Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, August 7-12,
2001
E-Therapy's Risks and Limits Concern Experts
Detroit Free Press, 8/7/2001
According to the monitoring service ABC's of Internet Therapy at www.metanoia.org, what started in 1995 with 12
independent, fee-based sites grew in 2000 to include 300 independent e-therapy sites plus
an additional three e-clinics with 700 additional e-therapists. Typically, they charge
anywhere from $35 for one e-mail response to $100 for a monthly package, far less than a
traditional office visit of $100 or more for an hour or less. (Keep in mind that most
insurance companies cover at least a portion of traditional office visits, while few cover
the expenses of online therapy.) Recognizing this growing trend, professional
organizations, including the International Society for Mental Health Online, the American
Counseling Association and the National Board for Certified Counselors, have created
principles and guidelines that address everything from security and confidentiality to
liability and appropriate counseling plans.
Approach with caution
If you are in a serious crisis situation -- such as feeling severely depressed or suicidal
-- you should call a mental health hot line immediately, says Martha Ainsworth, Internet
communications specialist and e-therapy consumer watchdog. In addition, she says, you must
have the ability to express yourself well in writing. "E-therapy can be a viable
alternative source of help when traditional psychotherapy is not accessible, if approached
with appropriate caution," Ainsworth says. "It's not therapy, and it should not
be compared with therapy." Ainsworth's New York-based Web site, ABC's of Internet
Therapy, warns potential e-therapy clients to make sure they understand the limitations of
the online relationship, the time line for responses and the privacy of the information
they reveal. In addition, she says, they need to find out whether their e-therapist is for
real. Conveniently, her Web site offers a directory of e-therapists that includes
ratings based on their credentials, fees, payment options and services offered.
Perhaps most important, say both proponents and opponents of online
counseling, is for consumers to recognize the risks of revealing details of yourself to
strangers. For starters, says Hiten Patel, a psychiatrist in Novi, "You need to check
references so you know you're not dealing with somebody who has just decided to become an
e-therapist." Patel, who prefers meeting with clients face-to-face, says that
although e-therapy offers some benefits, he's not ready to log on to the Internet. "I
know there are people who are very comfortable striking up relationships in chat rooms
...but therapy is give and take, a dialogue between two people," he says. "With
e-therapy, it becomes a series of monologues." Patel says that he doesn't discount
the Internet as a therapy tool and sometimes uses it to converse with clients after a
face-to-face session. "Occasionally, my patients will send me an e-mail after we meet
for clarification on something," he says. "But we don't do actual therapy."
Besides opening the door to "a lot of misuse by unscrupulous people," online
communication lacks some key elements of good therapy, Patel says. "A lot of our work
...is an art, not a science," he says. "The way a person walks, what he dresses
like, what kind of grooming he has, how he shakes hands and whether he makes eye contact
are some of the subtle ways we communicate things about ourselves."
Dr. Vic Strecher, professor at the University of Michigan's School of
Public Health, says that study after study in the past decade has proved that people are
more honest with a computer about their bad health habits than they are with a therapist.
"People seem to be more comfortable in front of a computer," says Strecher,
whose team has just applied for grant money to conduct a study on e-therapy versus
tailored self-help programs on the Internet. "On average, they elicit more factual
information." The U-M team has been studying the effect of new media and e-health to
create software that mimics human therapy sessions for Web intervention, prevention and
management of disease. Although it has had success dealing with issues like smoking and
weight loss, therapy is a different challenge, Strecher says. "How do you replicate
what great therapists ask into a software program?" Strecher asks, noting that one
element surely missing will be the "emotional support and empathy" that only
human beings can give.
Making it stick
E-therapy is not psychotherapy, and it isn't psychological counseling, says Dr. John M.
Grohol, a Boston author and online expert. "Since it does not presume to diagnose or
treat mental or medical disorders and because it does not limit who may be appropriate to
provide e-therapy services, it would be inappropriate to compare it to traditional
face-to-face psychotherapy, assessment or counseling services," he says. On his Web
site, Dr. Grohol's Mental Health Page, www.psychcentral.com,
he says that e-therapists do not diagnose disorders and do not treat diagnosed mental or
medical disorders. Rather, they use their specific skills to provide coaching to help a
person address specific concerns.
On her Internet advocacy Web site, Ainsworth says e-therapy provides an
outlet for people who are disabled or who live in rural areas as well as those who are not
comfortable with the stigmas attached to therapy. But she also makes it clear that the
client has to take some responsibility that includes doing a background check, asking a
lot of questions and being honest. "Without being together in person, the patient
doesn't automatically have information about the therapist, and the therapist doesn't
automatically have information about the patient," she says. "Both of them need
to take steps to gather enough information about the other to feel secure that the
relationship is bona fide."
Howard Wallman, psychotherapist with a private practice in Los Angeles,
is among those who see the benefits of e-therapy for people who are isolated, but would
not want it to replace face-to-face sessions. "It's good to have someone to talk to,
but I don't think it's the best way to get psychotherapy," Wallman says. His advice
for anyone considering e-therapy is to meet the therapist face-to-face first. Like Patel,
however, Wallman is utilizing the Internet to help people. For those who are depressed,
anxious or just looking for ways to uncover creative blocks, he has developed a self-help
package in which the client pays a one-time fee of $39.95 to participate in a program
called Free Yourself to Succeed, which includes 10 online lessons. "My hope was
always to find a way to reach a lot of people with a lot of information that is not
overwhelming," he says, explaining that the user is asked a series of questions,
which are then interpreted by the computer program. He says the results focus on what's
right and positive rather than what is wrong. "I do say on the site that if you have
serious problems, please seek face-to-face therapy," Wallman says. Since the site at www.yourTherapist.com was launched last year, 150
people have bought the program. Another 2,000 have tried the free trial.
Like self-help books, these programs also have their merit, Patel says,
"as long as you are not out on the fringe." Joelle Lucido, a psychologist with a
private practice in Clinton Township, says she began offering e-therapy to clients last
year. "I started offering it because I had seen clients who were either moving or
going away to college and wanted to continue therapy," she says. "Phone sessions
were too expensive for them." So far, Lucido says, she has not had much online
success. "Not many people are taking advantage of it," she says. "There is
a component in the face-to-face therapy -- a connection between the therapist and the
client that is missing when you are online." Not only does the therapist miss
important nonverbal signals but clients also miss those facial expressions of empathy.
"I've had a couple begin therapy with me in that manner, but it really didn't
stick," she says. "I think the coldness of the computer doesn't provide that
empathetic component that is so vital." Standard and online therapists alike doubt
the Internet will ever replace traditional methods. But they do think that as technology
continues to evolve, more online clinics will emerge. That's not all, Ainsworth predicted.
"Many people will continue to prefer asynchronous, text-based communication, but
video conferencing will open e-therapy for those who really want visual contact and
talking as opposed to writing."
Research: Emotional Impact Can Be Key to Memory
Erin Hayes, ABC News- 8/7/2001
If you saw a tornado coming your way tomorrow morning, chances are you'd have a very
accurate memory of it, for a very long time. So why can't you remember where you parked
your car? One of the keys to locking in a memory is how much emotion is attached to it.
"I think it's fascinating how some memories stick and others seem to disappear into
thin air," says Stephan Hamann, an assistant psychology professor at Emory University
who researches this very phenomenon. Hamann uses functional magnetic resonance
imaging, a technique that builds on standard MRI hardware, to chart activity in people's
brains as they are shown different pictures and words. Half of the stimuli are meant to
evoke emotion, while the other half are neutral. Examining the data, Hamann is then able
to "see what areas are more active at that particular time" when a picture or
word is shown.
Results indicate that when items with high emotional content are shown,
a specific area of the brain's temporal lobe called the amygdala lights up. The amygdala
is the center of emotion in the brain and, it is becoming clear, a very strong tool for
solidly hammering in a memory. "When the amygdala detects emotion, it essentially
boosts activity in areas of the brain that form memories," says Hamann. "And
that's how it makes a stronger memory and a more vivid memory." These can range from
painful or fearful memories to ones that are slightly more pleasant, such as "the
birth of a baby or a wedding." In Hamann's experiments, test subjects are able to
remember twice as many emotional words and pictures as neutral ones.
Although emotion can give weight to specific memories, it does not
necessarily improve memory across the board. In fact, the very emotion that locks in one
memory can often wash out others. University of South Florida neuroscientist David Diamond
devised a simple experiment to demonstrate this behavior in a rat. First, the rodent swims
its way through a water maze, searching for a safety platform. After a few tries, it
remembers the location well. Then, emotion is introduced. For a rat, this entails the
ultimate stress: close proximity to a cat. As stress hormones flood the rat's brain, its
amygdala locks in a memory of the cat. But those same hormones also wash out the rat's
other recent memories, stored in other parts of the brain. The next time it is placed in
the maze, the rat is at a loss. Where is that platform? It has forgotten. So was what the
rat learned before blasted out of its memory by the shock of seeing the cat?
"Exactly. It's completely gone," says Diamond. "What we can also say is
that the rat probably remembers the cat very well."
In this respect, he believes, rats and humans are very much alike.
"It appears to be pre-wired that we remember important events very well, and in the
process of remembering events extremely well, other memories basically get kicked
out." Diamond offers this analogy: "After you see a bank robbery, you come back
to the parking lot and you can't remember where your car is." These studies
take us a step closer to understanding the complexities of memory an intricate
process of brain biochemistry that affects us every day, at the most basic level. One day,
they may also show us how to unlock its mysterious power. "We may be able to learn
how to improve our memories if we study how extremely strong memories are formed,"
says Hamann
Ecstasy Creeps Into the Suburbs
ABC News, 8/7/2001
N E W Y O R K--"I think it makes me feel great, like I love everybody,"
Hilton Dufont said from his room at the Phoenix House, a New York drug treatment center.
It used to be a drug reserved for club kids who raved all night long in the nation's big
cities. These days Ecstasy use is spreading like a disease throughout the country. It's
growing more than any other illegal drug in the United States and in the last year alone,
the number of eighth-graders who used Ecstasy at least once jumped 82 percent. Dufont is
one of many teens who got into big trouble with a substance he once thought of as a simple
and safe love-drug. Doniel Goodstein, who is also battling his Ecstasy addiction at the
Phoenix House, said he never thought the Ecstasy could be harmful. "Everybody's
having fun, everybody's dancing, it seems like everything's all right," Goodstein
said.
