Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, February
19-23, 2004
Critics Unjustly Criticize Electroconvulsive Therapy
Daniel Maixner & David Knesper, Ann Arbor News- 2/19/2004
In recent weeks the Ann Arbor News has published two articles regarding
electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). One was published on Jan. 1 and appeared
in the editorial section. There, Larry Allen objected strongly to
court-ordered ECT. The other was a syndicated article from the Los
Angeles Times, which ran Dec. 17, that was opposed to the use of ECT
as a treatment for any psychiatric illness. At this time, we want
to educate the public about the paramount importance of ECT for the
treatment of serious mental illness.
Our perspective is clear. We are physicians
caring for people with some of the most serious and treatment-resistant
forms of mental illness: depression, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia
are examples. What is not clear in Allen's piece is his affiliation.
Allen's article does mention that he is the Michigan director of the
Citizen's Commission on Human Rights, but it does not indicate that
his group was formed by the Church of Scientology in 1969 and that
both groups have a history of antagonism toward ECT and psychiatry's
biological approaches to treatment. On its Web site, CCHR features
an exhibit titled "Psychiatry Kills"; this exhibit is front
and center in its Los Angeles headquarters. CCHR publishes material
stating "Electroconvulsive Therapy - Pain and Fraud in the Name
of Therapy."
Readers need to be aware that anti-psychiatry
groups exist and that their advocates do not necessarily disclose
their biases. ECT is not (even if court-ordered in rare cases) a cruel
procedure used by conniving physicians conspiring with the legal system
to harm patients. We also do not use ECT for "bad behavior,"
as insinuated by Allen.
What exactly is ECT? A brief electrical
pulse is applied (usually two to three times a week for a total of
six to 12 treatments) to the scalp, inducing a brief seizure while
the patient is under anesthesia. ECT reverses the course of severe
mental illness. ECT is not violent or dramatic as portrayed often
in movies and popular culture. Patients are asleep and relaxed.
Like any medical procedure, ECT does
have certain risks. For example, there may be memory deficits during
the treatment period, and there is a variable loss of memory for recent
(two-to-six months before treatment) past events. In rare cases, patients
have amnesia for memories that go back farther than a few months.
For many people, memory is already impaired due to severe depression.
When the depression improves so does memory.
The risk of death is also cited often
by opponents as a major risk with ECT; however, the scientific literature
documents that ECT is extremely safe. The University of Michigan Medical
Center and most major academic medical centers administer ECT for
Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved purposes. Tens of thousands
of people each year receive ECT safely, including the elderly and
patients with serious medical problems. ECT is so safe that it is
now largely administered on an outpatient basis.
Patients benefit from ECT because it stops and reverses what otherwise
would be a protracted mental illness episode. Scientific evidence
finds that the longer someone experiences a severe episode of depression,
mania, or psychosis, the more likely that the illness may be resistant
to treatment and/or become chronic and incapacitating.
Who receives ECT? Each year, about 100,000
people in the U.S. receive ECT. The majority of cases are patients
with severe and disabling depression. This type of depression has
not responded to antidepressant medications or psychotherapy, has
persisted often for many months or years, has wreaked havoc in that
person's life, and decimated families. Others may be so severely depressed,
psychotic, or manic that they shut down totally. They stop eating,
become unresponsive, and are at risk for death. In the most severe
medical situations, the person is so confused and incompetent that
a family member must serve as legal guardian and consent to ECT when
it is medically necessary.
In rare cases, physicians will ask the
probate court to order treatment. The Michigan Mental Health Code
allows this specifically. Although Allen highlighted two cases in
the last four years where court-ordered ECT was vacated by an appeals
process, those decisions are unrelated to the medical appropriateness
of the recommendation for ECT. When a person is judged to be a danger
to himself or herself or to others, and suffers from a severe mental
illness, the Michigan Mental Health Code allows the probate court
to order the administration of medications or ECT A pure Libertarian
viewpoint would find court-ordered treatment of any kind to be an
atrocity. But these same libertarians are also advocating letting
people suffer, and allowing people to commit suicide even though their
illnesses would respond to and improve with readily available medical
treatments. If a family has a loved one who is so delirious and disorganized
that he or she refuses life-saving antibiotics, the family would surely
insist that their bacteria-ravaged loved one receive antibiotics.
The same consideration must be given to someone who has a brain illness.
ECT has been used for 65 years, and
the reason ECT does not disappear is because it works. Patients recover
from severe illness. ECT saves lives and drives symptoms of mental
illness into remission. For a very few critics, ECT is a punishment
for misbehavior and a negative means to force behavior changes. This
is ridiculous. If the general public could see the dramatic improvements
in people's lives that we witness everyday, its stigmatized view of
ECT would evaporate.
Daniel F. Maixner is director of the ECT Program and David J. Knesper
is director of the Hospital and Community Psychiatry Section in the
Department of Psychiatry at the University of Michigan.
Livingston County Mental Health Services Demand Growing
Lisa Carolin, Ann Arbor News- 2/20/2004
When Angus "Mac" Miller came to work for Community Mental
Health in Livingston County in 1977, the population of the county
was 65,000. Today the population has more than doubled and growth
has turned the county substantially more suburban than rural. Miller
also has seen the services his agency provides mushroom along with
his budget. "In 1977, we had 20 employees, a $1.5 million budget,
and we provided outpatient services primarily," says Miller.
"Now we have 200 employees and a budget in excess of $16 million.
We do outpatient care, case management, residential services, psychiatric
hospitalizations, and manage the majority of Medicaid-funded mental
health services. The demand is higher, our services are broader, and
the finances are more complex."
"Before John F. Kennedy was president,
private mental health care facilities were just for people with money.
