Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, November 17-23, 2005
Rosie Mestel, Los Angeles Times- 11/17/2005 "MOM, I'm not like that," 21-year-old Tom Iland told his mother as they watched a TV news report about a young man with Asperger's syndrome who killed two neighbors in Orange County. It was a poignant moment for 48-year-old Emily Iland. Her son, who also has Asperger's, was worried that others would think him capable of such violence. It wasn't just Tom. Since the shootings in Aliso Viejo, people with Asperger's syndrome and their families have been thinking, talking and e-mailing one another. They have been sharing their upset and fears — and brainstorming some practical steps to allay public fears and forestall such tragedies in the future. On Oct. 30, 19-year-old William Freund dressed in a paintball mask and cape, entered a neighboring house and killed Vernon Smith and his daughter Christina, 22, with a shotgun. He shot at others, too, before returning to his house and shooting himself. In the days afterward, it was revealed that Freund frequently posted in an online forum for people with Asperger's, a condition that causes profound gaps in the ability to read social nuances but is not generally associated with violence. Michael John Carley of New York City founded GRASP, a support group network for Asperger's syndrome and related conditions, in 2003. The shootings, he said, have galvanized his group's resolve to expand across the country. "I don't know enough about this young man to deduce if we would have been able to have an impact," he said. "Maybe there was some other diagnosis going on that we don't know about." Carley, 41, was diagnosed with Asperger's in 2000, along with his son, now 9. "It's a very lonely place if you have no sense of shared experience with somebody with similar wiring to yours," he said. People in the Asperger's community are not saying their disorder neatly explains the killings. In fact, some are upset that Freund's crime is being linked to Asperger's at all. "What bothers me is the implication that there's something about Asperger's syndrome that causes people to do this kind of thing — kind of, 'Look out for the dangerous Asperger people,' " said Jerry Newport, 57, who founded a Los Angeles support group for people with autism and Asperger's in 1993. He now lives in Tucson and travels frequently to speak on the topic. "The only connection you can make between Asperger's and what happened is that his Asperger's syndrome may have set him up for ridicule as a child," Newport said. Days after the slayings, Newport and others in the Asperger's community brain-stormed ways to ramp up help, such as creating a crisis hotline staffed with people familiar with Asperger's and autism. They double-checked to make sure that their support groups had blanket policies of reporting threats to police. One activist contacted the Orange County sheriff's office with an offer to put on an educational town hall meeting about Asperger's; another is in discussions with the New York Police Department about training for crisis intervention officers. Though they don't excuse Freund's actions or know details of his case, many say they relate to some of the anguish he may have felt. People with Asperger's, while often highly academically gifted, tend to lack basic social skills such as knowing how to read a face or hold a conversation, or when to tell little white lies. They are apt to talk relentlessly about their deeply held and sometimes quirky passions, be they city maps, industrial cooling towers or, for Tom Iland, anything pertaining to "Star Wars." The condition, which varies greatly in severity, affects an estimated one in 250 to 500 children, mostly boys. The social awkwardness can add up to a childhood of ostracism and being the butt of playground jokes. "I was alienated when I was in school. I was made fun of. And I did feel very alone," said Benjamin Levinson, 36, of Culver City. "I tried to make friends, but I never really could make any — I just didn't know how." He received a string of incorrect diagnoses before finally learning in his 20s that he had Asperger's. "Looking back on my life, I know that there was a time between when I was about 13 to the time I was maybe 22 or 23, I was just really angry…. Thank God I was able to get some help when I needed it," he said. The future looks brighter Life may be easier for the next generation of children with the disorder. Today, because of far greater recognition of autism and related disorders, children with Asperger's syndrome are much more likely to receive a diagnosis early and get the help they need, such as support groups and social-skills education, said Laurie Stephens, an Asperger's and autism specialist with the Help Group. Among other things, that nonprofit organization runs Village Glen, a school in Sherman Oaks specifically for children with Asperger's and related disorders. "These are people who really want to be able to get along with other people, but it just does not come naturally," Stephens said. "There are many hidden social rules, and they need to be taught them." Iland was a Village Glen student a few years back — and he and his mother credit it with helping him make the transition to a regular high school, then to community college. He's now a junior at Cal State Northridge, studying for a degree in accounting. He still lives at home and has a mentor to help him with life skills. "Violence and revenge