efforts spurred a
measure to keep repeat sex offenders in custody past the end of their sentences if they
are deemed still violent.
Sharing the moment with Bartucci in court were other women victimized
by Koppa in similar incidents dating back to the 1970s. There were Joyce Tardio, the
mother of Julie Angel, the 15-year-old Koppa murdered in 1980, and a woman who escaped
from Koppa when he abducted her that same year. "It's been 20 years since Julie's
murder, and, thanks to Angela, he has been put away for life," Tardio said.
"It's just such a relief to know no one will have to go through this again."
Bartucci, 21, of Bloomingdale, said Koppa's sentence was for all those he has hurt.
"Putting him away for life was my one goal out of this whole thing," she said.
"It's not just for me; it's for the others too."
She told the court how the incident has affected her. "The bruises
on my arms have healed, but my life will never be the same," she said, reading a
statement. "I will always be plagued by the memory of that night and my fear that he
was going to kill me." On the night of July 13, 1996, Koppa, 51, of Palatine, forced
Bartucci into his brown Pontiac Trans Am at knifepoint. Bartucci had just left her job at
a children's clothing store at the mall. Koppa bound Bartucci's wrists with plastic ties
and placed bandages and sunglasses over her eyes. Bartucci testified she was able to see
Koppa out of the corners of her eyes after her tears loosened the bandages. When Bartucci
freed her hands and tried to escape, Koppa caught her and threatened her with the knife.
It was at that moment, Bartucci said, she knew what she had to do. "That's when it
really struck me. I wanted to get out, but there really wasn't any way to, and I thought
if I lived through this, I had to pay very close attention to everything," Bartucci
said. Koppa drove Bartucci to a wooded area, where he forced her to put on a blue silk
nightgown, an evening gown and a red silk shirt before he sexually assaulted her. He later
pushed her into a stairwell in a parking garage near where he had abducted her. Police
arrested Koppa after Bartucci gave them a description of him and his car.
Bartucci, who will be a senior this fall at a Big Ten university, works
as a photographer in a studio during the school year. She said her decision to talk to the
media was intended to help other victims. "I do want to move on, and I don't want to
let this rule my life, and I haven't, but at the same time, it's very therapeutic to talk
about these things," Bartucci said. "A lot of women feel guilty, like it's their
fault, and it's really difficult for a lot of women to face it." Bartucci's
mother, Susan, and her father, Frank, attended court each day with their daughter.
"You have this sense of security when you live in a good neighborhood and your
daughter works in a good area," Susan Bartucci said. "You don't really think
something like this is going to happen to your kid."
Urso sentenced Koppa under the state's "three strikes" law,
which mandates a life sentence without parole for anyone who commits three Class X
felonies within a 20-year period. The judge described Koppa as "the kind of
individual that the legislature had in mind when this particular statute was passed."
Koppa sat with his hands folded, showing no emotion. His lawyer, Scott Slonim, an
assistant public defender, said his office will appeal. Koppa declined to comment
when Urso asked him if he wanted to address the court. Koppa's criminal history dates back
to 1976, when he pleaded guilty to deviate sexual assault and served half of a 4-year
sentence. He was released from prison in December 1979, and he killed Angel the next
February. He was connected to the murder while in prison for abducting a 21-year-old woman
in 1980. Koppa was sentenced in 1983 to 30 years in prison for the murder, rape and
kidnapping as part of a plea bargain. He served 13 years, and it was while he was on
parole that he attacked Bartucci.
Bartucci said she is especially proud of her efforts to spur the
passage of the Sexually Violent Persons Act. "When I found out he was a repeat
offender, I knew something had to be done," Bartucci said. "I was
infuriated." In September 1996, Bartucci presented Senate Majority Leader James
"Pate" Philip (R-Wood Dale) with a petition drafted by Tardio containing more
than 2,000 signatures. The petition called for an end to plea bargaining with murderers
and child molesters. It also advocated tougher laws against repeat sex offenders,
demanding mandatory life sentences for a second sex offense involving a child. Her efforts
paid off in 1997. Under the Sexually Violent Persons Act, the state can force offenders
who have already completed their prison terms to spend additional time confined in state
mental hospitals. It was Koppa's case that helped mobilize the legislature, said Rep.
Thomas J. Dart (D-Chicago), who wrote the law with Atty. Gen. Jim Ryan. "He was the
poster child for sexually dangerous persons," Dart said. "Koppa really
crystallized a lot of people's opinions. He definitely gave me the jolt I needed to get
this done."
New Denver Drug Czar Plans Coalition Against Abuse
Sheba R. Wheeler & Carlos Illescas, Denver Post Staff- 7/12/2000
Darnell Jackson has already been down the road that Adam Brickner will soon travel. As
the drug czar of Michigan, Jackson has logged about 70,000 miles in his state-issued
Pontiac Bonneville over the past two years, driving from city to city to promote his
anti-drug message. Jackson has visited dozens of cities, schools, community organizations
and law enforcement agencies. His task is a daunting one. But it's also one that has seen
some significant results, Jackson said. "Surveys show drug use in Michigan has gone
down in a lot of different categories," Jackson said.
Brickner, Denver's first and newly appointed drug czar, will be trying
to live up to some of the successes Michigan and other states have experienced after
creating a drug-czar office. It's a battle tactic governments are increasingly using in
the war on drugs. Denver Mayor Wellington Webb this week appointed Brickner, coordinator
of the Denver Drug Court judge, as the city's drug czar. Hundreds of people attending
Webb's annual State of the City address Tuesday expected him to publicly introduce
Brickner. But Brickner was out doing his job - discussing drug policy ideas with state
Rep. Kay Alexander, R-Montrose, and other leaders in the drug treatment and policy
world. His goal is to pool independent anti-drug programs from throughout Denver
into a united coalition to curtail the illegal use of drugs, alcohol and tobacco.
"They have all been doing good things in the community, but there's no focused effort
to address the issue in a full, holistic scale," he said.
Brickner said statistics rank Colorado as one of the worst states in
terms of drug and alcohol abuse. The Colorado Department of Health released a recent study
showing Colorado was No. 2 in the country for alcohol abuse and had the 14th highest
number of drug users. Also, three years ago, the national drug czar reported that Colorado
had more children younger than 13 per capita who smoked marijuana than any other big city
in the country. "I think those numbers prove that it's a bigger issue than
people recognize," Brickner said.