But the good times don't last for most Ecstasy users, and when the
party is over they could end up with permanent brain damage and nerve damage. Research
shows that Ecstasy can also cause liver, kidney and heart problems. Goodstein remembers
the moment he realized that everything wasn't all right. "My legs started shaking, I
couldn't stop shaking for like three days. I couldn't move for like three days,"
Goodstein said. Ecstasy, known scientifically as methylenedioxymethamphetamine, or MDM, is
a synthetic, physchoactive pill that induces feelings of euphoria. It dramatically raises
blood pressure, heart rate and body temperature. Dr. Terry Horton from the Phoenix House
treatment center said Ecstasy use can have very severe consequences. "What we do know
is this drug affects very sensitive parts of the brain that are involved with learning and
memory," Horton said. "Eighth-graders are at a very special part of their lives
when their brains are developing, and we can't even begin to guess what the damage will be
5, 10 or 20 years out."
The U.S Customs Service has been tracking the flow of Ecstasy into the
states since the drug first began appearing at its borders, in substantial quantities,
during the late 1990s. In the last few years, Customs seizures of the drug have
skyrocketed, from about 400,000 tablets four years ago to more than 9 million last year.
The drug's compact size and shape make concealment options almost infinite, according to
Customs. Ecstasy is easier to transport and hide than drugs that take up more space like
marijuana or cocaine. The pills often cost $20 to $40 per tablet. Ecstasy dangers are
becoming evident to politicians around the country.
Just this week Illinois Governor George Ryan signed legislation that
will seriously increase the penalty for selling Ecstasy. He said Ecstasy and other
"club" drugs are growing more popular partly because teenagers don't think they
are as dangerous as cocaine or LSD. And the reality of Ecstasy dangers may finally be
getting through to some teens.
Danya Moore, 16, was a successful student with a stable loving family
who began taking Ecstasy at a friend's suggestion. At one point she was taking about 12
Ecstasy tablets a week. Moore testified about her ongoing climb out of Ecstasy's deep
abyss at a Senate Government Affairs Committee last week. "I was once a normal kid
and Ecstasy took me down a deadly, destructive path I could never have imagined,"
Moore testified. "Life is too precious. Ecstasy is not worth it."
Denver Orders Sex-Offender Group-Home Shutdowns
J. Sebastian Sinisi, Denver Post- 8/8/2001
Four group homes housing sex offenders in different parts of Denver were ordered on
Tuesday to shut down within 60 days. In a 5-0 vote, the Denver Board of Adjustment for
Zoning Appeals rejected an appeal by landlords and residents of those homes to remain
open. The appeal argued that the homes are not group correctional facilities and therefore
are not subject to a city ordinance barring them from residential neighborhoods. The city
statute stipulates that group-home correctional facilities with three or more members are
not permitted in single-family-home residential areas.
"We still have lots more work to do," said resident Paula
Hook, who organized an opposition group of Montbello neighbors. "Sex offenders
shouldn't live in any neighborhood - not mine and not anyone else's." Hook said the
safety of her 4-year-old daughter should supersede city zoning laws.
"We're obviously disappointed," said Greig Veeder, who
operates the group homes under a "Teaching Humane Existence" treatment program.
The ruling, he said, "now increases community risk because the cornerstone of our
program was a minimum of three people in one home. The idea is to deny sex offenders the
anonymity and privacy that contributes to their behavior." Tuesday's ruling
came after more than four hours of deliberation that drew a standing-room-only crowd of
more than 75 people.
Hook organized homeowners after learning that four sex offenders had
been living for 13 months in a group home near her while neighbors knew nothing of their
presence. Although buoyed by the board's decision, some residents living close to the
group homes were not completely satisfied. Montbello resident Daniel Johnson was more
optimistic, saying "It should get better if group homes have to go from three to two
people. The program in our neighborhood won't work with less than three." Johnson
lives next door to the group homes on East 51st.
Retired Denver police officer Robert Bogens, who has lived in Montbello
for 26 years, said, "I remember when the neighborhood was called "Mont-ghetto.'
Why, when the area has gotten better, do we want to bring in sex offenders?" Bogens
added: "I'd rather deal with a thief. You can restore property. But when you steal a
child's innocence, you never get it back."
Assistant City Attorney Kerry Buckey and deputy planning director Kent
Strapko argued that the homes in question were subject to the city ordinance. But attorney
Mari Newman, who argued the appeal on a pro bono basis, said the city ordinance is so
vague that it could be challenged in a federal court of appeals.
The city and county of Denver isn't the first local municipality to
curb sex-offender group homes. Lakewood altered city ordinances in the summer of 1999 to
limit sex offenders in group homes. Aurora, Englewood, Thornton, Superior, Northglenn,
Golden and Federal Heights followed suit by the following January. Arvada joined the fold
in June 2000.
Guide Suggests Media Should Take Care Not to Glamorize
Suicide
ABC News, 8/9/2001
Avoiding sensational coverage of suicides can prevent copycat suicides, a new federally
endorsed guide for the media says. U.S. Surgeon General David Satcher, along with
academics and suicide experts today issued recommendations calling on the media not to
give graphic details about suicides, and not to portray them as heroic or romantic or
present them as inexplicable acts of healthy people.
The new guide, written by the Pennsylvania-based Annenberg Public
Policy Center, calls on the media to report on suicide victims' problems such as
asking whether the victims ever had treatment for depression or problems with substance
abuse. "The bottom line is we have an opportunity to prevent suicides," Satcher
said. "The idea is to make clear that 90 percent of [people who commit] suicides are
suffering from mental illness."
Thirty thousand Americans kill themselves every year, and 760,000
attempt it, according to national statistics. "We're not saying don't cover it,"
Kathleen Hall Jamieson, director of the Annenberg Center, told The Associated Press.
"But there are vulnerable individuals who read and watch news and might be affected
by the way in which a suicide is covered."
The researchers said the way the media reports on suicides can
influence other vulnerable people to take their own lives a phenomenon referred to
as "contagion." The guide's authors studied hundreds of recent newspaper stories
on suicide, and interviewed reporters and editors about the coverage. However, they found
the reporters and editors to be generally skeptical about contagion, so they offered an
example: In the mid-1980s, a series of people in Vienna committed suicide by jumping in
front of subway trains. Media coverage was extensive and dramatic. After a campaign to
educate reporters about copycat suicides, the number of subway deaths dropped by 80
percent, the authors said.
The president of the American Society of Newspaper Editors welcomed the
guide's recommendations, and told The Associated Press that they should be a part of
training sessions for reporters and editors. "It's a classic case of attempting to
put ethics to work in practical situations," said Oppel, who is also editor of the Austin
(Texas) American-Statesman.
Based on media coverage from prominent national newspapers, Jamieson
gave another example of suicide coverage that might have been rethought. From The New
York Times came the headline, "Eighth Grade Sweethearts In Suicide Pact."
"Romantizing the act or making it a noble act increases the likelihood of
imitation," Jamieson told ABCNEWS.
Virginia Officials Laud Work On Addiction Facility
Brooke A. Masters, Washington Post- 8/10/2001
A public and private effort to replace a deteriorating Arlington drug treatment
facility puts Northern Virginia at the forefront of the battle to help addicts and cut
drug-related law enforcement costs, national and local officials said as work on the
center began yesterday. The $4.4 million project on Pollard Street in Ballston will expand
to 160 beds and house the headquarters of Vanguard Services Unlimited, a nonprofit group
that provides substance abuse treatment to adults and children in Northern Virginia, the
District and suburban Maryland.
Since its 1962 genesis in an Arlington church basement, Vanguard
Services has treated more than 27,000 people and grown to 10 facilities. But the 80-bed
Arlington building that houses its oldest and largest effort is dilapidated, with
insufficient plumbing and troubled air conditioning. So the nonprofit turned to local
foundations and government. Vanguard has already raised 79 percent of the $4.4 million
needed, including grants from Arlington County and Virginia, said Debby Volz, president
and CEO. The existing program will continue to operate until construction is complete on
the new building next door.
At the ceremony yesterday, former White House drug czar Barry R.
McCaffrey told more than 50 guests that well-funded and well-run treatment programs such
as the ones operated by Vanguard are crucial in tackling serious social problems. "If
we don't fund and support science-based treatment, we'll pay for it in law enforcement,
accidents, welfare and spouse abuse," he said. "There's probably 10 million of
us abusing alcohol and 5 million using . . . drugs, but we've got a treatment capacity of
2 million." Former Vanguard client Chris Tucker echoed McCaffrey's praise, crediting
Vanguard with helping him stay clean for more than 15 years. "It is extremely
important that you give us a place to go," said Tucker, of Montgomery County.
"We are not criminals. We are not bad people. . . . [Vanguard's counselors] were able
to lift the pain and give me a new direction."
The plan to expand Vanguard's Ballston presence has drawn little
neighborhood opposition, said Chris Zimmerman (D), vice chairman of the Arlington County
Board. "The fact that we can have a facility like this and not have controversy says
a lot about the community and a lot about Vanguard . . . the skills and sensitivity they
have shown in winning over the community." U.S. Rep. James P. Moran Jr. (D-Virginia)
praised the public and private support for Vanguard's expansion. "Arlington is not
only taking care of its own, it is showing the way to the rest of the country," he
said. "If we can reduce the demand [for illegal drugs] through effective drug
treatment . . . the supply will be less profitable and too risky for the growers to invest
in."
As Backstreet Boy Leaves Rehab, His Mom Tells of His
Emotional Struggle
ABC News, 8/10/2001
A month after Backstreet Boy A.J. McLean left his bandmates to undergo treatment for
alcoholism and depression, his mother says he is still struggling to reconcile two
conflicting sides of himself. Though the world knows A.J. as the tattooed, flirtatious bad
boy of the hit-making heartthrobs, his mother tells Connie Chung on ABCNEWS 20/20
that she knows him as "gentle" and "insecure" Alex. As the Backstreet
Boys achieved immense fame, Denise McLean says, Alex retreated into the A.J. persona, in
part to escape his insecurities and emotional distress. Though it stunned fans,
A.J.s decision to enter treatment was a great relief for Denise. It was the
beginning of what she hopes will be a homecoming for her son Alex. "Mom,
youve got your son back," Denise says her son recently told her.