isn't the answer," he said, talking on the phone from the CSUN campus last week. "I'm a big 'Star Wars' fan, and in the films those who seek revenge are the bad guys." But special schools can serve only a few. To make the Santa Clarita area public schools easier for her son and others like him, in 2003 Emily Iland pushed to start a peer mentoring program devised by the University of Minnesota in which children with disabilities are paired with nondisabled students. Now she is working on a new project aimed at educating those in law enforcement about Asperger's and autism. She recently convened a training session for more than 275 judges, sheriffs and attorneys in Santa Clarita and is working on a DVD aimed at teaching youth with Asperger's to interact safely with law enforcement and communicate their anxieties and frustrations instead of letting them escalate. Perhaps none of these things could prevent a tragedy such as the one in Aliso Viejo, she said, "but we're being as proactive as we can." Cocaine Prices Rise and Quality Declines, White House Says Juan Forero, New York Times- 11/18/2005 BOGOTÁ, Colombia, Nov. 17 - After years of disappointing news about the easy availability of cocaine on American streets, the Bush administration on Thursday said its multibillion-dollar drug war in Colombia was showing signs of success, with the retail price of the drug in the United States sharply higher and the level of purity lower. From February to September, the price of a gram of cocaine rose 19 percent, to $170, while the purity level fell 15 percent, the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy said. White House officials said those trends were consistent with a shortage of cocaine and validated the United States' $4 billion, multiyear plan to wipe out cocaine drug crops in Colombia through aerial spraying. "These numbers confirm that the levels of interdiction, the levels of eradication, have reduced the availability of cocaine in the United States," John Walters, director of the White House Office of National Drug Control Policy, said Thursday in a telephone interview from Washington. "There's a change in availability. The policy is working." But drug policy analysts critical of the administration's war on drugs said the White House was drawing unrealistically rosy conclusions from too short a period. They noted that a Rand Corporation study for the White House in 2003 showed that as the war on drugs had expanded since 1981, the price of cocaine had tumbled to historic lows while purity levels had risen. Drug policy analysts also said that like any commodity, the price of cocaine sometimes fluctuates wildly. Yet the cocaine trade remains intractably lucrative, they said. "Cocaine is not like computer chips, where new technology makes it cheaper and cheaper," said Ethan Nadelmann, executive director of the Drug Policy Alliance, an independent New York group that says the war on drugs has been counterproductive. "A small blip upward after so many years of decline in price and increase in purity is essentially meaningless." Since 2000, American officials have insisted that an aggressive push to spray land used for Colombia's huge drug crops with glyphosate would pay off. Hundreds of thousands of acres, many in a swath of southern Colombia held by Marxist rebels, have been sprayed. But this year, even after reporting that 336,000 acres of coca plants had been sprayed in 2004, the White House acknowledged that the amount of coca across Colombia was "statistically unchanged" from 2003. Coca cultivation has spread to most states, growers are planting more potent strains and the amount of cocaine Colombia produces is still more than enough to satisfy American demand. Right-wing paramilitary commanders have continued trafficking much of Colombia's cocaine, fearing little from the administration of President Álvaro Uribe, which has granted generous concessions shielding them from serious punishment as they participate in a government-sponsored disarmament process. Human rights groups and some Colombian political leaders say that the paramilitaries are evolving into a Mafia-like organization that depends on the cocaine trade. John Walsh, who follows American drug policy for the Washington Office on Latin America, a policy analysis group, said cocaine trafficking regularly rebounded after difficult periods. When Colombia dismantled the Medellín cocaine cartel in the late 1980's and began an offensive against the Cali cartel in the mid-1990's, "cocaine price increases, while obvious, were equally obviously short-lived," he said. "They were quite ephemeral." Still, the American government says the overall picture is positive: its figures show that seizures of cocaine are way up and that cocaine use among some sectors of the American population has declined. The White House said the newest figures were just the start of a positive trend. Officials say that trend took time to develop because the traffickers had probably overproduced when the spraying effort began and for months used stockpiles of cocaine to supply American consumers. "We kept watching this and watching this and that started to change," David Murray, a drug policy analyst at the White House, said of the price and purity figures. "Nobody is saying victory. We're just finding a figure that's consistent with some of the other data sets we had."