Brickner, 39, has worked in the Denver Drug Court since 1996 and has
served as the court coordinator since 1998. He has more than 13 years of experience in
community corrections and working with substance-abuse offenders. He believes he's
the right man for the job because he's an expert coordinator and a leader. As drug czar,
Brickner will be responsible for implementing recommendations from the city's 1999 Drug
Strategy Commission. Those include implementing a public media blitz on the warning signs
and dangers of substance abuse, expanding treatment centers and advocating for the
prevention of communicable diseases.
Denver isn't the first city to hire a drug czar. Houston and New York
City have done so in recent years. But mostly, it has been states that have hired
drug czars. In Michigan and other states, for instance, efforts are focused in several
areas, including gang task forces, community policing, treatment programs, anti-drug
prevention, police officers in schools, law enforcement, technology and public relations.
"Director McCaffrey points out that in America, we don't just have a national drug
problem, we have a series of community epidemics," said Bob Weiner, spokesman for the
White House's national drug czar, Barry McCaffrey.
Brickner's program will be budgeted through the Denver Department of
Safety. No financing has been allocated other than Brickner's salary, which he said will
be about $75,000 a year. Funding for drug-prevention programs such as the one being
implemented in Denver come from a variety of areas. Brickner will be able to apply for up
to $100,000 in "seed money" from the federal government to get his office going,
Weiner said. Brickner also will be able to apply for federal block grants. While
Colorado's state government does not have a drug czar, money the state receives from the
federal government could also finance Brickner's programs, Weiner said.
Former Students Accuse New Jersey Rabbi of Abuse Over 20
Years
Amy Westfeldt, Associated Press- 7/13/2000
NEWARK, N.J.--For 30 years, Rabbi Baruch Lanner was known in the Orthodox Jewish
community as a charismatic, dynamic educator, a founding principal of a yeshiva school in
New Jersey and guide on countless retreats. Colleagues and students say Lanner would call
parents to persuade them to let their children travel to Israel with him, board students
at his Paramus home so they could attend yeshiva, and inspire them to become better Jews.
Some saw him as a substitute father. In recent months, more than 25 former students
have come forward to say that for decades Lanner, a leader in the Orthodox Union's
National Conference of Synagogue Youth, also sexually, physically and verbally abused
them. The students, now in their 30s and 40s, said that Lanner kissed, fondled and hit
teen-age girls and kneed some boys in the groin. His accusers also say he attacked a man
with a knife.
Lanner, 50, resigned as director of regions for the New York-based
youth group last month after The Jewish Week, a leading Jewish weekly, published many of
the allegations. Two New Jersey prosecutors have begun criminal investigations and
Lanner's former employer, the Orthodox Union, has begun a probe to determine whether it
was responsible for covering up complaints about Lanner. Rabbi Yosef Blau, a Yeshiva
University counselor and one of Lanner's strongest critics, said the rabbi was largely
protected by the Orthodox Union, a venerable institution with a membership of nearly 1,000
synagogues that also puts the seal of approval on kosher food. ''I think that they were so
enamored with his success and accomplishments that they didn't want to hear problems,''
Blau said. ''There was a code of loyalty here at the same time, and also he was very
scary,'' said Naomi Freistat, a 41-year-old doctor who said that Lanner kissed and fondled
her a dozen times and punched her in the stomach when she was 15. ''This was a man where
you didn't know what was coming next.''
Lanner lived in Paramus until separating recently from his wife and now
takes calls from a number in Fair Lawn. He said he has violated Orthodox Jewish law in the
past by having physical relationships with former students none teen-agers but hasn't
broken any other laws. ''I did many things I shouldn't have done, but none of them were
illegal. None of them were perverted. None of them were threatening,'' Lanner said. He
denied the allegations of Freistat and others printed in The Jewish Week and said he
couldn't recall others. He admitted accidentally kneeing a boy in the groin in 1983 at the
Monmouth County school he founded. He has never faced criminal charges, although a
religious tribunal was called in 1989 to investigate whether he had attacked a Bergen
County man suffering from cancer with a knife in an argument over who the man should
marry. Lanner was cleared.
Bergen County prosecutors are investigating allegations in the article,
said First Assistant Prosecutor Fred Schwanwede. The article reports that one woman said
Lanner threw her on a bed in his home, and another said he suggestively brushed up against
her while she was a student at the Frisch School in Paramus, a yeshiva. Lanner has said he
didn't remember throwing the woman onto a bed, and said the second woman, Marcie Lenk,
could have been misinterpreted his actions. He said Lenk was living at his home at the
time and never spoke to him about feeling uncomfortable. ''If you felt threatened, idiot,
why did you come?'' Lanner said. ''Why did your parents let you come?'' Monmouth County
Prosecutor John Kaye is investigating the complaint of a woman who said she was a student
of Lanner's at the Hillel school in Deal, a yeshiva Lanner founded and was principal of
until 1997. Kaye said the woman came to Westfield police on Monday, but wouldn't identify
her or describe her complaint. The author of The Jewish Week's article, editor and
publisher Gary Rosenblatt, said he spoke to between 15 and 18 people who complained about
Lanner for the article, and has received letters from a dozen more since it was published
June 23. ''Some of them didn't know there were any others,'' Rosenblatt said.
Freistat, a podiatrist in New York, told The Associated Press that she
met Lanner when she traveled from Wilkes-Barre, Pa., to retreats in New Jersey. Freistat
said she persuaded her mother to let her go on his six-week trip to Israel in 1974. Lanner
asked Freistat to kiss him on the cheek the first week of the trip, and on the second week
summoned her outside ''it was always outside,'' she said and kissed and fondled her. She
endured the contact a dozen times, she said, fearing that the youth group leader would
send her home. She said she tried to pull away the last time he approached her in a
Jerusalem courtyard near her hostel, and Lanner grabbed her. ''He said 'Don't walk away
from me,''' Freistat said. ''He punched me in the stomach. All I remember is just looking
up at him and saying `You just punched the wrong girl.''' Freistat said she and another
girl on the youth group spoke to two rabbis, one who was helping lead the youth group
tour, about Lanner's conduct, but that Lanner went unpunished. The Orthodox Union has set
up a commission to find out ''who knew what and when did they know it,'' said president
Mandell I. Ganchrow. Freistat called the Union ''a boys' club,'' while other students have
said that the Union let Lanner's conduct go unchecked because he made a lot of money for
them. Others said they were intimidated. Freistat said, ''He was smart enough to pick on
little kids."