Everyone else went to state facilities, and the length of stay was
measured in years."
Miller says that in 1987, a full management concept was adopted in
the county, which meant accepting responsibility for Livingston County
clients anywhere in the state system. Mental health services became
more available in the communities where people lived. People were
able to move out of state hospitals and back into their communities.
Mental health patients now live more independently. Some get medication
services at their homes, and others with developmental disabilities
can live in group homes that specialize in adult foster care. There
is a facility called the Clubhouse in Fowlerville where disabled people
can build employment skills and engage in social activities. "We
now provide more support in the community," says Miller. "The
key is that you have to carry through with good support services and
good housing."
Why the increase in the number of people
diagnosed with developmental disabilities? Miller said that more people
and many more children are diagnosed now because health professionals
are better at identifying disabilities and there's not as much stigma
so more people come forward and seek help. He says treatment comes
after a problem has occurred and a condition has been diagnosed. "We
try to provide prevention services," says Miller. " A child's
success in school can predict criminal behavior. We need to intervene
early in childhood whether it's with the family setting or the child
himself."
Miller says that the Parent-Infant Program
has met with a lot of success. Families are referred to the program
by doctors and social workers. Problems range from post-partum depression
and problems in the bonding process to profound emotional development
problems of the child.
Miller was almost born into his profession. Both of his parents were
social workers who worked in state hospitals. He also had a great-uncle
who was a patient at the state hospital in Pontiac. He received a
bachelor's degree in psychology from Kalamazoo College and a master's
degree in social work from the University of Michigan. From 1973-77,
Miller worked at Kalamazoo State Hospital on and off as a psychologist
and social worker. "The job was rewarding and challenging and
discouraging," says Miller. "There were adults at the hospital
who had been there for 15 years and had burned all their bridges.
The hospital was their life, and it was difficult to be helpful. The
adolescents in the children's unit were remarkable. They had profound
problems but were open to intervention. I wanted to work with people
who were still in the community and had family, friends and assets."
One of the most rewarding parts of his
job is having people who were in state hospitals now working in Livingston
County. Miller began working for Community Mental Health in Livingston
County in 1977 as an outpatient therapist for adults and kids. He
also married his Iranian-born wife, Mandana, that year. The two met
at U-M's School of Social Work. Mandana ran a shelter home for the
county and now owns Heirloom Oriental Rugs in Brighton.
In 1982, Miller became the program director
supervising outpatient services and emergency services. He was hired
by the Community Mental Health Board as executive director in 1986.
The board is made up of 12 members, including at least three who have
been consumers of mental health services themselves or who have a
family member who has.
Probate Judge Susan L. Reck, a former
CMH board member, says Miller has been instrumental in starting the
county's human services collaborative body and "getting agreements
among agencies that result in pooled funding" which has improved
the lives of people living in the county. Miller wants to see society
less focused on repair and more focused on preventive maintenance.
He says that too often people identify the illness more than the person.
"Part of my passion for community mental health relates to the
fact that there should be a life for everybody in this community,
and Livingston County should embrace all of its residents and help
them to find a meaningful life."
Jeanette Freeland, administrative analyst
at the Family Independence Agency, has worked with Miller and CMH
for many years. "He is a remarkable man, an absolute delight
to work with, and he has a rare combination of qualities. He is incredibly
optimistic but very practical and attuned to good business practices.
He can find a strength or a positive in just about any situation.
His mantra is to always assume positive intent."
Community Mental Health Services of
Livingston County is at 2280 E. Grand River Ave., in the county's
east complex in Genoa Township. Visit or call the center at (517)
546-4126. Starting this week, a family and community training series
is being offered for 10 weekly sessions on Wednesdays from 6 p.m.-7:30
p.m. at the CMH building. There is no cost and the purpose is to provide
education and support to families who are struggling to deal with
mental illness.
Illinois Mental Health Experts Wary of Losing Center
Karen Mellen & Stanley Ziemba, Chicago Tribune- 2/20/2004
A day after the governor announced plans to close the state mental
health center in Tinley Park, officials said they have just begun
planning how to move patients out of the 140-bed facility. Advocates
for the mentally ill, who have long complained that the stigma of
the illness makes mental health services the stepchild of the health-care
system, said Thursday they are concerned that the move by Gov. Rod
Blagojevich will strain an already stretched system.
Others said they will reserve judgment
until they see what the Department of Human Services suggests will
take the place of Tinley Park Mental Health Center. According to the
governor's plan, the center would receive $23.8 million to operate
during fiscal 2005 and then close in mid-2005. "The danger here
is, we've had state closings where no money was transferred into the
community," said Frank Anselmo, head of Community Behavioral
Health Care Association, a Springfield-based trade association for
community providers. "If it's done poorly, it turns into tragedy.
If it's done properly, it's something everybody can support."
About one-third of the patients at
the Tinley Park center have been there more than a year. One patient
has lived there more than 30 years. Patients requiring lengthy stays
would be transferred to other state hospitals, officials said. The
average stay for patients discharged in 2003 was 22 days, and mental
health experts say new drugs to treat depression, bipolar disorder
and other conditions mean more people can live in the community.
To that end, patients could be offered
counseling, crisis intervention, affordable housing and other support
services, said Tracey Scruggs, spokeswoman for the Department of Human
Services. She could not provide a plan or the cost, saying that state
officials would reach out to providers and advocacy groups before
deciding anything. Part of the arrangements could include contracting
with local hospitals to provide in-patient care for the mostly indigent
state patients, Scruggs said.
But John Rowley, vice president of
the south-suburban branch of National Alliance for the Mentally Ill,
said there already is a shortage of psychiatric hospital beds in the
area. Having a hospital devoted to patients with mental illnesses
was a great resource for many, from police officers who would pick
someone up to local hospitals with no psychiatric units. "There
has to be a place for people to go," Rowley said.