Danny Hakim, New York Times- 11/19/2005 ALBANY, Nov. 18 - For Vincent Scala, the debate over the civil confinement of sexual predators pits his personal beliefs as "a card-carrying member of the A.C.L.U." against his family ties. In June, Mr. Scala's cousin, Concetta Russo-Carriero, was stabbed to death as she walked to her car in the parking garage of a White Plains shopping mall. The homeless man arrested and charged with the crime was released in 2003 after spending nearly 24 years in prison for rape and being repeatedly denied parole. Mr. Scala, a Manhattan criminal defense lawyer, believes that his cousin, 56, who leaves a husband and two grown sons, would still be alive if the State Assembly had passed sex offender legislation proposed by Gov. George E. Pataki and passed by the State Senate. The legislation would set up a system, including a jury trial, for civilly confining sexual predators in mental hospitals after their prison terms end. "I'm a criminal defense lawyer, and an ardent civil libertarian, but since what happened to my cousin, I have come to see the need for a carefully crafted civil confinement law that is mindful of civil liberties, while also protecting the public," Mr. Scala said. His painful internal debate goes to the heart of an issue that has become an Albany hot button: what to do with violent sexual predators after they have served out their sentences. On Tuesday, a State Supreme Court judge ruled that the governor had illegally ordered the detentions of a dozen sex offenders in a mental hospital without a required independent review of their cases. The governor recently ordered that procedures used to confine the mentally ill be adapted to confine sex offenders. He made the move after the legislation he backed, which he has been trying to get passed for several years, stalled in the Assembly. A total of 26 men have been detained in recent weeks under the procedures for confining the mentally ill. Ninety-four sex offenders have been deemed ineligible by a panel of three state doctors. Justice Jacqueline W. Silbermann of State Supreme Court in Manhattan said offenders had a right to independent hearings and examination by court-appointed doctors. The governor plans to appeal. The legislation backed by Mr. Pataki is similar to the laws passed by at least 16 other states and the District of Columbia, which allow confinement of sex offenders even if they do not have what psychiatrists consider serious mental illnesses. The United States Supreme Court has upheld such laws as long as a sex offender is shown to have "a serious difficulty in controlling behavior." State Republicans have used the civil confinement issue as a way to paint Democrats as soft on crime because Democratic Assembly leaders have not brought the legislation up for a vote. Jeanine F. Pirro, the departing Westchester County district attorney, whose office is prosecuting the Russo-Carriero case, made it the theme of the first radio spot in her campaign for the United States Senate. In October, The Star-Gazette of Elmira, N.Y., quoted her as saying, "That's a difference between Democrats and Republicans - we don't want them next door molesting children and murdering women." On Thursday, Governor Pataki chided the State Assembly on "The O'Reilly Factor" on Fox News. Asked by Bill O'Reilly if he thought the Assembly's speaker, Sheldon Silver, was just "pure evil" for blocking the legislation - Mr. O'Reilly finished the thought with a mild expletive - Mr. Pataki demurred, saying "not at all," according to a transcript. "What he is trying to do is reflect the wishes of some of the people in his conference," the governor said. "And who they're protecting is beyond me." Assembly leaders have said several laws have been passed in recent years to enhance sex offender registries and increase penalties for statutory rape and for repeated sexual offenses against children. The Assembly held hearings on civil confinement this year, and Charles Carrier, a spokesman for Mr. Silver, said, "We will have our proposal and advance that early next session." "I don't think this issue deserves to be politicized," he added. "Everybody abhors these crimes. The main thing is how do you do this in the smartest, most effective way." Assemblyman Peter M. Rivera, the Bronx Democrat who is chairman of the Assembly committee on mental health, said the measure would "laugh at due process rights." "It will be well handled by some prosecutors and abused by others," Mr. Rivera said, adding that he had sponsored legislation to give sex offenders longer sentences. In 1990, Washington was the first state to adopt a civil confinement law for sex offenders, allowing prisoners to be held past their sentences if a judge decided they were sexually violent predators. The law required an evaluation by the state's Department of Social and Health Services and a trial, according to a summary provided by the National Conference of State Legislatures. Other states that have since adopted similar laws include Arizona, California, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Missouri, North Dakota, New Jersey, South Carolina, Texas, Virginia and Wisconsin. In September, a freshman congresswoman from Florida, Debbie Wasserman Schultz, a Democrat, introduced such legislation on a federal level. Some psychiatrists question whether the mental health system should be used as a dumping ground for sex offenders. "The American Psychiatric Association said they were an abuse of psychiatry," said W. Lawrence Fitch, director of forensic services for the Mental Hygiene Administration in Maryland. "If the purpose of these laws is to make sure society is protected from dangerous people," he added, "there are other ways to achieve that end than pretending they are suitable for psychiatric treatment." Mr. Fitch served on an American Psychiatric Association panel that examined the laws in the mid-1990's. According to one of his own studies, of the 2,478 people confined in 2002 as sexually violent predators, only 12 percent were diagnosed with serious mental illness. Mr. Scala, Ms. Russo-Carriero's cousin, said he just wanted the Assembly to schedule a vote on the matter. "If you've served your debt and everything is O.K. now, fine," he said. "We don't mean for this to be punitive as much as it should be protective of the community."