Judge Orders City to Arrange Treatment for Released
Mentally Ill Inmates
Associated Press, 7/13/2000
NEW YORK --The Giuliani administration must arrange for the continuing mental health
care of thousands of inmates before they are released from the Rikers Island jail, a
Manhattan judge has ruled. On Wednesday, Justice Richard F. Braun, of State Supreme Court
in Manhattan, granted a preliminary injunction and gave class action status to a suit
filed against the city last August buy seven mentally ill inmates of the jail. The suit
contends that the 25,000 inmates who are treated for mental illness at the prison each
year were being released without proper provision for treatment in the community or a way
to continue their psychotropic medication.
The city has not disputed those claims, but argued that Rikers inmates
have no legal right to the kind of prerelease planning required for mental hospital
patients under state law. Braun found that the plaintiffs were highly likely to win the
lawsuit on its merits, and said they would suffer irreparable harm unless the city was
required to provide them with a discharge plan while the case is fought in court. Braun
rejected the city's contention that because many of these inmates are held for less than
45 days, there would be no time to arrange for such services, instead agreeing with the
plaintiffs that release planning could begin at the start of treatment. In the New York
state prison system, most prisoners who have been treated for mental illness during their
incarceration are provided with a two-week supply of psychotropic medication, a two-week
prescription and a referral to an outpatient mental health clinic.
Police Probing Girl's Death at Center
T. Shawn Taylor and Dan Mihalopoulos, Chicago Tribune- 7/13/2000
An 11-year-old mentally retarded girl died of asphyxiation at an Elgin counseling
center after being pinned to the floor face-down by two case managers from the Little City
Foundation home in Palatine, authorities said Wednesday. Elgin police were re-interviewing
the two workers late Wednesday to try to determine exactly what Tina Winston was doing,
how she was restrained and how much time elapsed before authorities were called.
Police said the two were taken to the counseling center to re-enact exactly what occurred.
"Was she swinging her arms? Was she biting? Was it just a matter of her not
responding to commands?" said Elgin Lt. Scott Davis. Little City has suspended the
two case managers, who are professionals trained in crisis prevention, behavior management
and developmental disabilities.
The Illinois Department of Children and Family Services is
investigating the death after receiving an anonymous tip alleging that Tina had been
abused. Elgin police and the Kane County prosecutor's office are still investigating, and
no charges will be filed until they learn more about the incident, they said. Kathy
Posner, vice president of the board of Little City, which serves developmentally disabled
children and adults, said the workers' suspension was routine. "It doesn't mean our
people did anything improper. This is a case that is still under investigation," she
said.
Tina, a ward of the state, was receiving medication and counseling for
behavioral problems, including aggression and occasional outbursts. She was taken to
Northwest Treatment Associates in Elgin on Monday evening for an appointment with
counselors. Police responded to a call around 7 p.m. Monday and found Tina unresponsive at
the center, Sgt. Tom Linder said. Police notified paramedics, who took the girl to Sherman
Hospital, where she was pronounced dead at 8 p.m. About an hour later, DCFS received an
anonymous tip to its abuse hot line accusing Little City of neglect, said Marjorie Newman,
a DCFS spokeswoman. Kane County Coroner David Moore completed his autopsy Tuesday, but did
not give the cause of death as asphyxiation until Wednesday afternoon. He would not reveal
specifics about his findings, including any contributing factors that might have led to
her death. Toxicology results are pending.
Northwest Treatment Associates and Little City both had at least two
staff members in the room with Tina. Therese Wrona, founder and co-director of the
counseling center, said counselors do not restrain clients, leaving such a decision to
their regular caretakers. "There have been times when a child has had to be
restrained here. If [the caretakers] need that to happen, it is their responsibility. We
are not trained or allowed to do that," Wrona said. Her agency specializes in
sexual-abuse treatment, and Wrona said she and her five contract employees often deal with
depressed, delinquent clients referred by the courts or other agencies. There has been no
similar incident in the facility's five-year history, she said.
Tina's death is the first in Little City's 41-year history, Posner
said. The children's home is licensed to care for 80 residents. Little City provided
counseling Wednesday for children and staff members who lived and worked with Tina,
described as a friendly child who liked to dance and sing along with music. "All of
us on the board are saddened and send our thoughts and love to the family," Posner
said. Tina, the youngest of four children, entered the state child-welfare system in
September 1993, when a Cook County judge removed Tina and her siblings from their mother's
care because of allegations of abuse and neglect, said Robert Harris, attorney with the
public guardian's juvenile division. Tina spent some time in private foster care, but was
removed due to her behavioral problems. She lived temporarily at Hartgrove Hospital, a
mental health facility in Chicago, before being placed at Little City last year, said
Wynona Redmond, a DCFS spokeswoman.
DSHS Put Girl's Safety Second, Chief Says
Ruth Teichroeb, Seattle Post-Intelligencer- 7/13/2000
OLYMPIA -- The new boss of the besieged Department of Social and Health Services says
he believes state workers wrongly put family reunification before the safety of 3-year-old
Zy-Nyia Nobles. After just a week on the job, Dennis Braddock, Secretary of DSHS,
announced yesterday that he is investigating why social workers ignored warning signs
leading up to the May 27 beating death of Zy-Nyia. Zy-Nyia's mother Aretha Sconiers, 26,
was arrested at her daughter's funeral and is in Pierce County Jail charged with
homicide-by-abuse.
"It seems to me that the child's safety was compromised in the
interests of reuniting her with her mother," Braddock told reporters at a hastily
called news conference. "I am definitely concerned. . . . All I can tell you is that
if a child died, something went wrong." He was responding to DSHS documents released
Tuesday which revealed that Sconiers failed a drug test and had no apartment just three
months before her daughter and 7-year-old son were placed in her south Tacoma home in
February. By November 1999, Sconiers had not yet been allowed unsupervised visits with her
children. Yet her DSHS social worker pressed on with plans to reunite Sconiers with her
children, convinced that the young mother deserved another chance. "I think there
should be danger signals, warning signs, that people should act on," Braddock said.
He also said DSHS workers would be disciplined if investigations find that any negligence
occurred in Zy-Nyia's case. "I don't know exactly what the level of negligence or
fault will be," Braddock said. "I'll know soon."