Suzanne Andriukaitis, executive director
of NAMI of Greater Chicago, said she was frustrated because the governor
made a decision on closing the facility with no plan for how to ensure
patients will receive care. She said without support services, there
could be other costs to society from people who do not receive adequate
treatment. "I'd like to go down to the governor and say, `Do
you know what you're doing here, buddy? You're going to have to spend
a lot more money on public services, police, fire, jails, prison,'"
she said.
The Tinley Park center has about 300
employees. State officials said the employees would be offered transfers.
The hospital's capacity has been shrinking almost from its beginning.
It was originally designed to be the state's main geriatric psychiatric
institution, but the $35 million, 3,000-bed giant officials planned
never materialized. When the center opened in 1958 on the northwest
corner of Harlem Avenue and 183rd Street, it had 480 beds. By the
early 1990s, as more community-based services and agencies were established,
the number of patients was halved to about 250. In 1982 the state
scrapped plans to house up to 150 criminally insane patients at the
center because of "strong community opposition."
When the state began closing some mental
health institutions in 1997, Tinley Park officials began eyeing the
hospital land near the Harlem Avenue interchange with Interstate Highway
80 and the Tinley Park Convention Center, which is considered a prime
spot. In 1999 the village acquired 54 acres of state land on the west
end of the hospital site in exchange for about $1 million worth of
discounts on water and sewer fees at the mental health center. The
village used the land to expand the parking lot for the Tinley Park
Metra Station and for a new library.
In the last two years, the village
has approached the state several times about selling a large chunk
of the land to ease state budget woes, Mayor Edward Zabrocki said.
The village, he said, envisions commercial and residential development
there. "We're looking at this as a positive step by the governor,"
Zabrocki said. "If this recommendation flies, it will definitely
enhance that corner and the entire area. Development would also produce
more tax dollars for our community and the state."
Researcher Says Children Need a Pat on the Back
Daniela Lamas, Knight Ridder News Service- 2/20/2004
Imagine going though the day without touch, without a casual hug,
pat on the shoulder or even a handshake. This would be lonely. It
might even be harmful, particularly for children. A growing body of
research suggests that American children and adolescents are dangerously
touch-deprived.
"It's a very serious problem. If monkeys are deprived of touch,
they kill each other," said Tiffany Field, who directs the University
of Miami's Touch Research Institute. The institute's studies have
shown touch can reduce pain and stress hormones, alleviate symptoms
of depression and help premature infants gain weight, among other
benefits.
But psychologists and school counselors
say that, particularly with today's pervasive sexual abuse accusations,
there are significant barriers to a large-scale shift in how Americans
view touch.
"I think parents really need to make sure kids are getting some
touch, a back rub before they go to bed or while they're doing their
homework," Field said. "Even for adolescents -- they love
their heads being rubbed, their backs being rubbed. It doesn't have
to be anything more."
One repercussion of the lack of human
touch could be increased aggression, Field says.
Anthropological studies have documented that primitive cultures with
less affectionate touch are more violent than geographically close
cultures with more touching. With this premise, Field traveled to
France, which has one of the lowest rates of adolescent male homicide.
She observed preschool children on playgrounds with their parents
and friends both in France and in Miami, and found that U.S. children
touched less and were more aggressive. The preschoolers in Miami grabbed
toys from their peers twice as often as the French children and quarreled
more than seven times as much, while their parents touched them three
times less frequently.
And while this study doesn't prove that
lack of touch increases aggression, Field said, monkey studies suggest
one possible way this link might work. Monkeys who have been deprived
of touch have shown a drop in the level of serotonin, she wrote. Their
levels of cortisol increase, which makes them more agitated and aggressive.
At the same time, massage therapy has been shown to lower the level
of cortisol and increase the level of serotonin -- hence, a relationship
between increased touch and decreased aggression. Field has studied
teacher touching in classrooms, and she found that the amount of touching
decreased as the children grew from infant to toddler to preschool
age while the childrens' aggressive behaviors increased.
Addiction Medication Has a Slow Start in the U.S.
Daniel Costello, Los Angeles Times- 2/20/2004
An addiction medication heralded as a breakthrough because doctors
can dispense it in their offices has failed so far to generate much
enthusiasm among the nation's doctors. The tepid reaction to buprenorphine
has disappointed some doctors and patient advocates who believe that
the drug has the potential to coax reluctant addicts into treatment.
The drug received federal approval more than a year ago.
Buprenorphine is an opiate substitute
and can be used by people addicted to heroin, prescription painkillers
such as Vicodin and OxyContin, and other opiates. It is the first
of the addiction medications doctors could begin dispensing in their
offices during the next few years. Prescription medications for alcohol
and cocaine addicts are under development or are being reviewed by
the Food and Drug Administration.
According to the National Institute
for Drug Abuse, there are more than 1 million opiate addicts in the
United States and that number is rising. Some of the reasons include
the large number of Americans, from baby boomers to the elderly, who
are getting hooked on medication for chronic pain, as well as a growing
and illegal trade of narcotics on the Internet. "We're seeing
less interest than we expected, especially among primary care physicians,"
says Robert Lubran, director of the division of pharmacologic therapies
at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Only a few thousand addicts across
the country are using buprenorphine, according to estimates, a much
smaller number than expected before the drug's approval. By comparison,
France introduced the drug in 1995 and within four years had more
than 60,000 patients. One major reason is that France's public health
system is paying for the medication. Although a few U.S. insurers
cover the drug's $250-a-month cost, most private insurers and state
Medicaid programs for the poor, including California's Medi-Cal program,
are not paying for buprenorphine. In California, the number of doctors
who have signed up for the federal training required before they can
dispense the drug also is fewer than anticipated: about 200 physicians.