Julie Deardorff, Chicago Tribune- 11/20/2005 Ken Zaretzky likes to say that if he didn't already have attention deficit disorder, he'd find a way to get it. To Zaretzky, a 49-year-old ADD coach, the condition isn't a "disorder" at all. It's a chemical difference in the brain that makes ADDers among the most energetic, charismatic, creative and misunderstood people around. But as we talked, Zaretzky had a minor "ADD moment." After returning home from Walgreens, he thought he had left his bag at the store. He drove back--chattering away on his cell phone the whole time--only to find the items were actually at home. "That's part of having ADD," he said cheerfully. "Doing too many things at once." Attention-deficit disorder is not something you necessarily seek out, at least not when society frowns upon hyperactivity, impulsiveness and forgetfulness. But ADDers do make life interesting. And Zaretzky is not alone in his controversial notion that ADD is not a curse but a potential gift, with an emphasis on "potential." Several books advance this major paradigm shift, offering fresh hope and insight to adults who have felt like irresponsible screw-ups since childhood. Two of the more recent ones, "Delivered From Distraction," by ADD experts Dr. Edward Hallowell and Dr. John Ratey (Ballantine, $25.95), and "The Gift of ADHD," by Lara Honos-Webb (New Harbinger, $14.95), have eloquently suggested that a difference is not a disorder. Although prisons are full of people with undiagnosed ADD, it's also a common trait in successful artists, CEOs and risk-taking entrepreneurs, such as David Neeleman, CEO of JetBlue Airways, who calls ADD his greatest asset. "I consider it a gift that's hard to unwrap," said Hallowell, a leading authority on the topic who also has ADD. "Adults with ADD almost always have undeveloped talents and strengths. They're curious, imaginative, think outside the box and have an interesting sense of humor. They're bursting to be tapped, but they've been frustrated for so long that they're hangdog and pessimistic. The first thing in treatment is to instill hope. Don't build a life on remediated weaknesses. Build on strengths and talents." That's easier said than done. Hallowell describes having ADD as speeding through the rain with bad windshield wipers (with a brain that is hard-wired for speed) or listening to a ballgame on a static-filled radio station. "The harder you strain to hear what's going on, the more frustrated you get," Hallowell wrote. Once in a while, you get a clear signal and can focus on the game, but then the static returns, and you get so frustrated that you want to break the radio or, God forbid, kick the cat. Robert Jergen, author of "The Little Monster: Growing Up With ADHD" (Rowman & Littlefield Education, $29.95), describes it as having a thought, like a maddening jingle, stuck in your head for days at a time. But instead of just one thought, you have four or five competing for attention. "Spin them round and round and round in your head and make them go faster and faster and faster until they become like an all-consuming obsession," he said. "Everything centers on those thoughts. You can't focus on anything else. You can't escape them. They drive you insane." But the flip side is that a rapid-firing brain that overflows with ideas can be turned into a personal and professional asset if it's managed properly. Hyperactivity can be transformed into hyperproductivity. And the need for high-stimulus situations drives some of the world's most creative and intuitive people. The real danger of the "gift" philosophy is that if ADD becomes trendy, it risks trivializing a real disorder that can wreak a lifetime of havoc. It also can offer unrealistic hope to those who desperately want to believe they are the next Thomas Edison, Richard Branson or Winston Churchill. An e-book offering "therapy to help creative types" proclaims that having ADD can lead to "fame, fortune & wild success" and that most of the self-made rich and famous (including geniuses, rock stars and billionaires) have the so-called ADD gene. They might. But the sad reality is that those with untreated ADD are more likely to commit suicide, be involved in serious accidents, be fired from their jobs, get divorced and suffer from depression and anxiety compared with those without ADD. In calling it a gift, we've gone from one extreme to the other, perhaps a necessary step to reach a middle ground. People with ADD are not losers or winners, and they're not suffering from a curse or a blessing. The reality lies somewhere in between. Assessing the Alternative Treatment Options for ADD Julie Deardorff, Chicago Tribune- 11/20/2005 Whether you're on medication or