DSHS social worker Michele Garner, who handled Zy-Nyia's case, is still
on the job and has not been disciplined in any way, said Kathy Spears, the department's
spokeswoman. But Garner is no longer in charge of Zy-Nyia's brother's case, a move that is
standard procedure after a death occurs, Spears said. The boy, who told police he saw his
mother inflict the fatal beating, was placed in foster care after Zy-Nyia died. Part of
Braddock's investigation will include a review of policies and procedures related to child
protection. He expressed concern that other DSHS workers might also be placing too much
emphasis on keeping families together despite the risks to children. A report on child
protection services done by an outside consultant will also be ready next month, Braddock
said. That report was commissioned by Gov. Gary Locke before the death of Zy-Nyia,
he said. Braddock was appointed by Locke last month after former secretary Lyle Quasim
retired. A child fatality review team is also investigating Zy-Nyia's death and expected
to issue a report in about three months. That is required by law each time a child dies in
state care.
The DSHS file on Zy-Nyia contained hundreds of pages which painted a
bleak picture of a child bounced between five foster homes while the state gave Sconiers
repeated chances to turn her life around. Zy-Nyia was taken from Sconiers at birth in
November 1996 after the infant tested positive for drugs. Two days after the child's
birth, Sconiers assaulted a hospital security guard while trying to sneak out with her
baby. The state still returned the baby to Sconiers until she was sentenced in January
1997 to 30 months in Purdy Correctional Center on a cocaine-related conviction. Sconiers,
herself abused and abandoned as a child, already had a juvenile criminal record dating
back to 1989, when she was convicted of forgery, first-degree robbery, first-degree
assault and custodial assault. Zy-Nyia's father, Willie Nobles, is serving a life sentence
for a fatal 1998 drive-by shooting on Tacoma's east side. The state planned to terminate
Sconiers' parental rights in 1997, but social workers repeatedly delayed court dates with
the hope that she would clean up her life. Although Sconiers often said she wanted her
children back, she insisted she did not have a drug problem, failed drug tests and missed
required parenting classes.
Drug Company in Record Settlement
James V. Grimaldi, Washington Post-7/13/2000
Mylan Laboratories Inc. tentatively agreed yesterday to reimburse consumers $135
million to settle lawsuits by the Federal Trade Commission, 32 states and the District
alleging that the world's second-biggest drugmaker conspired to corner the market for
generic anti-anxiety drugs and jacked up prices more than 2,500 percent. The antitrust
settlement is the largest in FTC history and bolsters the agency's nascent policy of
seeking damages on behalf of consumers in instances in which procedural roadblocks prevent
them from suing directly. Mylan, which makes both generic and name-brand drugs, admitted
no wrongdoing. The terms of the agreement would require Mylan to abandon the exclusive
deals that it cut with three companies that supplied the key chemicals needed to make the
anti-anxiety drugs, state authorities said.
After Pittsburgh-based Mylan made exclusive agreements with an Italian
drug-ingredient manufacturer and others in late 1997, Mylan raised the wholesale price for
a bottle of 500 clorazepate tablets from $11.36 to $377. The price of lorazepam soared
from $7.30 to $190 a bottle. In a telephone conference call with reporters, Mylan chief
executive and chairman Milan "Mike" Puskar rejected the notion that the company
conspired to raise prices: "That's absolutely untrue." Ohio Attorney General
Betty Montgomery (R), who led the states' effort, countered that the after Mylan's
exclusive agreements cut of the supply of the key ingredients to Mylan's competitors,
Mylan then raised drug prices more than 2,500 percent. Montgomery called the case "an
unfortunate example of undisguised and naked corporate greed." "Profit is not a
bad word, but this not profit. This is unconscionable," she said.
The case also has established important precedent for the enforcement
of antitrust law. Last year, U.S. District Judge Thomas Hogan ruled that the FTC could
seek disgorgement of ill-gotten gains in antitrust cases. Traditionally only private
litigants sought restitution in such cases, but the FTC sought that power because
consumers were unable to file such claims. That's because antitrust law requires the
direct purchasers of a product to sue, and in the case of these anti-anxiety drugs, the
first purchasers were wholesale drug companies and retailers who then sold to consumers.
"The ability to get this kind of restitution is something the commission has only
rarely done in the past," said William Baer, the former FTC official who masterminded
the Mylan case and now is in private practice. "It dwarfs any other award the FTC has
gotten in an antitrust case, either by litigation or settlement." Previously, the FTC
won a $20 million settlement in a case involving infant formula. The Mylan settlement
includes $100 million for the states and $35 million for private parties. An additional
$12 million in attorneys' fees would be paid. The terms are subject to approval by the
FTC, the states and the judge.
The District was a plaintiff in the case, along with Maryland and 31
other states. Those jurisdictions will work out a formula for divvying up the money based
on calculations of the number of consumers victimized by the alleged price gouging,
Montgomery said, and then each will figure out how to get the money to consumers, or
develop programs that benefit groups in which most of the consumers can be found. Puskar
professed the company's innocence and said the case was settled to put the matter behind
Mylan.
Study: Nearly 25% of Women Are Assaulted by Lover
Associated Press, 7/14/2000
Washington--Nearly 25 percent of women, and about 7 percent of men, say they have been
raped or assaulted by a current or former partner, according to a government report. The
survey, from a Justice Department agency and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
also shows that spousal stalking is more widespread than previously thought, with almost 5
percent of women saying theyve been stalked by a partner. Still, Julie Samuels,
acting director of the National Institute of Justice, warned against drawing many
conclusions. "Violence among intimates involves relationships and factors that are
too complex to be captured by a single research approach," said Samuels. But, she
added: "These survey findings significantly contribute to our understanding of
violence between intimates."
Race Is a Factor
The survey also found differences among racial backgrounds. African-American, American
Indian and native Alaskan women and men reported higher rates of partner violence than
people from other backgrounds. Asians reported lower rates. The survey found 1.5 percent
of women and 0.9 percent of men said they were raped by their partner in the last 12
months. According to the estimates, approximately 1.5 million American women and over
800,000 men are raped by an intimate partner annually. Figures among homosexual partners
varied. Women living with female partners experienced fewer violent incidents than did
women living with men. But men living with male partners reported more attacks than did
men living with women. Approximately 11 percent of female couples reported rape, physical
assault or stalking, compared to 15 percent of male couples.
Most Attacks Not Reported
Despite the rate of attacks, most incidents are not reported to the police, according to
the survey. Against female respondents, only one-fifth of all rapes, a quarter of physical
assaults and half of all stalking were reported. The report rate was even lower among male
victims. The survey consisted of telephone interviews using random-digit dialing with a
nationally representative sample of 8,000 men and 8,000 women across the nation.