Last summer, a Boston University School
of Public Health survey of doctors who have undergone federal training
found that many physicians are facing hurdles in trying to dispense
the drug. Anara Guard, the researcher who oversaw the survey, says
many doctors reported that they couldn't get local pharmacies to stock
buprenorphine, because the stores didn't feel there was a big enough
demand or because they were apprehensive about having addicts as customers.
Many doctors also said they were troubled
by the idea of dispensing a narcotic to addicts and did not feel they
had the resources in their offices to deal with patients who might
be prone to volatile behavior. Doctors had been barred from dispensing
narcotics to addicts since Congress enacted the Harrison Narcotic
Law in 1914. Legislation passed by Congress in 2000 eased those rules.
Another problem, some doctors said, is that federal health officials
have set unreasonable limits on how many buprenorphine patients each
doctor can treat. The current statute limits physicians practicing
solo or in small or larger groups from treating more than 30 patients
at one time. The result is that single practitioners and large-scale
medical plans have the same limitations on the maximum number of patients
who can be treated. Kaiser Permanente, one of California's largest
health providers, with 7 million members statewide, says it has not
started dispensing the drug because the 30-patient limit would make
it impractical.
Sen. Orrin G. Hatch (R-Utah) recently
introduced a bill in Congress to exempt large group practices and
academic medical centers from the limit. "The regulations around
this drug are too cumbersome," says Dr. Judith Martin, an Oakland
family physician who recently began treating two patients with buprenorphine.
She says she is "extremely pleased" with the results so
far. Some large medical providers and members of Congress are lobbying
the health department to update the regulation. A spokesman for the
drug's manufacturer, Reckitt Benckiser Inc., says sales are "lower
than some original estimates" but that the company expects the
numbers to increase rapidly over the next year.
Research shows buprenorphine is safer
than other medications such as methadone. Buprenorphine appears to
lead to fewer overdoses, a major concern with any opiate or opiate
substitute, and patients appear to experience fewer relapses. Buprenorphine
is given on a short-term basis in detox centers or, more often, it's
used as a maintenance medication. The orange-colored pill is taken
daily by letting it dissolve under the patient's tongue. Unlike methadone,
buprenorphine does not produce a sense of being high. Because of that,
experts say the drug has a lower chance of being illegally sold on
the street, which happens with many treatment medications.
Still, the drug is not for everyone.
It may not work with hard-core addicts who need a more potent medication
to stave off severe withdrawal. And some primary care doctors unused
to treating addicts say buprenorphine patients present unexpected
challenges. Dr. Art Van Zee, of St. Charles, Va., a small Appalachian
town that Van Zee says has been "destroyed" by OxyContin
abuse, says he recently stopped writing 30-day prescriptions to new
patients and now insists they stop by his clinic every day. Several
addicts, he says, stopped taking the medication for weeks at a time
when on their own. Van Zee remains hopeful about the drug's potential.
"This is no magic bullet,'' he says, "but I am starting
to believe it's better than anything else we've got."
Lubran, of the Department of Health
and Human Services, says the federal government will be heavily promoting
buprenorphine during the next year by sponsoring more than 40 information
sessions for doctors across the country. This spring, the department
is sponsoring its first buprenorphine workshop in California for primary
care doctors as part of the American Academy of Family Physicians
annual conference in San Francisco.
Grain Allergy a Risk Factor for Schizophrenia, Study Says
Reuters News Service, 2/20/2004
LONDON -- Schizophrenia could be linked to an allergy to gluten, a
protein found in wheat and other grains, scientists said Friday. Gluten
intolerance, known as celiac disease, can erupt at any age but mostly
affects people between 30 and 45, often causing weight loss, diarrhea
and fatigue.
"A history of celiac disease is a risk factor for schizophrenia,"
the researchers wrote in an article for the British Medical Journal.
The scientists recommended a gluten-free diet to treat celiac disease
and said some clinical trials had shown that cutting out cereals also
alleviated symptoms of schizophrenia.
The study, a collaboration between
Johns Hopkins medical institutions and Denmark's Aarhus Universities
and Aarhus Psychiatric Hospital, tested 7,997 schizophrenic patients
in a Danish psychiatric unit. The scientists stressed that the result
reflected only a small proportion of cases since both diseases were
rare. Last year, a study found a link between parental age and schizophrenia.
Drug use has also been cited as a potential trigger for the mental
illness.
British Journal Regrets Vaccine-Autism Link Study
Associated Press, 2/21/2004
LONDON - A leading medical journal said Saturday it should not have
published a controversial 1998 study that claimed a link between childhood
vaccinations and autism. The editor of the Lancet, Dr. Richard Horton,
said Dr. Andrew Wakefield and a team of British scientists who conducted
the study on the triple measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine didn't
reveal that they were being paid by a legal aid service looking into
whether families could sue over the immunizations. Horton called it
a "fatal conflict of interest."
Wakefield's study suggested that the
MMR vaccine could put children at risk of autism a developmental disorder
often arising in the first few years of life and inflammatory bowel
disease.
The paper has since been discredited on scientific grounds, but some
parents have clung to the findings and health officials say that vaccinations
have fallen dangerously low since its publication.
Allegations to be published in The Sunday Times say Wakefield and
his team at the Royal Free Hospital were being paid by the Legal Services
Commission, a legal aid service which was considering whether families
could sue over children believed damaged by the MMR injection.