not, support groups are a key, but often overlooked, part of ADD treatment. "We've gone through life feeling misunderstood and all alone," said a 44-year-old father from Naperville, who withheld his name in order to protect his 14-year-old son, who also has ADD. "When you go to these support groups, you feel like you belong. It allows us to embrace the positives." Here's a look at some other non-drug treatments that can be used as part of a multi-faceted plan that may or may not include medication. ADD coaches A life coach with special training (but not a therapist) who can come to your home or work with you by phone on quality-of-life issues. Pros: Many coaches recast ADD as a gift, rather than a disorder, and help clients identify their positive characteristics and strengths. Coaches can focus on improving executive functioning skills, such as planning, organizing and prioritizing. Cons: No quality control. Anyone can claim to be an ADD coach. Even "licensed" coaches can be self-licensed. Try to get a referral from someone who had a good experience. Also, be wary of the prices. Most coaches should be around $60 a session. Beware of coaches charging $150 to $200 a session, but pay something so you take it seriously and don't blow it off. One resource is the ADD Coach Academy (www.addca.com). Biofeedback Used for decades, biofeedback allows people to increase brain-wave activity through training. One company, Play Attention (www.playattention.com) uses an EEG biofeedback-based system (the patented name is "Edufeedback") that attempts to form new neural networks. During each session, the user wears a helmet equipped with sensors that record theta (daydreaming) and beta (focused) brain-wave activity. The video-gamelike interface coaches ADD subjects through tasks designed to maintain concentration for a certain period. For example, the screen might show a bird flying through the sky. A loss of concentration would cause the poor bird to fall. A live "coach" could be present to give instruction encouragement and verbal feedback. Pros: Biofeedback has been used for conditions including seizure disorders, mood disorders and ADD for the last 30 years. The evidence shows biofeedback is "probably efficacious," according to a June study in the journal Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback. Cons: The knock against biofeedback has always been that the benefits likely vanish once you unhook yourself from the machine. It's also expensive and time consuming. Hourly fees at freestanding Play Attention "learning" centers can range from $35 to $250, and about 40 hours of training (two hourlong sessions per week) is recommended. Brain exercise and movement The Dore Achievement Centers (www.dorecenters.com) use what they call "cerebellar stimulation." The cerebellum, a clump of neurons in the back of the brain, has long been associated with balance and coordination. The Dore theory, which is still being researched, asserts that the cerebellum is underdeveloped in those with ADD. Dore clients might balance on a wobble board, toss a bean bag from one hand to another while sitting on a Swiss ball, or move the eyes from side to side to stimulate the cerebellum. The idea is that the exercises will help build correct neural pathways and improve frontal lobe performance. A similar technique, used by The Brain Gym (www.braingym.org), works to "develop the brain's neural pathways through movement." Pros: Though skeptical at first, psychiatrist Dr. Edward Hallowell, director of the Hallowell Center for Cognitive and Emotional Health, put his son Jack through the Dore program and says the founders deserve credit for "developing an innovative method of tapping into the untapped power of the cerebellum." Both methods are enjoying anecdotal reports of success. Cons: More research is needed. The Dore method is "essentially a combination of physical therapy and occupational therapy," said psychology professor Robert Resnik, author of "The Hidden Disorder: A Clinician's Guide to Attention Deficit Disorder in Adults." "You wonder about the placebo effect," he said. "I think it's a gimmick." Fatty acid supplementation Fatty acids, which are essential for brain development, maintenance and function, are mainly found in fish oils. Omega-3 fatty acids suppress inflammation and have been shown to be useful in treating adults with depression and bipolar disorder. Studies also show fatty acids promotes the body's production of dopamine, which could be good for those with ADD. Pros: Excellent safety profile. In this age of fast and processed foods, they should be part of your diet anyway. Humans can't make fatty acids; they must be consumed through diet. Cons: Evidence on its success with ADD is mixed. Also, not all fish oil is created equal. Fresh fish oil capsules should taste fresh; if you're experiencing unpleasant burping and foul taste, look for a brand with quality control, like Nordic Naturals. Green outdoor spaces Some studies have shown that children were more able to concentrate, complete tasks and follow directions after spending time in natural, especially green, settings, according to psychologist Lara Honos-Webb in "The Gift of ADHD" (New Harbinger Publications, $14.95). Camping, fishing or playing soccer outside were all considered green activities. Activity alone couldn't explain the findings, because "playing basketball in paved surroundings didn't result in the improvements in concentration that even passive