Alex was only 4 years old when his parents divorced. He and his mom
lived with his grandparents in West Palm Beach, Fla., and his mother says there was a
strong bond of friendship within the family. "We were inseparable, we were this
mom-son buddy team," she says. He landed his first job in show business when he was 6
years old. It was a part in a play at the childrens theater where his mother worked.
She says he was immediately hooked. "He walked on the stage that day when he was 6,
that first show, and I dont think he ever wanted to leave," says Denise. Alex
continued acting as well as taking piano and dance lessons. By the time he was 8, he was
spending his weekends in professional theater productions. "Everything that was
involved around the theater, he wanted to learn. It was like he had this drive," says
Denise.
He dreamed of eventually going to Broadway but his plans took a turn
when he answered an ad in a trade newspaper announcing auditions for a boy band, which
would become known as the Backstreet Boys. The band spent two years in Europe, where they
became a pop phenomenon, then they returned to the States, where they rocketed to stardom.
Denise traveled with the boys, first as a guardian and later as part of their management
team, but the mother-son team became increasingly difficult to maintain. "It
wasnt like you could just go somewhere as a mother and son anymore and enjoy the
privacy, and the special moment of being with your child. There was no such thing. It was
fading very quickly."
Alexs relationship with his mother was not his only relationship
that was strained by his success. He seemed to attract people who were intoxicated by his
fame and there was little substance to many of his new friendships, his mother says.
"I think people started coming around that really were not interested in Alex
anymore," Denise says. "They were interested in what the Backstreet Boy could do
for them. ... It was not about him, it was about them."
Instead of eschewing these people, her son would embrace the A.J.
caricature, Denise says. "He, wanting to please, would be the, the big guy
he would turn into A.J., and he would take them out, and he would pay for [them],
and he would be the big shot." The private Alex was giving way to the public A.J.,
and he often went out drinking and carousing at night, she says. "He wanted to
sleep all day," his mother says. "He wanted to just go out and party at
night."
Denise says A.J. was hurt by his father, who had been out of his life
for 15 years. A.J. had sought him out, hoping to build a meaningful relationship and find
answers about his past. But like many of the other people coming into his life,
Alexs father seemed less interested in his son than he was in A.J. the pop star,
Denise says. "He was interested in him because he was a Backstreet Boy," Denise
says. "It wasnt about Alex.
Alex had already seen so much of this in his
friends happening that that must have been just devastating for him to see this in his
father." Alexs father disputes that he was only interested in Alex
because of his fame.Robert McLean says he was elated when his son first contacted him, and
is now disappointed that Alex no longer returns his calls. "I love my son
Alex very much and would do anything I could to help him," says Robert. "It is
my deepest desire for us to work together to resolve our past and to move forward."
This year, Alex/A.J. took another emotional blows, which his mother believes contributed
to his depression.
His beloved grandmother, who helped raise him, died of heart failure.
Denise says her son never had a chance to grieve. "He really didnt have the
coping mechanisms," she says. "And his lifestyle didnt allow him the time
to deal with it." Denise believes Alexs way of shutting the door on his
personal pain was to retreat further into his stage persona. "He found a back door he
could go through, and that was A.J.," she says. "He just got lost in the hype,
the drinking, the lifestyle, the fame. It just pushed Alex out."
Last fall, when the Backstreet Boys launched their third album, Black
& Blue, and began touring, A.J.s bandmates became distressed by his
self-destructive behavior. His voice was faltering, he lost energy on stage, and he
wasnt living up to his responsibilities in the group. It was clear to Denise that
she was further losing touch with her son. A therapist began traveling with him. Denise
says she tried repeatedly to get through to her son, but he wasnt receptive. Then,
one Sunday, he called his mother and asked for help. She says he was desperate and scared
and told her, "I cant stay out here
I cant cope with it. I need
help. I need to go somewhere." In July, his bandmates made the announcement on MTV
that A.J. would be seeking treatment, and the support from the fans was overwhelming.
Denise says she saw an immediate change in her son once he decided to
seek treatment. "I was absolutely amazed at the calmness in his voice," she
says. "I was so relieved that you could hear in his voice that he felt safe. He was
where he needed to be." Denise says Alex has been out of residential treatment for
six days, but remains under a doctors care in an outpatient program. She says her
son now recognizes that he needs to learn to differentiate himself from the pop star
persona. "He needs to learn that when he walks off that stage, he becomes Alex,"
his mom says. "He was capable of doing that. And he needs to regain that
capability."
How TV Host Beat Depression
ABC News, 8/10/2001
N E W Y O R K With her broad, smiling face, quick wit and infectious laugh,
its hard to believe that Rosie ODonnell even gets the blues. But, as the TV
show hostess reveals in the latest issue of her magazine Rosie , she has struggled
with depression her entire life. "I am one of the haunted," she wrote, saying
she only freed herself of depressions grip two years ago, at age 37, with the help
of antidepressants. Depression is an illness that haunts many Americans, particularly
women. In any given one-year period nearly 10 percent of the population 19 million
Americans, including 12 million women suffer from depression. ODonnell wrote
about her own trials with depression in the September issue of her magazine, which
launched this spring.
"It is scary to read it back to myself
to let it go out
there into the world, this dark piece of me," she wrote. ODonnell decided to
reveal her depression because she wanted to help others who suffer from it feel less
alone. In an exclusive interview with ABCNEWS Good Morning America,
ODonnell said she went through 10 years of seeing different therapists before
deciding to take medication for depression. "I would list all my complaints of my
childhood and they would listen and nod and say I think you need
medication," ODonnell said. "And after they said it two or three
times I would get another shrink and change my number so they couldnt call me
back."
Why talk about it now? Shes not sure. When she watches her
performance in the 1992 movie A League of Her Own, ODonnell says she can see
her own depression coming through. She said her emotional state was at its worst in
her infamous television interview with Tom Selleck two years ago, when she blasted him for
appearing in an ad for the National Rifle Association. Soon it was she who was being
accused of hypocrisy. Her local paper reported that her sons bodyguard had applied
for a gun permit. At the time she defended herself by saying that she sometimes has
security people who carry guns, and that they should be regulated, not banned. The
Columbine High School massacre was what pushed her over the edge, ODonnell said. She
became obsessed with the idea that there was danger everywhere, and that no one was safe.
She worried about her three adopted children. She would wake up in the middle of the night
four or five times, gripped by fear. It got to the point that she considered leaving her
talk show and checking into a hospital.
ODonnell says she was depressed even as a child, feeling that
there was a darkness in her home but not knowing what it was. In fact, depression runs in
her family, as does alcoholism "and an absurd ability to deny the obvious," she
said. ODonnells aunt was severely depressed and attempted suicide when she was
a child. ODonnell remembers watching her aunt at parties, sluggish from the lithium
she was taking, unable to remember the names of her nieces and nephews. It scared her. Her
aunt would likely have been helped by some of the new antidepressants, ODonnell
said. She herself resisted taking antidepressants, thinking it was cowardly, and a way not
to really live. She also told herself that she was just sad or moody, not truly depressed.
But that changed one day when she was lying in bed, feeling like the
whole world was gray. Her son came in with a Rugrats video and said, "There
are no guns in it. Do you want to watch it?" She saw her own fear reflected in
his eyes and thought of her aunt, who did not have the luxury of the medications she was
refusing. The next day, ODonnell took antidepressants. Even though the effect of the
pills was supposed to take longer, her life began to change in about five days. Suddenly
the world seemed brighter and she was able to forget some of the pain of her childhood,
and the fears that kept her awake at night. There are side effects, including dry mouth
and a disinterest in sex. But overall she is happy. "The gray has gone away. I am
living in bright Technicolor," ODonnell wrote.
Gay Teens Twice As Likely to Have Suicide Attempts
San Francisco Chronicle, 8/11/2001
SAN FRANCISCOAt 17, Tracy Peerson was a devout Christian struggling to come to
terms with her attraction to other girls. She isolated herself from her classmates at her
high school in Antioch, Calif., and didnt talk with her family about her feelings.
She became depressed and so despondent that she attempted suicide.
Peerson was hardly alone when she tried to take her own life. A study
published in Augusts American Journal of Public Health shows teen-agers with
same-sex attractions, or those in gay and lesbian relationships, are twice as likely as
their heterosexual counterparts to attempt suicide. "A lot of people knew I was
lesbian, but they were silent about it," said Peerson, now 21 and in a relationship
with another woman. "I think with a lot of gay teens, you almost feel rejected from
your family, school, your religion. Some of the time, there might be support there, but
theres no dialogue."
The gay teen suicide incidence rate in the newly published study is
lower than previous research (an oft-cited figure has been that 30 percent of teens who
attempt suicide are gay or lesbian), but it is the first study to look at national data.
The report is based upon research gathered from the ongoing National Longitudinal Study of
Adolescent Health. The questions about sexual orientation and suicide, asked in 1995,
found that of the 458 youths who reported suicide attempts, 15 percent had a same-sex
attraction. Only about 7 percent of the 12,000 adolescent girls and boys surveyed reported
same-sex attraction.
The study recommends improved prevention and intervention efforts that
also take into consideration substance abuse, depression and family history of
suicideall of which researchers found are higher among gay teens. "It is our
hope that this study can put to rest any doubt that while the majority of youth reporting
same-sex sexual orientation make it through adolescence with no more problems than
heterosexual youth, a significant number are at risk for suicide," said co-author
Stephen Russell.
The new data came as no surprise to Crystal Jang, who counsels gay,
lesbian, bisexual and transgender youth through the San Francisco Unified School
Districts Support Services for Sexual Minority Youth. Jang herself tried to commit
suicide as a teen-ager because of her lesbian feelings. She thinks the number may be
higher based on her conversations with teens and the fact that many dont label
themselves gay.
Kim Westheimer, former director of the Massachusetts Safe Schools
Program for Gay and Lesbian Students, said schools should look at ways to make students
feel safe since research has shown that youths who are harassed less are also less likely
to attempt suicide. "More needs to happen in schools, in communities to create safer
and more welcoming environments for gay, lesbian and bisexual youth," said
Westheimer, who co-wrote a book, When the Drama Club Is Not Enough, about the
Massachusetts program. "They need to know theyre not alone. The more we can
raise awareness about gay teen suicide, the more we can develop positive
interventions."