"In my view, if we had known the conflict of interest Dr. Wakefield
had in this work, I think that would have strongly affected the peer
reviewers about the credibility of this work, and in my judgment it
would have been rejected," Horton told the British Broadcasting
Corp. Wakefield defended his study in a statement to the editors of
The Lancet. "The clinical and pathological findings in these
children stand as reported," he said. "My colleagues and
I have acted at all times in the best medical interests of these children
and will continue to do so." The Legal Services Commission could
not be reached for comment.
The allegations have led to calls for
a public inquiry. Health Secretary John Reid said the General Medical
Council, the health industry's watchdog, plans to mount an investigation
"as a matter of urgency." Evan Harris, a lawmaker with the
opposition Liberal Democrat party and a member of Parliament's science
and technology committee, also called for an independent inquiry "given
the importance attached to the work of the Royal Free Hospital group
by the media in the MMR debate."
Lilly Warns of Zyprexa Risk for Elderly
Associated Pres, 2/21/2004
INDIANAPOLIS - Eli Lilly and Co. said it had warned doctors and psychiatrists
that elderly patients suffering from dementia face a higher risk of
stroke if they use the company's top-selling drug, the anti-psychotic
Zyprexa. Lilly made the warning in a letter sent nationwide on Jan.
15 based on findings from recent clinical trials of Zyprexa, Lilly
spokesman Dan Collins said Friday. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration
did not require the warning, he said. "We felt it was important
to be proactive in communicating this information about the increased
risk of stroke in elderly patients with dementia-related psychoses,"
Collins said.
That category of patients accounts for
about 2 percent of total Zyprexa sales, he said. Clinical trials conducted
to investigate whether to seek an FDA-approved indication for Zyprexa
to treat that category of patients found those taking Zyprexa were
more likely to suffer a stroke than those taking a placebo, Collins
said. The Zyprexa patients also had a higher risk of death from all
causes than those using a placebo.
Zyprexa is not approved for use in elderly
patients with dementia, although some doctors do use the drug on a
so-called "off-label" basis to help such patients get through
episodes of dementia.
Because of the test findings, Lilly will not seek FDA approval for
a Zyprexa indication to treat older patients with dementia, Collins
said.
Introduced in 1996, Zyprexa now accounts
for about a third of overall sales at Indianapolis-based Lilly, with
Zyprexa sales last year reaching $4.3 billion Recently, the drug has
come under competitive pressure because of the emergence of newer
rivals Geodon and Abilify. Zyprexa also is undergoing a patent challenge.
Lilly and generic companies that want to introduce generic knockoffs
of Zyprexa concluded a three-week bench trial in Indianapolis last
week, and a federal judge is expected to issue a ruling in coming
months. Industry analysts have said they expect Lilly to prevail.
On Friday, Lilly shares closed down 18 cents at $72.47 on the New
York Stock Exchange.
On the Net: Eli Lilly and Co. www.lilly.com
Gambling Addiction Nearly Tore a Family Apart
Sam Skolnik, Seattle Post-Intelligencer- 2/23/2004
DES MOINES -- Before he stepped into the Emerald Queen Casino in the
summer of 2000, Eli Bunch had gambled only a few times. Briefly in
Las Vegas in the late 1970s, when he lost about $20. Once, on a Caribbean
cruise a few years back, netting $50 -- "enough to do a lot of
laundry," he said. So Bunch, a former top manager at a prominent
local company, didn't think twice about taking a brief, diversionary
trip to "the boat," the casino on the Blair Waterway in
Tacoma run by the Puyallup Tribe. He won $300 that day playing electronic
slot machines. Days later, Bunch stopped in again. He hit it big,
winning $3,000 from a $20 investment. "I stood there handing
hundreds to my wife, and I was saying, 'All you've gotta do is go,
and they give you money,' " said Bunch, 50.
Those wins triggered the most devastating
period in Eli's and Jody Bunch's lives. Within three months, Eli Bunch
had lost his initial $3,000 winnings, and $3,000 more. He lost an
additional $50,000 over the next six months. He took money out of
his retirement fund and other investments. The tally through June
20, 2003 -- the day he quit gambling -- came to about $250,000. Because
of a consuming dependence on slot machines, blackjack and other games
of chance, he spent his savings, separated from his wife and nearly
lost his house before he stopped. Along the way, Bunch briefly moved
in with his elderly parents and "nearly destroyed" ties
with his two grown daughters.
In April, Bunch said, he and his employer -- a company where he had
built a 28-year career -- mutually agreed that he would leave, because
of a number of issues related to his gambling. "Gambling became
more important to me than my career, than relationships -- every relationship
I had that was important," Eli said. He even stole his wife's
credit card to quickly gin up gambling money.
Jody and Eli Bunch, who is now a defense
industry consultant, still live together. But they are legally separated.
"In my head, we are married," said Jody Bunch, 50, a secretary
for a construction management firm. "The legal separation, that's
a financial protection, and I'm not willing to undo that." Jody
Bunch said that in a fruitless effort to try to change her husband's
habits, she would set deadlines for Eli to return home from his gambling
binges before she locked him out by setting the burglar alarm. After
those late-night deadlines came and went, Jody said, "I would
set the alarm and leave a note on the front door saying, 'It's on,'
and he didn't care. He would just sleep in his car until morning."
At first, she found it difficult to
understand the power of gambling. "I never used to believe in
this whole 'addiction culture,' " she said. "I thought,
'Yeah, right, give me a break.' But, oh my goodness, I've learned
a lot. It's incredible the hold gambling gets on you." Eli Bunch
says he is recovering. He attends Gamblers Anonymous meetings, although
not as regularly as both he and his wife say he should. And the couple
has attended joint therapy for people with gambling problems and their
spouses. "It's like a grand chase, like you're a race-car driver,"
Eli Bunch said. "But you just don't ever want to get out of the
car -- whether you're ahead or behind."