Insanity Claimed In Longmont Killings
Monte Whaley, Denver Post- 7/14/2000
A 14-year-old boy is claiming he was legally insane when he killed his adoptive mother
and grandmother in their Longmont home last year. John Christopher Engel entered a plea of
not guilty by reason of insanity and impaired mental state Thursday in district court.
Engel faces a trial in December, one year after the stabbing death of his mother,
56-year-old Mary Elizabeth Reinschmidt-Engel, and the fatal beating of her mother, 82
year-old Catherine Reinschmidt, with a hammer. Police say the teen also attacked his
father, Tom Engel, after he returned home and discovered the bodies. The elder Engel
sustained a head injury. The younger Engel faces two counts of first-degree murder,
attempted first-degree murder and three other counts of a crime of violence. He's being
tried as an adult and if convicted could spend life in prison.
Anyone found not guilty by reason of insanity or impaired mental
condition could spend indefinite time in a state mental hospital. District Judge Dan Hale
on Thursday ordered a mental evaluation of Engel. The findings will be given to the court
and lawyers on both sides to determine how to proceed, Hale said. Hale also ruled against
Engle's attorney, public defender Cary Lacklen, who claimed Colorado statutes are
unconstitutional regarding the insanity defense. State law says if a person charged with a
crime on or after July 1, 1999, wants to plead not guilty by reason of insanity, the
defendant must cooperate in a court ordered examination. If the defendant refuses to
cooperate, the defense can't call its own doctor as a witness and can't introduce evidence
about insanity unless first entering a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity.
Lacklen said Engel will cooperate with the court-ordered examination.
But, Lacklen said, he wants to be present when the examination takes place. Hale said he
most likely will allow Lacklen to be present. Hale also said if the defense withdraws the
plea of not guilty by reason of insanity, any statement Engel made to a court-appointed
psychiatrist cannot be used by the prosecution. Prosecutor Phil Miller said that point is
likely to be argued later. "It's sort of a to-be-determined issue," Miller said.
Cape Cod Case Tests Sex-Offender Law in Massachusetts
Jordana Hart and Jamal E. Watson, Boston Globe 7/14/2000
BARNSTABLE -- On June 15, 1998, after 20 years, a jury ordered the state to release
James Lee Pells from the Massachusetts Treatment Center for Sexually Dangerous Persons,
even though three out of five state specialists determined that the Osterville man was
still a sexual predator. But, with two of the specialists deciding Pells was not sexually
dangerous, the 12 jurors apparently believed they had no legal recourse but to set him
free, since they could not find beyond a reasonable doubt that he would strike again. At
41, with two convictions for attempted rape, the mentally retarded man went to live at his
sister's Cape Cod home, free of any requirement that he receive further treatment or
register as a sexual offender, since he wasn't on parole or probation. On Tuesday, Pells,
living in a Hyannis homeless shelter, was arrested for allegedly raping a mentally
disabled 19-year-old man. Held without bail after a not guilty plea, he faces a
dangerousness hearing today. ''I'm not sure how this man could be released into the
community without a plan,'' said Joyce Strom, chief executive officer of the Massachusetts
Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, which treats sexual offenders. ''If you
want to keep these individuals on the right track, you have to provide a training program
and a support system so that they don't relapse. ''
The Pells case exemplifies the dilemma facing officials in
Massachusetts and other states as they wrestle with sex-offender laws and the complex set
of problems that drive offenders to strike out. With 555 men locked up at the treatment
center, and hundreds more serving prison time for sexual offenses - 400 are up for release
each year - judges and juries face the task of balancing the civil rights of inmates and
the pressing need to protect society. Some studies indicate that treatment can
reduce recidivism among sex offenders to single digits, but of the 3,557 sexual offenders
imprisoned in Massachusetts in 1994, the latest figure available, 854, or 24 percent, were
repeat offenders. Cases like Pells's have left the issue so politically charged that laws
governing the release of sex offenders have changed twice since 1990, with the current
version under review by the state's highest court.
The problem for juries is that even highly trained mental health
professionals cannot predict with a high degree of certainty who will or won't reoffend, a
sticking point when the state tries to convince jurors beyond a reasonable doubt of a
convict's dangerousness. ''Beyond a reasonable doubt is the highest standard of proof and
it is doubly hard to convince a jury because [jurors] invariably know that the defendant
has already served his punishment,'' said Geline W. Williams, executive director of the
Massachusetts District Attorneys Association. ''Juries feel compelled to be as fair as
possible, so these are hard cases to prove.'' But defense attorneys counter that it is
wrong to hold defendants because of what they might do, and that the standard of proof is
high because a person's liberty is at stake.
In 1973, at age 16, Pells was charged with intent to rape after
attacking a 13-year-old girl in Centerville, according to court records. He spent a year
in juvenile detention after pleading guilty to simple assault. He was convicted of
stealing a car in 1975 and illegal possession of a firearm in 1976. In March 1978, a judge
sent Pells to the treatment center after he pleaded guilty to assault with intent to rape
after attacking a woman in her home in 1976. Pells was freed in 1998 after a five-day
trial that included findings by two doctors, Marie King and Thomas Laage, and a
correctional officer, Captain Timothy Claflin, that he was still ''at risk to act out
sexually,'' according to an evaluation in Pells's court file. The evaluation, written by
King and representing the opinion of a majority of the five-person panel that reviewed
Pells's case, said he had not attended treatment programs, had engaged in ''illicit''
sexual activity inside the facility, and that his mental retardation contributed to his
acting out. However, the other two specialists, doctors William Meadows and Carol G.
Feldman, said in a minority finding that Pells's mental retardation limited how much more
he could gain from the treatment program and that ''there has been no evidence that Mr.
Pells derived sadistic pleasure from his actions. ''He allowed both victims to go free and
did not actually rape or molest either victim,'' the two experts wrote. ''This showing of
empathy points to at least some degree of control over sexual matters.''
Pells's release in 1998 was one factor in the latest change of the law.
In 1978, a judge committed Pells to the treatment center in a civil process, which meant
that Pells and other offenders like him could be held from one day to life with an annual
status review. In 1990, a change in the law took from judges the power to make commitments
to the treatment center. Instead, convicted sex offenders now complete their prison time
and are released. But on Sept. 10, 1999, the Legislature passed a law that would
allow officials to keep sex offenders deemed a public threat locked up after they had
served their time. Three imprisoned offenders challenged the constitutionality of the new
law in May and the Supreme Judicial Court is deciding how it should be applied.