Russell, a professor of human development at the University of
California at Davis, said that while the research delves into a somber area, he is
optimistic the results offer a glimmer of hope. While gay teens are twice as likely to
contemplate or attempt suicide as their straight counterparts, the study found that 85
percent of the same-sex oriented youth never contemplated taking their own lives, Russell
said. "The next step is to look at the kids who are fine and ask what is it that
promotes healthy development for gay and lesbian youth," he said.
Meditation Holds Silent Promise for Prisoners
Vanessa Ho, Seattle Post-Intelligencer- 8/11/2001
Here, at the Northern Rehabilitation Facility, a minimum-security jail in Shoreline,
Buddhist meditationand its quest for freedom from sufferingis seemingly at
odds with incarceration. But as more jails and prisons search for better ways to
rehabilitate lawbreakers, meditation has emerged as a cheap, innovative way to reduce drug
and alcohol addiction and its associated crimes. At the forefront is NRF, the first jail
in the country to offer inmates the rigorous course in Vipassana meditation, first taught
by the Buddha more than 2,500 years ago. Today, Vipassana is considered non-sectarian and
followed by many non-Buddhists.
At first, the course sounds like cruel and unusual punishment. Ten days
of isolating silence. Ten hours a day of meditation, beginning at 4:30 a.m. Very little
food. No TV, no books, no mail, no exercise, no smokes, no meat. And no sleeping during
meditation, which is no small feat for sleep-deprived neophytes propped on pillows in a
darkened room. But officials say the program, which began four years ago, can transform
even the most habitual offender. The early results have been so promising that the
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, part of the National Institutes of
Health, gave the University of Washington a grant to study the program last year. The
research is expected to be completed in 2003. "Its an extremely powerful
journey in self-discovery and self-awareness," said Dave Murphy, the jails
programs manager. Others are beginning to agree: Two jails, in California and
Massachusetts, now offer meditation, and its piqued the interest of prison officials
in New Mexico and Alabama.
Most inmates at NRF, which is part of the countys public health
and jail departments, are petty criminals and traffic offenders. Many come in for drunken
driving. The vast majority report some kind of drug or alcohol problem. And most reoffend.
In a King County study, 75 percent of released inmates returned to jail within two years.
But among Vipassana students, only half came back. The course is much shorter than other
treatment programs, and costs taxpayers nothing, Murphy said. Courses are taught by
Vipassana volunteers from around the country. The facilitys future, on the other
hand, is less certain; it is being considered in a round of county budget cuts.
As proof of success, officials point to Richard Jimerson, who by his
own count has been in the King County Jail at least 45 times since 1986. An alcoholic with
a bent for malt liquor, he racked up assaults, thefts, DUIs. He countered with detox
stays, 12-step programs, church support groups. Nothing worked. But during a stint at NRF
in 1997, he took the course, was released three months later and hasnt been
incarcerated since. "Ill be realistic," said Jimerson, 36.
"Everything didnt stop at once. Its not like you snap your fingers and
youre cured." Vipassana followers are supposed to meditate daily, but Jimerson
quit and discovered heroin. Two years ago, he said he resumed the practice and has been
sober since. "I was always bad for fightin," said Jimerson, who now works
for a Vipassana publishing company. "Stuff really became calmer." His mother
delighted in her sons newfound serenity so much that she, too, became an ardent
meditator.
The intensive courses are taught worldwide through an estimated 70
centers but were first taught in a prison setting in India, where a documentary captured
hardened criminals weeping after a course. Adherents often say that results are
"profound" and "life-changing," but struggle to articulate how. The
literature offers vague nuggets about achieving the "highest happiness of full
liberation," further prompting skeptics to wonder whether its all brainwashing.
"Hmmm, it sounds like a rather new and unique alternative," said one veteran
Seattle narcotics officer, snickering slightly. "But I would never argue with
something that works."
Lending credibility to Vipassana is the UW study at the Addictive
Behaviors Research Clinic, where lead investigator Alan Marlatt just received another
grantfrom the Robert Wood Johnson Foundationto study the meditation practice
in a community setting. For the NRF study, psychologists will track meditators with a
battery of questions both before the course and months after release. "Addicts lack
self-regulation skills," said psychologist George Parks, the studys research
coordinator. "Theyre impulsive. Theyre pleasure-seeking. They want to get
high; they get high. They want to drive drunk; they drive drunk."
In contrast, Buddhist meditation trains people to simply be aware of
impulses, thoughts and sensationsand to not react. It teaches a moral code, which
forbids lying, stealing, doing drugs and killing, including even insects. At the root of
Buddhism are the "Four Noble Truths," in which all life is suffering, and all
suffering begins with craving. Thats something addicts already know well, Parks
said. "Its a theory that lends itself to understanding addictive
behaviors," he said. The study of Vipassana, which means "to see clearly,"
is also part of two larger trends: More prisons are emphasizing offender rehabilitation,
with understanding that drugs and alcohol fuel many crimes. And more scientists are
studying the role of spirituality in treating addiction.
Besides basic education and work skills, many prisons and jails now
offer 12-step programs, cognitive-behavior therapy and even acupuncture. Yet, the idea of
Vipassana wasnt a big hit in the beginning at NRF, despite its reputation for
innovation. When a staff member first introduced the idea, Administrator Lucia Meijer
remembers dismissing it as some new-age "relaxation therapy." "Im a
bureaucrat," she said. "I like to think of myself as a pragmatic, practical,
no-nonsense type." But after taking a course, she was sold. The next problem was
logistical. Officials had to get creative to accommodate meditators in the jails
crowded World War II-era barracks, which house nearly 300 inmates. Now, whenever they
offer the course, which is five times a year, they have to clear out an entire wing of
offices and classrooms, remove all clocks and drape the windows. The vegetarian diet also
raised eyebrows. Initially, the jail chef, a retired military cook, wondered what to do
with the "mye-so" (miso), "tah-fu" (tofu) and "brown stuff"
(barley) on the Vipassana menu, Meijer joked. Soon, officials noticed meditating inmates
were calmer and had fewer discipline problems. Staff members began taking courses at the
Northwest Vipassana Center in Ethel in Southwest Washington. They became happier at work,
more serene in traffic jams, more loving at home, they said. Some now meditate every day
in the daily sessions offered to inmates.
"If you can go through this, you can go through anything,"
said Steven Marcus, a 20-year-old former meth addict in for a DUI charge. He had struggled
to finish the course in June. His body had hurt from sitting still for hours. But as his
concentration deepened, he began to experience what teachers call "storms," in
which the unconscious mind unleashes memories, emotions, traumas, songs and sometimes
advertising jingles. Marcus thought of how he missed his aunts funeral because he
was too high. How his grandmother was fed up with his addiction. How his mother and
brother died violent deaths when he was 8 and 9. Heat rolled from his stomach to his head.
"I had a lot of guilt. It was a way of letting go," he said. "I came to a
resolution about the stuff I did to people through my addiction that I didnt make
right." He had dropped out of high school and got hooked on meth at age 15. He had
stolen to support his habit and later lost his house in a meth lab raid. But in a few
weeks, when he leaves jail, he hopes to emerge a new man, one breath at a time.
On an Expedition Through the Mind
Andy Meisler, New York Times- 8/12/2001
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, a standard reference work
for mental health professionals, defines dysthymic disorder as "a chronically
depressed mood that occurs for most of the day more days than not for at least two
years." From his office on West 36th Street in Manhattan, Bill Lichtenstein, the
creator and executive producer of the weekly public radio program "The Infinite
Mind," got increasingly enthusiastic recently as he riffed on how the syndrome could
be the perfect focus of an episode. "We'd want to know what it's like to live with
dysthymia," he said. "Which brings up the question: What happens if we take all
these people and treat them? Would you, if you were dysthymic, take a pill--or undergo a
cognitive therapy or whatever--that would guarantee you'd be happy for the rest of your
life?
"So now you've got to get someone--a well-known observer of
culture--to do an essay. To talk about this dialectic: How is it that some people feel
that it's great to be happy all the time while some people seek the misery of life? So
let's find a comedian who builds an act around being depressed all the time, and ask him
or her: What's that all about? "And then there's the Anne Sexton thing. People say,
'If we'd had effective antidepressants in Anne Sexton's time, we wouldn't have had her
great poetry.' The other side says, 'Yes, but she would have been alive and writing a lot
longer.' So I say: Let's find some suffering poets! And ask them how they work and how
they feel."
In the media mainstream, explorations of human psychology tend toward
relationship makeovers and journeys into the minds of serial killers. But "The
Infinite Mind," a three-year-old program that focuses on the nature of thought, the
science of the brain and mental health--and the subtle, often unfathomable interactions
between them--is not afraid to probe deeper. And later this month an hour-long installment
on dysthymia will join 117 previous shows on topics like habit, shyness, clutter and
hoarding, the insanity defense, altruism, courage and post-traumatic stress disorder.
"Sure, it's a complicated subject," Mr. Lichtenstein, 44, said, "but isn't
it our job as journalists to take complicated subjects and make them understandable and
interesting? That's the very reason we created the show."
"The Infinite Mind" is broadcast on 168 public radio stations
to an audience that averages around 500,000. Mr. Lichtenstein and his five-person
staff--which includes his wife, June Peoples, as his senior producer and chief
deputy--execute their idiosyncratic format on a budget of slightly more than $20,000 a
show. The show's host is Dr. Fred Goodwin, 65, a former director of the National Institute
of Mental Health and a leading expert on manic depression, also known as bipolar
disorder. Dr. Goodwin handles the show's in-studio interviews as well as all introductions
and segues. Before he joined the show, he had no radio experience. "One of the
reasons I took the job was to let the public listen to a psychiatrist who didn't fit the
stereotype--who actually sounded like a normal person," he said.
John Hockenberry, the writer and NBC correspondent who has contributed
dozens of commentaries and essays for "The Infinite Mind," said: "Dr. Fred
wouldn't pass an audition, wouldn't even get a callback, at any broadcast entity I've ever
worked for. But on this show he does a tremendous job." Indeed, the soft-spoken,
empathetic Dr. Goodwin--he often concludes his interviews with a therapeutic-sounding
"I'm afraid we'll have to stop"--manages to keep himself and his interview
subjects relatively jargon-free. "One of the interesting things we've learned doing
the show," Mr. Lichtenstein said, "is that the top people in the field,
including Nobel Prize winners, seem to have gotten where they are partly via their ability
to explain their work effectively to the general public."