To Get Help
Several resources are available for people who believe they have a
gambling problem or know someone who does:
Gamblers Anonymous: 206-361-8413, or toll-free at 877-727-5050. www.gamblersanonymous.org
Gam-Anon, for family and friends of problem gamblers: toll-free at
877-727-5050. www.gam-anon.org
University Program Helps Autistic Students
Associated Press, 2/23/2004
HUNTINGTON, W.Va. -- Lowell Austin and his uncle, Howard, had a special
bond. The man with the doctoral degree in artificial intelligence
from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the boy with Asperger's
Syndrome played ball together and roughhoused like friends. Lowell
is advanced in some areas and far behind his peers on others -- hallmarks
of his autism spectrum disorder that is characterized by normal intelligence
and language skills, but marked deficiencies in social and communication
abilities.
When Howard Austin died in April 2001,
his family wanted to create a memorial and turned to Marshall University.
The family's only connection to Marshall was they had heard about
its Autism Training Center and that it was in West Virginia. Howard
Austin and his siblings grew up in Athens, Mercer County. With a $50,000
contribution, the family asked the center to create a program that
could serve as a national model to help people with autism attend
college. The family would later add $25,000. ``Marshall had all the
parts of the puzzle,'' said Lowell's mother, Linda Austin. ``They
just hadn't put it all together.''
Although Lowell would become the program's
first student, his father said the donation was made with no strings
attached. ``There was no quid pro quo,'' said Larry Austin, an Alexandria,
Va., lawyer and banker. ``We were happy when he was accepted, but
it was not preordained. ``We wanted them to have the freedom to design
the program as they saw fit,'' he said.
What's been created since the 2002-03
school year is a program where Lowell and the two other students with
Asperger's Syndrome are supported, not coddled. They are required
to meet and maintain the university's academic standards. ``If I didn't
have the support, I wouldn't have been where I am right now,'' said
Lowell, a 19-year-old sophomore majoring in sports marketing.
No one knows how many college students have Asperger's Syndrome. Many
go undiagnosed or are simply perceived as ``a little bit strange,''
said Lars Perner, an assistant professor of marketing at San Diego
State University who has the disorder.
And no one knows how many people in
the general population have autism. Some studies suggest it might
affect at least 40 per 10,000 U.S. children. That is 10 times higher
than estimates a decade ago, which many scientists think reflects
better diagnosis. The exact cause is unknown, although both genetics
and environmental factors are suspected of playing a role. ``Some
of these students might be able to get into college because of fairly
strong academic credentials and a reasonable academic showing. That
may not mean they will be able to stay in college,'' said Perner,
author of a guide to selecting a college in a recent issue of ``Asperger's
Digest.''
As researchers learn more about autism
and public school services for autism improve, more autistic students
are graduating from high school academically prepared for college,
said Kim Ramsey, who directs Marshall's program. ``The problem is,
social and daily living issues are interfering.'' Marshall's program
offers tutoring, individual counseling, a space to take tests away
from distractions, help navigating the bureaucracy and social world
of college and a lounge to hang out. Once students learn how to manage
college life, they can use those skills to obtain and keep jobs. ``We
see ourselves as safety net,'' Ramsey said.
Lowell was the program's only student
its first year. His experience was such a success that two more students
were admitted this year: Andrew Reinhardt, 18, of Beckley and David
Fair, 23, of Weirton. Lowell and Andrew are now excelling. David is
having a more difficult time because, as he admits, he never studies.
Stephen Shore, who is finishing his
doctoral degree in special education at Boston University and has
been diagnosed with ``atypical development with strong autistic tendencies,''
said there is a need for programs like Marshall's. ``In some ways,
looking back on things, I realize now I made a lot of my own accommodations,''
said Shore, author of ``Beyond the Wall: Personal Experiences with
Autism and Asperger Syndrome.'' He asked for extensions on tests,
shared notes and bought notes from note taking services. People with
autism spectrum disorders ``have been going to school for years on
their own. ``I think they would do much better, there would be a much
higher rate of success if this type of program were available. It
is a needed thing,'' Shore said.
Marshall's program may expand up to
10 students, but it will remain small by choice. The goal is not for
all students with autism to attend Marshall, but for the program to
become a model for other colleges, said center Director Barbara Becker-Cottrill.
``The true goal is for students to have the ability to attend the
university of their choice. Our work will be working with other universities
on how to establish a program such as this on their own campuses.''
Marshall may begin doing that as early as this fall, she said.
The program has been a lifeline for
Lowell, his family says. ``I have seen such a growth in him, his confidence,
his ability to face a situation, ... his conversational skills,''
said his aunt, Ellen Austin Friend of Athens. He participates in clubs.
He is the equipment manager for Marshall's football team. He lives
in a dorm, without a roommate. ``Without the help, I wouldn't have
made it to college,'' Lowell said. ``I wouldn't have lived like a
normal student.''
Domestic Abuse Gets Attention of Washington Lawmakers
Jennifer Lloyd, Seattle Post-Intelligencer- 2/23/2004
OLYMPIA -- Bills dealing with domestic violence -- including measures
spurred by the murder-suicide involving Tacoma police Chief David
Brame -- are moving through the Legislature. The Senate endorsed two
bills focusing on domestic-violence issues, while the House passed
seven bills. Two companion measures stemming from Brame's fatal shooting
in April of his wife, Crystal, are top priorities. House Bill 2392
and its twin, Senate Bill 6161, would require law enforcement agencies
to adopt a model statewide policy or an individual policy for responding
to allegations of domestic violence by their employees. The Washington
Association of Sheriffs and Police Chiefs, along with representatives
from law enforcement agencies and victims' rights organizations, would
develop the model policy by Dec. 1. Agencies would have to adopt procedures
by June 1, 2005, and train every employee on the domestic-violence
protocol by June 30, 2006. The bills' sponsors, Rep. Pat Lantz, D-Gig
Harbor, and Sen. Debbie Regala, D-Tacoma, represent districts at the
epicenter of the Brame tragedy.