Sex, Race Influence Psychiatric Diagnoses
Reuters, 7/14/2000
NEW YORKAre mental health problems more likely to go undetected in some people
rather than others? US researchers say yes--primary care doctors are less likely to spot
psychiatric disorders in African American, Hispanic, and male patients. Dr. Steven J.
Borowsky, of the Veterans Affairs Medical Center, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, and
colleagues looked at the "patient and provider characteristics associated with
increased risk of nondetection of mental health problems by primary care physicians,"
they write in the Journal of General Internal Medicine for June. Over 19,000 patients and
nearly 350 doctors were included in the study.
"We found that primary care physicians were less likely to detect
mental health problems among African-American and Hispanic patients than among
whites," the study authors report. In addition, they say, physicians seem to be more
sensitized to the possibility of mental health problems in women than in men, leading to
reduced rates of detection among men. While doctors were able to identify many in the
study population who had major depression, they were less successful in detecting the more
subtle depressive disorders.
Interestingly, people who were diagnosed with other medical problems,
such as high blood pressure or diabetes, were also diagnosed more effectively in terms of
mental health problems. "One explanation for this relationship is that patients with
medical conditions are seen more frequently and thus their physicians can more accurately
interpret their symptoms of mental distress," the authors say. They call for the
development and implementation of "strategies to improve detection of mental health
problems in African Americans, Hispanics, and men," with an eye towards
"(eliminating) racial, ethnic, and gender disparities in depression care."
In Maine Resort Town, Memory of Wilhelm Reich Still Lives
Jerry Harkavy, Associated Press, 7/16/2000
RANGELEY, Maine--Sixty years ago, in this lakeside village renowned for fly fishing,
psychoanalyst Wilhelm Reich recorded his discovery of the cosmic life force he believed
was associated with the sexual orgasm. This week, about 15 to 20 people each will
construct one of the devices invented by the discredited scientist to concentrate a
mysterious force he called ''orgone energy.'' Reich had hoped to use the energy as a
treatment for psychological and physical illnesses. The making of orgone accumulator
blankets will be one of the highlights of a conference starting Monday at the Wilhelm
Reich Museum, founded four decades ago at the Austrian-born scientist's hillside retreat,
Orgonon. The conference will feature presentations by a science historian, an
agronomist and a biologist who studied with Reich. Participants also will hear an audio
recording in which two Reich's students discuss with him their experiences with hostile
reactions to his ideas.
Reich died in disgrace in a federal prison in 1957, and even today many
in the scientific world ridicule him as a quack and crackpot. His supporters say the
stigma attached to Reich's theories makes it all but impossible for researchers to obtain
the backing they need to pursue his work. But some still believe in Reich and his
theories. The museum, housed in the modernistic fieldstone building where Reich carried
out his most controversial work, has sought to keep his memory alive. ''His ideas are very
powerful. It's a mistake to think that Reich is just going to go away,'' said Bernard
Grad, of Montreal, a longtime biologist at McGill University who worked with Reich at
Rangeley in the early 1950s. Grad, now 80, is one of the speakers. Among other topics, he
will discuss a study on the orgone accumulator's therapeutic effects on mice with
leukemia. Reich's work is carried on by the American College of Orgonomy in Princeton,
N.J., which publishes a journal twice a year with new developments in the field.
''He is much more respected in Europe, particularly in Germany, where quite a bit of
research continues,'' said Dr. Richard Schwartzman, a Philadelphia psychiatrist who serves
on the college's board of trustees. ''In the United States, he's still someone to poke fun
at.''
The museum, an offbeat tourist attraction, serves as a shrine to Reich,
outlining his life's work and preserving a piece of history. His equipment, including
orgone accumulators and the cloudbuster he designed to try to change the weather, are
displayed there, as are his writings, his paintings and even his old wooden skis. ''We
can't prove anything. We present things,'' said Mary Boyd Higgins, who oversees the
worldwide publication of Reich's work and administers the trust fund that owns and
operates the museum. ''But if somebody leaves here with a sense that something serious
went on here, that this is not a joke, then I feel that we've accomplished a great deal.
It's a tiny first step in another direction.''
After breaking with his earlier mentor, Sigmund Freud, Reich went on to
emphasize the role of sexual gratification in achieving psychic health. He maintained that
the body discharges excess energy through orgasm; if that function is blocked, the
undischarged energy becomes a source of neurosis. After fleeing Nazi Germany and settling
in the United States, he invented the orgone accumulator, a device he said would collect
the energy that first manifested itself to him as a flickering in the sky above Rangeley.
The accumulators, crafted of alternating layers of metallic and non-metallic materials,
are designed either as a blanket that wraps around a person or as a box in which a person
sits. People who believe in their therapeutic value say people get a tingling sensation
when they use them. The devices were branded a fraud by the Food and Drug
Administration, which obtained an injunction against Reich. After a 1956 trial in
Portland, Reich was found guilty of contempt of court and sent to prison, where he died of
a stroke at age 60. At his request, he was buried at Orgonon.
Reich's followers remain fearful even today, but not of criminal
prosecution or destruction of books and equipment, Higgins said. Rather, she said,
Reichians keep their interest in their mentor closeted because openly embracing his
theories could jeopardize their academic standing or positions. As a result, Higgins says,
scholars who might build on Reich's work and develop ways to fight disease or control the
weather are reluctant to come forward or apply for the grants to pursue their research.
''There is still a lot of fear here, and a lot of confusion and ignorance,'' she said.
''People are afraid of losing their jobs.''
The Internet has provided a vehicle for Reichians throughout the world
to share ideas, but Higgins said it also attracts ''all sorts of jerks and amateurs and
silly people'' who disseminate bad information. Schwartzman agrees. ''There are some crazy
people out there who are, quote, 'in touch with the energy,''' he said. Reich believed
that the orgone accumulator could charge the body tissue with essential life energy,
heightening vitality and potentially helping to heal disease. Higgins uses the accumulator
''all the time. I find that my breathing deepens, and after a while you get a tingling
feeling. And then it's like you fill up and you leave.'' While the device has won few
converts in the medical profession, it is not rejected out of hand by all doctors. Using
Reich's plans, Dr. Stephan Simonian hired a carpenter to build an accumulator. Five months
ago, Simonian installed it in his Milford, Mass., office and has tested it on patients who
were not progressing well with conventional therapy. The results have been encouraging, he
said. Simonian's intrigue with the orgone accumulator lies partly in the fact that
physicists have not been able to explain the sensation of warmth that he and his patients
feel emanating from the device. ''I don't want to take the chance and not use it,''
said Simonian, who has installed an orgone accumulator in his home.