In the hoarding and clutter episode, Dr. Goodwin intently questioned a
clinician who treats patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder and a researcher
examining the genetic and neurobiological underpinnings of the problem--after listeners
heard from an elderly woman whose house had been taken over by decades of magazines and
newspapers. There was also a segment about a successful advertising executive who had to
face his fears and clear out his apartment before he brought his newly adopted child home.
In the episode titled "Courage," a financial analyst related how he had
reflexively risked his life to try to save a couple who had fallen into a nearly frozen
lake: Dr. Goodwin talked to a Polish-born Jew who was hidden from the Nazis by a Catholic
peasant woman and has become an authority on the sociology of courage and altruism and
their siblings, sensation-seeking and criminal aggression. Mr. Hockenberry, a paraplegic
since his teens, contributed an essay in which he bemoaned being congratulated for having
the "courage" to proceed with life in a wheelchair.
One of the themes that runs through "The Infinite Mind" is
that those with mental illnesses and neurological disorders experience suffering and
social stigma--and fascinating, often unexpectedly advantageous changes. This can be
traced to Mr. Lichtenstein's own experience. Born and raised in the Boston area, he
received a graduate degree from Columbia School of Journalism in 1979 and by his mid-20'sa
was producing segments for "20/20." "Nightline" and other ABC news
programs. In 1986, when Mr. Lichtenstein was working as a producer and director for a
short-lived late-night television called "Jimmy Breslin's People," he began
having paranoid thoughts and delusions, including the conviction that the FBI had him
under surveillance and that he was receiving messages through his television set. Friends
and co-workers convinced him that he needed to be hospitalized. After several incorrect
diagnoses, he was identified as a manic depressive and placed on the proper medication.
"So I said to myself, 'Well, now I can explain to my friends what
was going on,' " Mr. Lichtenstein said. " 'That I have manic depression, but now
I feel much better.' As if that would explain things. And then the phone just stopped
ringing. I couldn't get a callback. People I'd worked with for six, seven years, with whom
I'd been through war zones as a journalist, just stopped returning my calls." The
strain of joblessness, Mr. Lichtenstein said, made his mood swings worse and complicated
the task of getting his illness under control He was hospitalized several more times; by
1990 he was supporting himself as an office temp. With the help of a local support group
for people with manic depression, he managed to regroup.
Reviving a long held ambition, he formed an independent production
company, Lichtenstein Creative Media. Working out of his apartment, he started raising
money for a series of public radio documentaries on subjects he felt had received grossly
inadequate coverage: manic depression, schizophrenia and depression. They were well
received and won numerous awards; he met Dr. Goodwin while producing the program on manic
depression. By 1998, with money from various private and corporate foundations--including
several unrestricted grants from pharmaceutical companies--he was able to launch "The
Infinite Mind."
Although produced in association with WNYC, which contributes studio
time and other services, "The Infinite Mind" is not affiliated with either
National Public Radio or Public Radio International, the two major suppliers of public
radio programming. The show is distributed free by satellite to any radio station that
wants it. This means, Mr. Lichtenstein said, that he maintains editorial independence. It
also means that "The Infinite Mind" receives far less promotion than programs
like "Car Talk." "This American Life" or "Prairie Home
Companion." Still, he said, the show is well enough established that he and his team
are contemplating both TV and book versions. And he doesn't see the show running out of
ideas anytime soon. "I don't see any sort of end game," he said,
non-dysthymically. "The more subjects we do, the more subjects are revealed to
us."
Teens Trek to City for Heroin
Jeff Coen, Chicago Tribune- 8/13/2001
The teenage experimenters from Chicago's western suburbs have never known the old
heroin, the cooking spoons, the needles and the back rooms of drug houses. Theirs is the
user-friendly version, a cheap but pure white powder inhaled with friends willing to make
runs from suburbia to city neighborhoods where the new heroin can be bought on the street.
Chicago tactical officers watch them from their surveillance posts in
the tough Harrison District on the city's West Side. Teens park their Honda Civics or
parents' SUVs and walk into busy open-air drug markets in a place they call
"K-town," police say, so dubbed for Kostner and Keeler Avenues and other K-named
streets that run through the sometimes troubled area. "These kids drive in and park
the car and walk down blocks that I would be afraid to walk with my gun," Chicago
Police Cmdr. Eugene Williams of the Narcotics and Gang Investigations Section said.
Authorities say more and more teens are coming from across the area into the city to buy
heroin, but most are from DuPage and Kane Counties. They are making the trek for the purer
forms of the highly addictive drug--and more of them are turning up for treatment at
emergency rooms back home.
National statistics from the federal Department of Health and Human
Services show heroin use among high school seniors last year reached its highest level
since the agency began its annual survey more than two decades ago. Local experts said
they fear teens in some suburbs are experimenting at a rate that outpaces even those
figures. Although hard local numbers are difficult to come by, some suburban hospitals and
treatment centers say they are now handling more overdose cases involving teens than ever
before. The numbers began rising when high-purity heroin, most of it from South America
and Mexico, became widely available in Chicago in the late 1990s, officials said.
Hospitals notice a change
Many west suburban hospitals report seeing several overdose cases a month so far this
year, compared with only three or four a year in the mid-1990s. Most are described by
hospitals as near-misses, but a handful of deaths have been recorded. Many teens believe
the newer variety of heroin is safe, experts said, failing to recognize that what makes
the drug effective when snorted is its dangerous purity level. Drug counselors said some
youths don't expect the powerful cravings, crippling withdrawal symptoms and lifelong
addiction that still come with its use.
Although alcohol abuse still affects many times more teens in the area,
heroin has extended its reach into some unlikely places, said Paul Teodo, administrator of
behavioral health at Central DuPage Hospital in Winfield. "The shockers are the cases
that are the type of thing you saw in the movie `Traffic,'" Teodo said. "Maybe
dad's an executive and the mother is a stay-at-home mom or a schoolteacher. And they live
in an area where you wouldn't expect heroin to be a problem." Young suburbanites have
the money to experiment with the drug, which sell for about $10 a hit, police and experts
say, and the Eisenhower Expressway offers a convenient way to get quickly into and out of
city areas notorious for heroin dealings.
For the most part, police said, neighborhood thugs know not to touch
the teens or their cars. "They walk with impunity, because everyone knows why they're
there and where they're going," Williams said. "The sellers protect them because
they know these kids represent income, and they'll be back again and again."
As the number of teens coming into the West Side became more
noticeable, city police and the DuPage Metropolitan Enforcement Group, a collection of the
top drug cops from county departments, occasionally began to run joint stings on the West
Side. Mark Henry of the DuPage group said officers have seen teens make drug buys, traced
the license plates of their cars and notified the registered owner, often a parent, where
the vehicle has been. Williams said the teens who enter the drug markets are often are
watched but not arrested because surveillance teams fear tipping off the sellers to busts
like the one that resulted in more than a dozen arrests in North Lawndale in May.
Risky experimentation
An overdose of the powerful opiate can slow breathing to the point that it stops, and
authorities said it's not difficult for teens new to the drug culture to take a dangerous
amount. Dr. Jabeen Hussain, director of adolescent services at Glen Oaks Hospital in
Glendale Heights, said as recently as a year or two ago her facility saw a few teenagers
annually for heroin overdoses. The hospital now sees an average of one every week or two,
Hussain said.
One teen treated there this summer was the son of a Glendale Heights
legal secretary who asked that her name not be used. Her 16-year-old's friends used heroin
with the teen in her kitchen, and when he began losing consciousness, they called 911 and
left. "I got home and my husband told me our son was in the ambulance, and that he
overdosed on heroin," said the mother, whose son survived. "I don't even
remember driving to the hospital after that."
New federal data released in July through the Drug Abuse Warning
Network shows a slight increase nationally in young teens treated for overdoses at
emergency departments in between 1999 and 2000, but officials say the new figures are five
times what they were in the early 1990s. National data from the federal Department of
Health and Human Services released earlier this year showed that, among seniors in high
school, heroin use rose to 1.5 percent last year from 1.1 percent in 1999. While a small
jump, the increase resulted in what officials called the highest rate of heroin use among
seniors since the 1970s.
Don Mitckess, resource and referral coordinator for the Linden Oaks
treatment center in Naperville, said his facility typically sees 10 teens a month seeking
treatment for heroin addiction or counseling. The purer heroin available today is so
addictive that some teens find themselves hooked after two or three uses, Mitckess said.
Many turn to injecting the drug and spiral into $40-a-day habits simply to stave off
withdrawal symptoms, which include severe flu-like symptoms and muscle pain, experts say.
`A socially acceptable drug'
"Heroin has become more of a socially acceptable drug in this age group,"
Mitckess said, "and because of the purity and the ability to inhale it, the stigma of
the needle is no longer an issue." Many parents awaken to their teen's habit when
valuables go missing. "It can be expensive, and to avoid withdrawal, life becomes a
constant search to score," he said. "It's a daily hustle to get money, and their
own stuff starts to disappear--CD players, the VCR, TVs. You ask, `Where'd it go?' and
they say, `I don't know.'" Although the DuPage coroner's office could not provide a
number of teen fatalities involving heroin, officials said cases involving accidental
fatal overdoses of heroin are no longer viewed as uncommon.
One such case involved Frank Mondia, 16, of unincorporated Wheaton. The
teen's last conversation with his father, Frank G. Mondia, was not an extraordinary
exchange. "He was coming in that night and he said, `Dad, I'm taking out the
garbage,'" Mondia said recently sitting in the dining room of his home. "I said,
`I'm going to bed, I love you,' and he said, `I love you too.' It was the last thing he
ever said to me." Sometime that night, a few days after Christmas, Mondia's son
sneaked out and joined a group of youths to cruise the streets of Chicago looking for
heroin. They found it, and the teen, a popular sophomore football player at Wheaton North
High School, died of an overdose. His stepmother found him the next morning in bed, and an
autopsy revealed a lethal amount of heroin in his system along with cocaine and
prescription drugs.