"For me, there has been a degree
of satisfaction that I took action and a positive step to make amends
for what happened in the parking lot of my grocery store last April,"
said Lantz, a member of the state's Task Force on Officer-Involved
Domestic Violence. "It is definitely a pioneering effort. No
other state has adopted statewide minimum standards."
On Thursday, the House Committee for
Juvenile Justice and Family Law heard testimony on the Senate bill,
a result of concern over the Brame incident. According to testimony
Thursday, law enforcement agencies should have a clear policy for
handling domestic-violence allegations against officers so that victims
know what to expect during a police investigation.
"In my case it was two whole months
before they contacted me. That's a whole lot of time to wonder if
they're investigating it, how they're investigating it, without talking
to me," Heidi Collins testified. Her husband, an officer with
an Eastside department, was charged last July with assaulting her.
He returned to work in January after receiving a "stipulated
order of continuance," not a guilty verdict, for a fourth-degree
assault charge in King County District Court. He must undergo domestic-violence
treatment. "This bill will eliminate a lot of the stress that
comes from not knowing what is going to happen next, when or if anything
is going to happen at all," Collins said.
According to the 2002 Statewide Domestic
Violence Comparison Report from the Washington Association of Sheriffs
and Police Chiefs, 13.6 percent of all offenses were domestic-violence
related. King County reported more than 11,000 domestic-violence offenses
that year. A lobbyist for the Washington Council of Police and Sheriffs
agreed that police departments should have a policy for dealing with
domestic violence in their ranks. "We think it's important that
all of our guilds have domestic violence policies," said Lee
Reaves, spokesman for the council's more than 4,700 members.
Both bills unanimously passed their
houses of origin. Also on Thursday, the Senate Judiciary Committee
heard testimony for another House bill regarding domestic violence.
House Bill 2398 would require that the courts notify the victim at
least five days before any hearing on changes in a protection order
against an offender.
Rep. Dave Upthegrove, D-Des Moines,
sponsored the bill after the Washington State Coalition Against Domestic
Violence brought to his attention several cases in which victims were
not notified of protection-order changes. "We had one case where
the petitioner had not known that her order had been changed and had
allowed the abuser to come to the home to pick up his things,"
said Grace Huang, the coalition's public policy coordinator.
The coalition discovered 12 cases in
which the petitioner did not receive notice that his or her protection
order had changed. Each year, the courts in Washington file about
18,000 protection orders and modify about 3,000 of those orders, according
to Huang. "The goal of the legislation is to make sure the victims
know when a protection order is being changed or modified," said
Upthegrove. "Current law doesn't have tight enough requirements
on serving notice."
Committee members raised concerns over
the amount of money required to enact this legislation. The estimated
cost is $170,000 to city and county governments through 2009. "I
think it's a great idea, but it's a huge fiscal impact on local governments
at this time," said Sen. Mary Margaret Haugen, D-Camano Island.
Judiciary Committee members will continue debating this issue next
week.
Other domestic-violence related bills this session:
**House Bill 2397 and Senate Bill 6384 would allow courts to impose
a penalty up to $100 on someone convicted of a domestic-violence crime.
The penalties would help pay for domestic-violence programs.
**House Bill 1949 would allow the court, during a protection-order
hearing, to require the accused to give temporary financial assistance
to the alleged victim.
**Police officers would be prohibited from bringing a weapon into
a court if the officer is there as a party in a harassment or domestic
violence case by House Bill 2473.
**House Bill 2481 would tack $10 onto marriage-license fees for domestic-violence
prevention programs.
**Victims of domestic violence, sexual assault or stalking will be
able to terminate housing rental agreements without paying future
months' rent if House Bill 1645 passes. Victims would still be obligated
to pay rent for the month they break the rental agreement.
Meth Lab Plague Spreading
Fox Butterfield, New York Times- 2/23/2004
BOONE, N.C., Feb. 20 Sandra Rupert, a counselor at an elementary
school in this town tucked high up in the Blue Ridge Mountains, wondered
last year about two sisters who were second and third graders. They
had headaches, colds and coughs virtually every day. Sheriff Mark
Shook found the explanation when he raided the children's home and
discovered their mother and her boyfriend were cooking methamphetamine
in the attic, next to where the girls slept. The girls were suffering
from the toxic fumes emitted by the methamphetamine cooking, said
Chad Slagle, a social worker with the Watauga County Child Protective
Services Unit. They were removed immediately from the house and taken
away from their mother. They had to leave without taking any of their
clothes or toys, Mr. Slagle said, for fear of further contamination.
The girls are among the young victims
as methamphetamine has crossed the Mississippi and moved to the East
Coast in the past few years. According to the Drug Enforcement Administration,
small methamphetamine laboratories, known as mom and pop labs, are
now being found in every state in the East. What makes the spread
particularly worrisome is new evidence that children living in homes
with laboratories face a health threat as hazardous as those who actually
use the drug.
A study released in January by the
National Jewish Medical and Research Center in Denver, which specializes
in respiratory illnesses, found that poisonous chemicals released
in the methamphetamine cooking process spread throughout buildings
where the cooking was being done. "The study showed that the
chemicals are everywhere in the house and that children living in
houses with meth labs might as well be taking the drug directly,"
said Michele Leonhart, the acting deputy administrator of the D.E.A.,
which helped finance the research.