Green Slams Pataki on Cuts to Mental Health Care
Associated Press, 7/16/2000
NEW YORK --Cuts to funding for treatment of the mentally ill have left many troubled
people on the streets and subways and created a threat to public safety, Public Advocate
Mark Green said Sunday. Green criticized Gov. George Pataki for making the cuts and
failing to spend the money saved by shrinking psychiatric hospitals on community-based
treatment for the mentally ill. ''We in the city are forced to read about attacks on our
streets and subways by people who have had recent contact with the state's criminal
justice, mental health and homeless systems,'' Green said in a letter he wrote to Pataki
and released to the press. ''Too often, those responsible like thousands before them have
simply been dumped from facilities and programs without access to the care and services
that might have helped them avert disaster.'' Green cited recent street attacks on two
women who were hit on the head by bricks and concrete. He also pointed to several
incidents in which mentally disturbed people pushed others in front of subway trains.
Green, a Democrat who hopes to become mayor, said
deinstitutionalization has reduced the number of inpatients at state psychiatric hospitals
from 93,000 to less than 6,000 in the past four decades. He accused Pataki of failing to
live up to a pledge the state made in 1993 to reinvest all the money saved from reducing
the number of psychiatric inpatients in community-based treatment for the mentally ill.
''The state broke its promise to the mentally ill, and to the public, by creating a
revolving door that practically guarantees failure,'' Green wrote.
A spokesman for the state Office of Mental Health disputed Green's
allegations. ''The governor has shown a strong commitment to mental health,'' said Roger
Klingman, spokesman for state office of mental health. Klingman said 4.3 billion is spent
on mental heath services in New York each year and ''that's far and away above any other
state.'' Green called for Medicaid insurance coverage to be extended to mentally ill
people released from prison in New York, additional spending on supportive housing for the
mentally ill, and the reinvestment of money saved through deinstitutionalization. Last
week, a Manhattan judge ordered New York City to arrange for the continuing mental health
care of thousands of inmates before they are released from the Rikers Island jail. Seven
mentally ill inmates of the jail had sued, saying the 25,000 people treated for mental
illness at the prison each year were being released without proper provision for treatment
in the community or a way to continue their psychotropic medication.
Mental Facilities' Use of Restraint Raises Concerns
Michael Higgins & Janan Hanna, Chicago Tribune- 7/17/2000
In Tucson, Ariz., a 15-year-old girl died from asphyxiation in 1998 after being pinned
face-down by two workers at a youth psychiatric center. In Chula Vista, Calif., a
16-year-old girl stopped breathing and died last year after four workers at a psychiatric
hospital pinned her face-down to the floor. In San Antonio, a 14-year-old boy stopped
breathing and died in March after three workers at a psychiatric hospital pressed him to
the floor for about 12 minutes. However tragic the story of Tina Winston, the emotionally
troubled 11-year-old resident of a Little City Foundation home in Palatine who died last
week when caseworkers tried to restrain her during an outburst, it is hardly an isolated
incident.
Indeed, mental health advocates said there are problems across the
nation with restraining children at facilities that care for the mentally ill or
developmentally disabled. An investigation by the Hartford Courant in 1998 found 142
deaths across the nation over a 10-year period related to restraints at such mental health
facilities. A study by the General Accounting Office found 24 deaths in fiscal year 1998
alone. Though not all involved children, experts said many did. "Many of these deaths
are asphyxiation of children by two or more adults holding kids down," said Clarke
Ross, deputy executive director for public policy at the National Alliance for the
Mentally Ill, which tracks such incidents. "You go into a residential treatment
program as a safe haven," Ross said. "We want to restore a safe haven."
Advocates for the mentally ill attribute the deaths to inadequate training and
insufficient standards in some states on how and when mental health workers should rely on
restraint to control patients.
A bill called the Compassionate Care Act of 1999 would bar staff at
federally funded mental health facilities from using restraint unless it was needed to
protect a patient or others. The bill passed the U.S. Senate and is awaiting action in the
House. Some cases where patients died involved mechanical restraints, such as straps.
Others involved staff members pinning down patients. Illinois doesn't keep precise numbers
on deaths that happen while a person is under restraint. But the Illinois Department of
Children and Family Services said it has had no such deaths in the past 10 years. The
number does not include the case of Tina, whose death is still officially under
investigation by DCFS and Elgin police.
Federal regulations are already strict on the use of physical restraint
by hospitals and nursing homes, mental health advocates said. In addition, homes for the
mentally disabled that receive federal Medicare or Medicaid funding must follow tough
federal rules that limit the use of restraint. But federal standards do not apply to group
homes or other facilities that operate only on county or state funds, they said. State
standards are often lacking, said Brian Copper, senior director of consumer advocacy for
the National Mental Health Association. "That's one of the problems," he said.
"There's this patchwork of regulations." Officials in Illinois said there are
already strict regulations in place regarding the use of restraints in residential care
facilities.
Little City cares for children in the custody of the DCFS, so it must
meet their rules, which specify that restraints be administered so as "to avoid
provoking [the child] further and escalating incidents" of misbehavior.
"Everybody understands that restraint is inherently dangerous," said Ron
Davidson, a DCFS senior administrator who deals with the placement of children.
"That's why the rule says you're supposed to try everything else first."
Davidson said he couldn't comment on the Tina Winston case because DCFS had not yet
received reports on the incident. "Any death is a tragedy," Davidson said. But
overall, "we've been very fortunate."
Two years ago, a 40-year-old ward of the state died at Lincoln
Developmental Center in Lincoln, Ill., while being restrained. Michael Lane, a severely
developmentally disabled Chicagoan and longtime resident at the facility, died of
suffocation while being held face-down on the floor by five staff members for nearly an
hour. A coroner's jury ruled the death an accident. But investigators for the Illinois
Department of Public Health criticized the staff for restraining Lane in a stomach-down,
face-down position, in which their ability to monitor his condition was limited.