Mondia said he had been trying to get his son help at a rehabilitation
facility after finding syringes in his room. He was a good-natured, lovable kid who made
some bad choices and didn't get the kind of help he needed quickly enough, Mondia said.
"We talked about finding things to replace this: God, church, music, anything,"
he said of his son, who was Mondia's best man when he remarried three years ago. "He
wanted to straighten his life out and break away, but he just got sucked back in."
Lights Out for Troubled Youth Camps
Richard Stewart, Houston Chronicle- 8/13/2001
APPLE SPRINGS -- The teen-agers hiking up the eroded, sandy trail through the deep
woods to the open-walled huts they called home knew nothing about tight state budgets and
bureaucracies. They just knew that soon they and everyone else at the Bob Lanier
Therapeutic Wilderness Program for Boys would soon have to be somewhere else. Soon they
would have to leave the sense of structure and community they had learned at this 236-acre
compound in the Davy Crockett National Forest. The camp and the Elizabeth G. Lanier
Therapeutic Wilderness Program for Girls -- which were founded in 1972 by the future
Houston mayor, his then-wife and others -- are closing this month. The nonprofit Hope
Center for Youth and Family Services, which operated the camps, this year lost the $1.8
million in state funding it had received annually, and its officials say it must close.
"I'm going to miss it here," said Chris, a round-faced
16-year-old with the wispy beginnings of a goatee. "I'm proud that I've been able to
stick it out here." "I didn't think I could stand it when I was first here, but
I've done real well," said Nick, 14, his dark eyes shining. Both boys seemed to
revel in the pure primitiveness of the place, which is precisely the point. The
remoteness, the absence of television, radio or even electricity or flush toilets in the
sleeping areas -- all seemed like an adventure to them.
It's an adventure that has been undertaken by troubled teens for 29
years but is about to end. Hope Center President Hector Garcia said the center cannot make
ends meet without the state money. "That was 60 percent of our annual budget,"
said Garcia, 65, who took over the Houston-based Hope Center several years ago after
retiring as head of community relations for the Metropolitan Transit Authority.
"Without that money, the board just found it impossible to go on." The Hope
Center has strong ties to Houston. Its headquarters are on Richmond, and the organization
once operated an alternative school on Yoakum. It owns an 18-unit apartment building on
San Jacinto where troubled teens used to stay. Finances forced the Hope Center to
discontinue the school and the residential center in recent years. Garcia said he doesn't
know what's going to become of the campgrounds and buildings.
Lanier was studying wilderness camps while seeking help for his son's
drug problem when he decided Houston and East Texas needed the Hope Center. Lanier helped
organize the private foundation and donated $1.5 million to build the camps. "I knew
that a lot of young people could be helped in places like this, but many people didn't
have the ability to pay for it," Lanier said. "We thought this could be a way to
help some young people who needed it." The Hope Center camps serve 12- to
16-year-olds from all over the state and from all sorts of situations. Some are sent by
county child probation departments, others from the Department of Protective and
Regulatory Services. Some are enrolled by their parents. All have been in some sort of
trouble and are in danger of getting into worse trouble in the future, Garcia said.
The whole idea of a wilderness camp, Garcia said, "is to get these
kids completely away from the environment they had been in." "This is so
different from where they came from that they can start all over again in a structured,
secure environment," he said. Their tent mates become their family, he said,
and "all of the other campers become their community." Typically for 10 months,
as many as 55 youths -- and their counselors -- sleep in tentlike huts with no
electricity. At each campsite is a single cold-water spigot, a mess hall where campers
cook their own meals on weekends over wood fires, a latrine and a central gathering spot.
Campers sit on big peeled logs several times a day to talk over plans and hash out
problems. Campers soon learn to "circle up," Garcia said. They talk out problems
before they escalate into hard feelings or violence. Sometimes they just tell stories,
sing songs, write poetry or relax. Campers spend most of every weekday at a central area
where there are air-conditioned classrooms operated by local school districts, as well as
a dining hall and offices for counselors and other support staff. There's no hazing or
boot-camplike activities, Garcia said. "In boot camp, they tear them down to build
them back up," he said. "Our kids come to us already torn down. We're here to
build them up." Every year, the campers take down and rebuild some of their huts or
other facilities. "This lets them know that they can accomplish things," Garcia
said. The Spartan living conditions have drawn criticism from time to time. In 1996, some
lawmakers questioned the DPRS for placing wards in the camps. Garcia and his staff insist
that the campers were treated well.
There have been success stories. The grandfather of Carey, a
16-year-old from Kirbyville who recently spent time at the boys camp, said he spent
$20,000 for a month in a psychiatric facility for the troubled teen. But five months at
the camp changed Carey's life, the grandfather said. "The boy got back and was
completely different from the boy we sent them," he said. Carey said he hated the
camp at first. But after making friends and realizing the key to success there was
cooperation, he said, he changed his mind. "Even while you're working, it was
fun," he said. Without television or video games to distract him, Carey said, he had
time to think about his life. Now he plans to finish high school and go on to college to
study parks and wildlife.
Such stories did not come cheaply, Garcia said. The camp employed
almost as many people -- 83 -- as it had campers. It cost the camp about $3,200 a month to
house, feed and counsel a camper. Counties, other agencies and occasionally families paid
for some of the campers, but by far the largest part of the operation's funding came from
the state. "That is why the money from the state was so crucial," Garcia said.
Garcia said the state appropriation -- administered by the DPRS -- covered the daily costs
for counties that couldn't afford them. In exchange for the money, the Hope Center
promised slots for 25 DPRS teen-agers. Some days there were fewer kids, sometimes more.
Last year, there was an average of 26 a day, Garcia said.
Some lawmakers were quick to point out the DPRS could have enrolled
children in far less expensive programs. There are other youth camps with somewhat similar
programs in Texas, but none is directly funded by the state like the Hope Center.
"How fair is that to have, in effect, most-favored-agency status?" asked state
Rep. Jim McReynolds, D-Lufkin. McReynolds said he is a longtime supporter of the camps but
that the group's appropriation just stuck out as something different from similar agencies
during every legislative session. State Rep. Garnet Coleman, D-Houston, agreed. He said he
and other supporters of the Hope Center would often have to fight to keep the group
included in the budget, but during the last legislative session the budget battle just got
too tough.
In the end, McReynolds said, there was just a general feeling in the
Legislature that it was time for the center to lose its unusual funding and have to
compete for state dollars just like other agencies. "There was no one leading a
charge against it," he said. Lanier said that for years the Hope Center had
strong allies like former Lt. Govs. Bob Bullock and Bill Hobby. "But they're gone
now," he said. "I should have seen it coming," Garcia said. Pay for the
last of the staff members is scheduled to end in a few weeks. Still, Garcia said he isn't
giving up hope that something can be done to keep the camps alive. "I'm spending all
day, every day, talking with other groups trying to find a way to combine this with their
programs. Anything to keep this place open," he said. After all, he noted, Hope is
the name of his center.
California Drug Users Get Treatment, Not Jail
William Booth, Washington Post- 8/13/2001
LOS ANGELES -- In a dreary courtroom at the end of the hall, Crystal Davis shuffled her
slippered feet, rearranged her shackles and mumbled to the judge, "Yes, your
honor," as she pleaded guilty to possession of 0.02 grams -- a crumb -- of cocaine.
In a few hours, Davis would be free from county jail. Whether she would be freed from the
drugs that have brought havoc to her life is unknown. But instead of serving months or
years behind bars, the 29-year-old crack cocaine user would be ordered to attend five to
10 hours a week of group therapy, individual counseling and 12-step study classes.
California, known for its strict three-strikes penalties and its prison
construction spree, has made a U-turn in the war on drugs. The felons are now patients.
Despite widespread opposition by the state's political leadership, voters last year passed
Proposition 36, and starting July 1, all people convicted of simple drug use or drug
possession -- even for the hardest substances, such as heroin and cocaine -- were no
longer sent to jail, but instead had to be released and offered drug treatment. It is
estimated that 36,000 drug users a year -- and perhaps many, many more -- will be diverted
from jail to treatment, enough to delay the construction of at least two new state
prisons. The money saved on incarceration will be spent on rehabilitation, making dollars
available for the first time for treatment on demand -- about $120 million a year.
Although drugs have certainly not been legalized in California, drug
users have essentially been decriminalized. With the exception of Arizona, which passed a
similar measure requiring treatment instead of jail in 1998, no state has more lenient
drug use and drug possession laws than California. While other states and cities have
adopted "drug courts," where some drug offenders are diverted from jail to
treatment, the California experiment is being played out on a grand scale. "It's a
complete revolution," said Dave Fratello, one of the authors of Proposition 36.
"We've changed the way drug abusers are seen by the system. Before, some people got
some treatment. Now, everybody gets treatment, even the most hopeless cases." Los
Angeles Superior Court Judge Michael Tynan agrees: The system has been profoundly altered.
"People who went to jail or prison last month are now going back into the community
and hopefully into drug treatment," he said in an interview in July. "The people
have spoken. They wanted us to try something else."
Outside a courtroom recently, a drug defendant who had just begun
treatment under Proposition 36 and who asked that his name not be used, was enthusiastic
about the new law, but also realistic. "For me? I've used on and off for 10
years," said the cocaine abuser in his thirties, who said he worked as a mechanic.
"I've been sober and then I used again. I can stay clean. But some of these other
people? They're junkies, man, and crack heads, they live on the streets, and nobody is
going to take their drugs away." Then he hesitated. "But you know? Maybe they
might clean up their act. They deserve a chance, and it's not any worse than sending them
to prison."
No one knows how successful Crystal Davis or any of the other tens of
thousands of convicted drug users will be. Critics of Proposition 36 worry that the
already overtaxed criminal justice system and community treatment centers will be
overwhelmed, that committed addicts will resist help and abuse their freedom, and that not
nearly enough money has been appropriated for such things as drug testing or residential
treatment, which some hard-core users might need. The experiment will be closely watched,
as the backers of Proposition 36 are currently polling and working to put similar
proposals before the voters in Florida, Ohio, Michigan and Missouri. Support for the drug
reform measures has come from three wealthy men: financier George Soros, University of
Phoenix founder John Sperling and insurer Peter Lewis.