Last year, 8,000 illegal methamphetamine
laboratories were seized nationwide, and 3,300 children were found
in them, according to D.E.A. figures. In addition, 48 children were
burned or injured and one was killed when methamphetamine laboratories
caught on fire or exploded, as they sometimes do, the agency's statistics
show. In Tennessee, which has the worst methamphetamine problem in
the Southeast, 697 children were removed from their parents' custody
and placed in foster homes over the past 18 months because they were
living in places with methamphetamine laboratories, said Carla Aaron,
a spokeswoman for the Tennessee Department of Children's Services.
About the same number were placed with relatives who were not cooking
methamphetamine, Ms. Aaron said.
Here in Boone, a town of 22,000 in
western North Carolina near the Tennessee border, 41 illegal methamphetamine
laboratories have been seized in the past two years, and 17 children
have been placed in foster homes or with other relatives, said Mr.
Slagle, the social worker. "We had heard about meth for years,
but it was always a West Coast problem," Mr. Slagle said. "So
we were completely surprised when it hit us here."
It is hard to compare the impact of
different drugs. But given the harm methamphetamine does to children
and the large amount of toxic waste cooking it creates five
pounds for every pound of methamphetamine some law enforcement
officials are now comparing the problem to the crack cocaine epidemic
in the nation's big cities in the 1980's. "Meth makes crack look
like child's play, both in terms of what it does to the body and how
hard it is to get off," said Capt. Richard P. Nuzzo of the New
York State Police. Mr. Nuzzo is a member of the New York State Contaminated
Crime Scene Emergency Response Team, which deals with methamphetamine.
The authorities in New York State found their first methamphetamine
laboratory only in 1999, Captain Nuzzo said. By last year the number
had climbed to 73, mostly upstate.
Methamphetamine is an artificial stimulant
that releases high levels of the neurotransmitter dopamine into the
brain, producing euphoria and great energy, often lasting up to 12
hours. But it also leads to paranoia, delusions and memory loss, and
over a period of time to physical decay like rotting teeth. There
is debate among experts about how treatable methamphetamine addiction
is. But most specialists believe it is one of the hardest to treat,
requiring that a patient stay in treatment for up to two years.
Cooking methamphetamine is an extremely
toxic process, said Dr. Andrew Mason, a forensic toxicologist who
lives in Boone. There are two common methods used in the mom and pop
laboratories, and they both produce dangerous gasses and leave hazardous
waste, Dr. Mason said. One method combines red phosphorous, usually
taken from the strips on matchboxes; pseudoephedrine, from cold tablets;
and iodine. The other method, more common in farming country, involves
anhydrous ammonia, a liquid fertilizer, cooked with pseudoephedrine
and lithium, taken from car batteries. "One out of every five
labs is discovered because of an explosion," Dr. Mason said.
"That alone ought to tell you something. If you heat the ingredients
too high, they spontaneously burst into flame."
Last Monday, a laboratory was discovered
when it blew up in a house down a hollow in the mountains just outside
Boone. The man doing the cooking had third-degree burns, Sheriff Shook
said. The red phosphorous method produces phosphine gas, which can
be lethal, Dr. Mason said. The ammonia method can produce a cloud
of ammonia gas, which is also extremely dangerous, he said. Last year,
six members of the volunteer fire department in Deep Gap, a neighboring
town, were injured when they put out a fire in a trailer where, unknown
to them, there was a methamphetamine laboratory. One of the men, Darien
South, 31, had his lungs burned so badly that he went into respiratory
arrest for four days. Mr. South said that as a result of his injuries,
he had lost his job as a truck driver for Coca-Cola and had so much
difficulty breathing that he had trouble performing his other job,
as a preacher in a Baptist church.
Sheriff Shook said he believed methamphetamine
first came into his county via truck drivers from Tennessee, who for
a price taught local people how to cook it. The local authorities
have improvised their response. Mr. Slagle said that in his first
case, he was investigating a family for domestic violence when Sheriff
Shook told him the parents had a laboratory he was going to raid.
"We were completely ignorant about the dangers, and when we took
the kids, we let them keep their clothes and stuffed animals, contaminating
our vehicles and contaminating the children further," Mr. Slagle
said.
By September last year, the county
had worked out a rigorous protocol. In a raid, the sheriff's deputies
found methamphetamine and its residue all over a house where the father
was cooking, so Mr. Slagle made the man's 15- and 16-year-old sons
take off their clothes and gave them new clothing. They were then
taken to the emergency room in the Boone hospital where a nurse dressed
in a "moon suit" decontaminated them, scrubbing them down
with a special solution and large brushes, "like a car wash,"
Mr. Slagle said.
One problem Sheriff Shook faces is
that North Carolina's current penalties for manufacturing methamphetamine
are light, the same as for growing one marijuana plant. A first-time
offender faces a maximum sentence of six to eight months in jail and
can get out on bond for as little as $1,000. "So they can be
back cooking before we finish the paperwork," Sheriff Shook said.
That was what happened in the case
of the two sisters. Their mother and her boyfriend were charged, but
were released on bail, and the grandmother, who was given custody
of the girls, secretly let them go back to their mother. In January,
the methamphetamine laboratory apparently started a fire behind the
house. When sheriff's deputies arrived, they found jars with chemical
residue from cooking methamphetamine in the kitchen sink along with
the family's dishes. The county will now move to terminate the mother's
parental rights and put the girls in a foster home, Mr. Slagle said.
Ms. Rupert, the school counselor, said, "The sad thing is that
these girls lost everything." After they were taken away the
first time, people volunteered to give them new toys and clothes.
This time, they had to leave those new possessions in the house. They
too were contaminated.
|