The Department of Public Health classifies Little City Foundation as a
"community living facility," said Jena Welliever, spokeswoman for the
department. That means that to maintain its license, the facility must not physically
restrain patients for punishment or for staff convenience. Facilities that don't care for
DCFS children still must comply with the Illinois mental health and development disability
code, experts said. That code also sets limits on the use of physical restraints, said
Marsha Koelliker, public policy director of Equip for Equality, a non-profit group that
monitors the state's compliance with disability laws. "I think we have a pretty good
set of laws," she said. "The mental health code doesn't have any enforcement
mechanism. That is one of the problems." The Department of Human Services can
withhold funding for facilities that deal with the mentally ill or developmentally
disabled, but it lacks the power to levy fines, she said. "It makes it difficult if
they don't have an array of penalties they can use," she said.
In the Winston case, experts can only speculate about what might have
gone wrong. Details about exactly how Tina was restrained are sketchy. Tina became
agitated while in the waiting room of Northwest Treatment Associates in Elgin. Caseworkers
tried to calm her, but she threw a shoe at one and began scratching the legs of the
caseworkers. The caseworkers pinned her on the floor and released her when she calmed
down. But Tina, described as 5-foot-1 but 143 pounds, erupted again and began trying to
hit and bite the staffers, according to reports. The caseworkers, who haven't been
identified, restrained her again. Law-enforcement officials have said Tina was pinned
face-down by the caseworkers. Paramedics were summoned, but the child was pronounced dead
at an area hospital. The child had a history of violent outbursts, according to
child-welfare records. Little City is required to report to DCFS and the Cook County
public guardian's office all unusual incidents, which include physical altercations
resulting in injury, restraint of a resident, or sexual abuse or activity. At least seven
such reports had been filed on Tina since January, a number that includes the report made
after her death July 10. In five of the incidents, Winston had to be restrained before
calming down. A report from Feb. 8 explains "Tina was restrained for 8 minutes.
During the restraint, she was crying and yelling." Little City also reported that at
one time in May 1998 they illegally restrained another person, causing a burn to her knee.
The caseworker in that case was fired, according to Little City incident reports.
Experts said there are specific rules, in Illinois and most states,
about when and how to subdue a person who has lost control. The guidelines, outlined in
mental health codes in each state, typically guide caretakers at institutions, like
hospitals, prisons and residential care facilities. The state's mental health code says
that those who apply restraint must be "trained in the application of the particular
type of restraint to be utilized." DCFS says those who apply restraint must have
completed a basic competency training program and that their certification be updated
every 12 months. No information about the background or level of experience of the two
female caseworkers involved in Tina's death was made available by Little City officials,
although they did say the two women had training in how to restrain a patient.
The initial approach when faced with an out-of-control patient is
"you try to talk with the person to reason with them to establish some type of bond
with them so you can help them gain more of a sense of control over themselves," said
Dr. James Cavanaugh, president of the Isaac Ray Center for psychology and law at
Rush-Presbyterian-St. Luke's Medical Center. Restraint must be used judiciously, said Mark
Moses, a supervisor at Ada S. McKinley Community Services in Chicago. Moses said his
staff, which works with 350 children with mental illness or developmental disabilities,
gets restraint training when they're hired, then annual refreshers. The state mental
health code prohibits a patient from being placed in restraints for more than two hours
without written instructions from a doctor or nurse. The patient must be constantly
monitored and re-evaluated by a psychiatrist before the isolation or restraint can
continue. All staff workers must be trained in proper restraint techniques, but there are
no licensing requirements. Jan Holcomb, executive director of the Mental Health
Association in Illinois, said incidents like the Tina Winston case simply shouldn't
happen. "I just can't even imagine how somebody can be smothered," she said.
"I think what happens sometimes is the staff aren't adequately trained or there's not
enough people around to ensure that it's done safely."
Crowding Pushes Mentally Ill Onto Streets
Associated Press, 7/17/2000
MEDICAL LAKE, Wash. -- Overcrowding at Eastern State Hospital is pushing mentally ill
people back onto the streets. Mental-health workers say they are encountering former
Eastern State patients on the streets of Spokane -- many of them released with only a
short supply of their medications and no follow-up treatment. Eastern State is supposed to
house just 219 patients at a time, but the hospital has routinely had more than that
during the past three months. On May 24, Eastern State had 235 patients. As a result,
patients are sleeping in recreation rooms and conference rooms; some are being discharged
to make room for new patients.
The worst-case scenario occurred last month when former patient Todd
Marsh was charged with first-degree murder, accusing of killing a 70-year-old Omak woman
the day he was sent home from Eastern State. Marsh was discharged without arrangements for
follow-up treatment and was given a ride back to Okanogan County. Marsh's release
underscores the risks of overcrowding, said Dr. Dennis Dyck, director of the
state-financed Washington Institute for Mental Illness Research and Training.
"There's a safety concern for the public," Dyck said. "What happened at
Omak illustrates that."
Eastern State is the last stop for mentally ill people who are judged a
danger to themselves or their community. Initial stays last three days, and patients who
do not respond to treatment can be held longer. In the past two years, admissions have
risen from about 80 per month to 104 in May. "I don't think anyone knows why
admissions are going up," said Jan Gregg, chief executive of Eastern State until her
recent move to the same job at Western State Hospital in Steilacoom; the former facility
isn't experiencing the same level of crowding. As admissions have risen, so have
discharges. There were 75 discharges in March and 109 in May. No patient is discharged too
soon, insisted Dr. Kamal Floura, Eastern's medical director. "How can I discharge
when someone is not ready to go?" Floura said. "If someone goes and kills
themself, how could I live with myself?" Discharged patients are given two weeks'
worth of medications and as much as $40, but many have nowhere to go, and some are
discharged to homeless shelters.
A major problem is the lack of stable, supervised housing for former
patients, said Anita Cornell, head of social work for the hospital. Some observers say
failings in the state mental-health network are forcing more people into the mental
hospital. For instance, caseworkers at Spokane Mental Health each handle 70 or more
patients, more than double the level recommended by experts. "What's keeping the
traffic flow into the hospitals is the poor funding of community treatment," said Tom
Richardson, president of the state chapter of the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill.
Dyck also noted a hospital study that found 53 percent of patients were drunk or high on
illegal drugs when admitted. Gregg banned voluntary admissions in September in an attempt
to deal with overcrowding. Now patients must be diagnosed as a danger to themselves or the
community to be admitted. In May, the hospital also stopped accepting patients with a
blood-alcohol level over .15, as well as people with terminal illnesses or with recent
head trauma. Such patients now are sent elsewhere. |