An early examination of the implementation of Proposition 36 in Los
Angeles, which has the largest addicted population in the state, is revealing. Crystal
Davis was arrested for possessing cocaine while she was on probation for an earlier drug
conviction, the possession of a crack pipe. A presentence report written by the probation
office before Proposition 36 took effect recommended that Davis, who has a long criminal
record of drug charges, be sent to state prison. Her attorney, public defender John Alan,
assumed that before Proposition 36, his client would have been sentenced to a minimum of
six months in county jail. "She probably would not have gotten the maximum, but you
never know," Alan said.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Commissioner Ronald Rose, who
presided over her case, said later that a defendant such as Davis, with a long history of
drug convictions and a demonstrated unwillingness to pursue treatment, would have
definitely gotten county jail time, perhaps even a year or two in prison. "I believe
you can stop using drugs," Rose told her at her hearing. "It's going to be a
very, very difficult thing. But you can do it, and we are here to help you." Rose
ordered Davis and two other drug defendants, who were all shackled together, to appear at
the Homeless Health Care center near downtown Los Angeles within 24 hours to meet with
their probation officer and undergo evaluation to decide the appropriate level of
treatment. Davis will be on probation for three years and will likely be ordered, after
evaluations, to undergo outpatient drug treatment for nine months. "All three of you
are going to be released," Rose said. "The odds are that one of you isn't going
to make it, and then you'll be going to state prison." And then they were led away by
the bailiff, due back in court in three weeks to have their progress evaluated.
A report done for the California legislature last year estimated that a
total of 36,000 people would be diverted from jails to treatment each year under
Proposition 36. But that number might prove to be conservative. In Los Angeles, a task
force assembled to implement Proposition 36 estimated that 14,000 to 20,000 offenders in
Los Angeles County alone would be eligible for treatment. To handle this volume, the
county arranged for 18 judges to hear nothing but Proposition 36 cases. Defendants who are
deemed eligible -- meaning they have not committed any violent crimes in the last five
years -- and who plead guilty or are convicted of drug use or possession, are released and
placed on probation, usually for three years.
Their first step is to attend a Community Assessment Service Center,
like Homeless Health Care or Tarzana Treatment Center. "I sit down with them, explain
how it works and then off they go," said probation officer Ray Causly, who works at
Tarzana. "After that, my contact with them is minimal." From there, they move
down the hall into a treatment program. Before Proposition 36, Causly would meet with drug
offenders on probation three or four times a month. "Now, that's all handled by
counselors," he said. Asked whether he thought the new approach, described by a
probation official as "kinder and gentler," would work, Causly said, "I
give it a 50-50 chance. What we've done is decriminalize the individual, offer them help,
and then step back and let treatment do its thing, and see if it works."
In the past, some offenders were sent to drug courts, which offered
treatment instead of jail time. The success rate was high in Los Angeles, with as many as
seven of 10 abusers completing their programs and staying clean. But the number of people
who went through drug court was small -- only about 5 percent of the eligible drug
defendants in Los Angeles -- and preselected for potential success by judges and
prosecutors. Now, everybody is offered treatment -- even users with dozens of drug
arrests. Some judges and prosecutors worry that the toughest addicts will simply refuse
treatment.
At the Tarzana center, counselor Monica Weil is the first person the
Proposition 36 clients see after the probation officer. She administers a standard test,
the Addiction Severity Index, which measures how much treatment a client should have. An
occasional cocaine user, who has a job and a supportive environment, would be classified
as a Level One. Weil estimates that about 80 percent of the Proposition 36 clients would
be Level Ones. A crack addict living on the streets, with multiple arrests and perhaps a
psychiatric disorder as well, would be considered a Level Three. Treatment for a Level One
would entail four or five one-hour meetings a week for three months, while treatment for
Level Three addicts might include several days of detoxification, followed by a month of
residential treatment and then 10 hours of meetings a week for nine months.
There was widespread concern before Proposition 36 became law that the
existing treatment centers would be overwhelmed, but that has not been the case in Los
Angeles. The centers are busier, and they are scrambling to hire more counselors, but they
are managing their growing caseload. If the convicted users fail to stay sober, and
stumble in their recovery, the court gives them another chance. If they fail again? They
are given yet another chance. On their third strike, they can be sent to jail or prison.
"There is still a carrot and a stick," probation officer Causly said. "It
just takes a lot longer before we pull out the stick." Crucial to the treatment, say
the judges, probation officers and many counselors, is money for repeated, random drug
testing -- funds that have not yet been appropriated.
"Trust only takes you so far. Then you want to test them. A
lot," said Ken Bachrach, clinical director at the Tarzana Treatment Center.
"That is what this program is. Treatment. Treatment takes time. People screw up. They
fail. They try again. The public should understand. They need to be patient. Because this
is addiction we're talking about."
Mark Epstein Introduces Buddha to Sigmund Freud
Connie Lauerman, Chicago Tribune- 8/12/2001
Like most psychiatrists of a certain age, Dr. Mark Epstein was steeped in Freudian
psychoanalytic theory during his residency training. But well before that, as a freshman
at Harvard, he had encountered Buddhism in a course on world religions, and that was the
major influence on the kind of therapist he would become. "What Buddhism actually did
was give me courage in terms of being a therapist," said Epstein, who practices in
New York. "For all the lip service they pay to it, [psychiatry programs] actually
don't train you very well or very much in how to actually be with another person as a
therapist. "All of a sudden you've got the doctor's coat on and you're the
psychiatrist and they give you a patient and you take him in a room and you do therapy.
You're alone. They never really tell you what to do."
Epstein had studied Buddhism intensely, attending a sort of Buddhist
summer school at Naropa Institute in Boulder, Colo., after his sophomore year. There he
encountered Ram ("Be Here Now") Dass and later such influential Western teachers
of Buddhism as Jack Kornfield and Joseph Goldstein. It made more sense to him, he said,
than "the psychoanalytic stuff." Meditation, he said, during a visit to Chicago,
"is so deceptively simple. You struggle just to keep your mind on your breath. And in
trying to keep your mind on your breath, your world is intruding and you have to pay
attention to that. So there's no room for pushing away parts of the self or trying to
reinforce other parts of the self. It's just all there. Later, in therapy, I found the
same kind of experience."
Epstein, 47, a soft-spoken man with hair just going gray who dresses
with tailored Zen simplicity, grew up in a suburb of New Haven, Conn. His father was a
physician, an internist with a specialty in kidney disease, who taught at Yale and went on
to become a chairman of the department of medicine at Harvard. "My family wanted me
to be a doctor," Epstein said. "My father loved his work. He loved it the way my
wife, an artist, loves art. I think he wanted me to be as happy as he was. He used to take
me to the hospital with him." Growing up, Epstein, an introspective boy who liked
reading, bicycle riding and sports, didn't know exactly what he wanted to do. In 7th grade
he joined his classmates in forming "The Tuli Kupferberg Fan Club," named for a
member of an East Village band, an outgrowth of the Beat literary movement, called the
Fugs. He especially like the group's "nothing song," which was inspired by Zen
Buddhism's' Heart Sutra. It had a chorus something like "Monday, nothing, Tuesday
nothing, Wednesday, Thursday nothing. . . . "
As a teenager, he was attracted to the writings of Eugene Ionesco and
Samuel Beckett and the theater of the absurd. He said Paul Goodman's "Growing Up
Absurd," a book that looked at the problems of youth in the "organized
system" of modern American life, "really spoke to me. I didn't know Paul Goodman
was a Gestalt therapist. I only knew he was a sociologist. "[At the time] I felt a
psychological emptiness--some combination of personal unworthiness, yearning, lack of
meaning and mostly insecurity over [my] ability to love. Goodman's book and the theater of
the absurd gave me a frame."
During that period, Epstein said, "I decided: `I know I'm a good
listener. Maybe whatever being a therapist involves, maybe that's something I can
do.'" He also wanted to figure himself out. It is a journey Epstein describes at
length in his new book "Going on Being: Buddhism and the Way of Change"
(Broadway Books, $23.95), his third and most personal book on the blending of
psychotherapy and Eastern spirituality. The book amplifies the similarities Epstein finds
between Buddhism and psychotherapy and how he fuses them in the way he works with his
patients.
In Buddha, Epstein said, he found "the first great
psychologist," who put together a positive rather than a pathological approach.
"He articulated a science of mind, a psychology before there was psychology. He found
it in his own experience and then elaborated it conceptually as an explanation of anxiety,
fear and where it comes from." Epstein likes to recount a story about the
Buddha-to-be in his early days as a struggling ascetic, starving himself and trying to
understand the nature of existence.
"Then at the moment of maximum self-destruction," Epstein
said, "the Buddha had a memory, the only reported childhood memory in Eastern
thought. It was a memory of when he was a child, of spontaneously arising joy, while he
was sitting under a tree watching his father work in the field. "It made him question
his whole orientation. Where does pleasure come from? What he found is that it comes
spontaneously on its own from within. That's the message of Buddhism, that there's some
kind of latent capacity of joy that is inherent to who we are. That's not dependent on any
kinds of outside stimulation."
That view of humanity, so different from the psychoanalytic or
psychiatric view of man as inherently flawed, is what drew Epstein to the ancient Eastern
spiritual tradition. He is not alone. Other therapist-writers, including John Welwood, a
San Francisco clinical psychologist, and Richard N. Wolman ("Thinking with Your
Soul"), a clinical psychologist who has been on the faculty of Harvard Medical School
for more than 25 years, also have explored the interface of spiritual traditions and the
practice of psychology. While "there is still resistance on the part of a lot of
therapists and psychiatrists," Wolman said, "many more are willing to deal with
it. "[The establishment is] starting to open up. Research is being funded and people
listening more carefully when we talk about it. People's lives cannot be thoroughly
understood only in terms of the traditional psychodynamic language or theoretical
framework."
Still, Epstein, who once taught a course about Buddhism and
psychotherapy at a New York University psychoanalytic institute, believes the founder of
psychoanalysis, Sigmund Freud himself, had found meditation. "In his work as a
psychoanalyst, from his writings, I think he was clearly putting himself in a meditative
state, and that's where his insights would come from," Epstein said. "But he had
trouble articulating what he was doing in that state and communicating it to his
followers." Epstein also noted that Freud said very directly that therapists
"have to give impartial attention to everything there is to observe, not to hold on
and not to push away. It was completely a meditative state."
As a therapist, Epstein said he found an approach that puts less
emphasis on understanding and more of a focus on experiencing than he was ever taught in
his formal education. He tries to get his patients "to be in the present moment with
me. . . . I try as much as I can to put into practice what I've learned, which is to be
present, as present as I am able. Then I look to see what's in the way here, what's
keeping the person from meeting me in this moment." That is usually an issue that
brought them to therapy in the first place, he said, and it's often the shadow of the past
that's hanging over the present. "Change will happen naturally as we open to the
truth," he writes. "Although terrible and traumatic things may have occurred, it
is the individual's mind that perpetuates the suffering and that can be trained to
change."
As a psychotherapist, Epstein said, his approach requires making an
effort to "undercut his professional stance," in a way, so as not to lose the
person-to-person awareness that he said makes awareness so powerful. "A certain kind
of expertise develops where people's problems start to fit into patterns, and I think I've
seen it before," he said. "There's distancing in that kind of stance, and people
are very sensitive to that. It's alienating and it detracts from the immediacy of the
moment, which is where the healing comes from in therapy."
Researcher Looks at Treatment for Early Onset of Bulimia
Meghan Mutchler Deerin, Chicago Tribune- 8/12/2001
In her quest for beauty titles, Miss Lake Cook has been sharing an ugly secret. Lest
anyone get the idea that looks are everything, every aspiring beauty queen needs a
platform, but while Gina Coconato's competitors have been expounding on politically
correct causes from AIDS awareness to drunken-driving prevention, the young woman from
Schaumburg has been tackling a very personal issue: bulimia.
"I was bulimic from the time I was 13 till I was 16," said
Coconato, now a 20-year-old senior at Roosevelt University's Theater Conservatory of
Chicago and second runner-up in the Miss Illinois Pageant this summer. "I hid stashes
of food. I'd eat whole pizzas." At her lowest point, Coconato was throwing up five
times a day, bingeing as many as four times daily and regularly abusing diet pills and
laxatives. Her parents never had a clue-until she told them. "They had no reason to
suspect anything," Coconato said. "My grades were good, and I didn't look
sick."
Eating-disorder specialists suspect that many young bulimics are
disguising the illness into adulthood. "An awful lot are not telling you that they
really have had this eating disorder from a very early age, earlier than anyone
assumed," said Vivian Hanson Meehan, executive director of the National Association
of Anorexia Nervosa and Associated Disorders, based in Highland Park.
Bulimia is two to four times more common than anorexia but much easier
to hide because unlike anorexics, bulimics seldom become alarmingly thin, said
psychologist Daniel le Grange, director of the University of Chicago's eating-disorder
program and assistant psychiatry professor. Whereas an anorexic may be avoiding food to
stay abnormally thin, a bulimic may be bingeing on food, even in secret.
"So you have to be a bit of a detective," explained le
Grange, who recently launched one of the first and largest treatment studies of adolescent
bulimia. He faces the daunting task of recruiting 90 young bulimics to participate in the
five-year, $668,000 study funded by the National Institute of Mental Health. "We need
to make people more aware that bulimia is not just a late adolescent or early adulthood
illness," le Grange said. "If you catch someone soon after the onset, the
outcome is likely to be much better."
Bulimia nervosa was defined as a separate disease from anorexia nervosa
in 1979. Like anorexia, bulimia is largely a female disease. The illness is characterized
by frequent episodes of binge eating that are almost always followed by purging. Purging
can include vomiting, abusing laxatives and diuretics, exercising compulsively and
fasting. Often it starts the way Coconato's did, with a failed diet. Girls attempt to
adhere to a very strict diet, but the deprivation leads to intense physical cravings for
food, and they find themselves bingeing. Disgusted, they purge, vow once again to stick to
the diet, and the cycle repeats.
Coconato ended up going to her parents about it. "She had read
about it, so she knew what was going on," said her mother, Linda. "She did come
to us, and I was devastated to find out. We got involved, and she started working with the
different groups. Really that's how she got the majority of her help. I have to give
credit to the groups that are out there."
"We are dealing with a very scary illness, which, sadly, many
people view as self-inflicted or just as a fad, something you can get over yourself,"
le Grange explained. Instead, bulimia is a chronic and complex disorder. "There's a
great deal of damage," le Grange said. "Patients can lose their teeth, rupture
their esophagus. I've known patients who've died from [internal bleeding] when they've
ruptured their esophagus." Bulimia also can cause dehydration and damage to the
bowels, liver and kidney. It can induce electrolyte imbalance, which can result in
irregular heartbeat and sometimes cardiac arrest. "Compared to other eating
disorders, adolescent bulimics are typically more depressed, have lower self-esteem"
and are more likely to be suicidal, le Grange said.
Most studies indicate that 2 percent to 5 percent of 15- to 19-year-old
girls are bulimic. About to .5 to 1 percent of girls in the same age group are anorexic.
But while the anorexics are likely to get treatment when they're young, most bulimics
struggle with the disease for six years before seeking treatment. "The mean age of
onset for bulimia is 18, but a lot of the cases clearly have an adolescent onset,"
said Jim Mitchell, president of the Academy for Eating Disorders, the largest
international organization of eating-disorders professionals.
In the absence of a national study, no one has a clear idea of how many
younger teens and even preteens are bulimic, Mitchell said, but there is anecdotal
evidence that it's striking girls earlier. "Most of us think it's happening
earlier," said Mitchell, who also is a professor and chairman of the neuroscience
department at the University of North Dakota Medical School. "We know that by the
time kids start school, there's already a strong bias against obesity, and it could be
that these sorts of cultural messages are just reaching girls at younger ages." But
because bulimics typically wait years before getting treated, little is known about how to
treat adolescent bulimics.
Le Grange's study will examine the effectiveness of family therapy in
treating adolescent bulimia, because some studies suggest that the method is more
effective than individual therapy for treating adolescent anorexics. Family therapy
reverses starvation in 60-70 percent of adolescent anorexics, said le Grange, who
co-authored, "A Treatment Manual for Anorexia Nervosa, A Family-based Approach."
"That's pretty good outcome data given the seriousness of the illness," le
Grange said, adding that an estimated 18-20 percent of anorexics ultimately die of the
disease.
Family therapy emerged in adolescent anorexia treatment in the 1980s,
when most hospitals closed their inpatient eating-disorder units, le Grange said.
"Once health-management organizations decided [inpatient] treatment was too
expensive, there was quite a dilemma of how to treat anorexics," le Grange said.
"Family therapy became a very viable alternative." In family therapy,
parents are coached to do exactly what nurses at inpatient clinics once did. "Mom and
Dad will make the choices about the type of food, the time to eat, and they don't engage
in debate and don't discuss with the anorexic the merits of what's on the plate," le
Grange said.
When family therapy is applied to bulimics, a little more vigilance may
be required, le Grange said. At first, the child may be very resistant and extremely angry
but is likely to be relieved. "I feel a lot better and a lot more confident,"
said 13-year-old Elizabeth Hanke, of Michigan City, Ind., whose family began seeing le
Grange after she was diagnosed with anorexia in the 7th grade. "I'm scared sometimes
that I think it's going to happen again, but then, I know it can't happen again because my
parents won't let it. They'll know what to do."
For help and information
- For information on participating in the University of Chicago Adolescent Bulimia
Treatment Study, call773-702-9277,orvisit http://psychiatry.uchicago.edu/research/volunteers/bulimia.html
- Other bulimia resources include The National Association of Anorexia Nervosa and
Associated Disorders (ANAD), Box 7, Highland Park, IL 60035. Call the hot line,
847-831-3438, or log on to the Web site, www.anad.org
for a listing of support groups and referrals in your area.
- Anorexia Nervosa and Related Eating Disorders Inc. can be contacted through www.anred.com
Study: Kids Show Effects Before the Divorce
Ascribe News Service- 8/12/2001
COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Many of the problems seen in adolescents of divorced parents are
evident before the divorce is final, according to a new nationwide study. The study showed
that even about a year before the divorce, children of divorced parents showed more
academic, psychological and behavioral problems than children whose parents remained
married. Moreover, many of these problems were not much worse after the divorce than they
were a year before the breakup, results showed. "Divorce is a process, not just
a single incident in these children's lives," said Yongmin Sun, author of the study
and assistant professor of sociology at Ohio State University's Mansfield campus.
"The negative effects that we associate with divorce are actually evident in teens at
least one year before the marriage has ended."
The study appeared in a recent issue of the Journal of Marriage and
Family. Data for this study came from the National Education Longitudinal Study, which
surveyed thousands of students beginning in 8th grade in 1988. Sun's study involved 10,088
students who were surveyed in 1990 and again in 1992. Between these two waves of data
collection, 798 of the children experienced the divorce of their parents. Sun examined how
the children fared before and after the divorce in four broad areas: academic progress,
psychological well-being, school behavior and substance abuse. In addition, the study
looked at the extent of family dysfunction both before and after divorce. The results
showed that in every indicator of academic progress, psychological well-being and behavior
problems, children showed maladjustment even before the divorce of their parents. This was
true even after various demographic controls were taken into consideration. For example,
on average, students whose parents would later divorce scored lower on both math and
reading tests than did students whose parents would stay together. They also showed more
behavior problems in school and a less-positive self-concept.
"It's not accurate to say divorce doesn't matter at all, but it is
true that much of the damage to adolescents has already occurred before the divorce,"
Sun said. Sun said that many of the problems children of divorce face may be caused by the
poor family environment that existed before the parents split up. For example, children of
pre-divorced parents were less likely to report having a good relationship with their
parents than did children whose parents would stay together. Parents who would later
divorce also attended fewer school events and were less likely to do things or discuss
school-related issues with their children. All of these factors were associated with lower
well-being in their children, Sun said.
In addition, while several previous studies concluded that divorce
affects boys more than girls, Sun said these results suggest girls are equally vulnerable.
One reason may be that most previous studies have focused on younger children, while this
study involved children with an average age of 16 at the time of the divorce.
"Adolescents may react differently to divorce than do younger children," Sun
said. Sun cautioned that the results of the study don't mean that the actual divorce
itself does not affect adolescents. This study only looked at teens about one year before
and one year after divorce. Sun is working with a collaborator on a study that will
examine children both further before and further after the divorce of their parents to see
if more effects become evident. |