activities in green settings did," Honos-Webb wrote. Still, other studies contradict this to some extent. Pros: Getting some outside exercise is good for you anyway, whether you're trying to treat attention deficit or another modern malady: obesity. Cons: Not enough research to prove whether it works as a sole treatment. Nutrition Three primary dietary inventions are used to treat ADD: the Feingold (additive free) diet, the oligoallergenic/oligoantigenic (few foods) diet and sugar restriction. Feingold asserted quite controversially in 1975 that the increase in learning disabilities and hyperactivity was related to an increase in the use of artificial flavors and colors. Overall, the science is still lacking, but recent studies focusing on behavior effects of artificial colors and preservatives suggest that some children (not necessarily those with ADD) might have sensitivities, according to Neal Rojas and Eugenia Chan of Children's Hospital Boston. Others have taken Feingold's theory and eliminated not only additives and dyes but also sugars, dairy products, wheat, corn, yeast, soy, citrus, egg, chocolate and nuts. Pros: Diet modification can offer a sense of control and help promote a healthy lifestyle. Some foods do exacerbate the condition, and food allergies are underdiagnosed. Anecdotal evidence is strong, especially among families who removed gluten and dairy products. It never hurts to eliminate refined sugar from the diet. Cons: Elimination diets are notoriously hard to stick to, especially if other family members aren't in the same boat. Quality-of-life improvements Get daily physical exercise, join support groups, avoid foods with trans-fatty acids (often hidden on labels as partially hydrogenated oils) and get some sleep. Israeli researchers found that treating sleep disorders in children can lead to a significant reduction of ADD symptoms and improved cognitive performance levels. Yoga and meditation have also been shown to be excellent adjunct therapies. Pros: "Exercise can't hurt, but if you have ADD you need it tenfold," said social worker Laurie Walsh of Insight Employee Assistance Provider. "Even if it's just 10 minutes to help you release chemicals. You can regain focus without needing medication." We should all be doing these things anyway. Cons: None. Pharm Land Joe Queenan, New York Times Book Review- 11/20/2005 GENERATION Rx How Prescription Drugs Are Altering American Lives, Minds, and Bodies. By Greg Critser. 308 pp. Houghton Mifflin Company. $24.95. Apocalytic
literature naturally gravitates toward the maudlin, lamenting that the world is going to hell in a handbasket, usually courtesy of someone like Eminem or Tom DeLay. This is what makes Greg Critser's "Generation Rx" such an unexpected delight. Although his message is unrelievedly depressing - drug companies, with the nation's physicians and the federal government already on the payroll, have transmogrified a self-reliant nation into a herd of functional drug addicts - there is something so congenial and non-self-righteous about the way he tells his story that few of the scoundrels singled out for public obloquy will take personal offense. Meditation Research Is Coming of Age Carey Goldberg, Boston Globe- 11/22/2005 Meditation seems to energize the sleep-deprived. It seems to help with concentration. It even seems to bolster the very structure of the brain as we age. Neuroscientists presenting their latest research at a convention of 34,000 colleagues last week had so much praise for meditation that it was starting to sound like a mantra. Melanie Warner, New York Times- 11/23/2005 Every day Tom Cabrera, a 27-year-old auto mechanic who lives in Middletown, R.I., drinks a can of SoBe No Fear energy drink on his way to work. Later in the day, if he goes to the gym, he downs another before his workout. He says he probably could not get through the day without one. "It lifts me up. One minute I'm dragging and then it's like 'Pow!' " he said, widening his eyes. Loyal and enthusiastic customers like Mr. Cabrera have helped propel caffeinated energy drinks into the fastest-growing sector of the $93 billion domestic beverage industry. Sales of energy drinks, which sell for $2 to $3 a can, have grown a torrid 61 percent this year in the United States, according to Beverage Digest. Energy drinks, which have become a $3 billion business since their introduction in the United States eight years ago, are expected to accelerate profit growth for the beverage industry more than any other drink category in the next few years. Sales of regular soda, meanwhile, are unchanged or declining in the United States and major markets around the world. "The energy drink category came out of nowhere," said John Sicher, publisher of Beverage Digest. "It's been a pleasant surprise for the industry." But that has scientists and nutritionists worried. Energy drinks have as much sugar and roughly three times the caffeine of soda, and some experts peg their popularity to their addictiveness. And with racy names like Full Throttle, Rockstar and Adrenaline Rush, critics say these drinks are fostering caffeine addiction among teenagers. Caffeine can cause hyperactivity and restlessness among children and is known to increase the excretion of calcium, a mineral much needed while bones are still growing. Energy drink manufacturers say they do not market to children and their products have no more caffeine than a typical cup of coffee. But the debate persists. Four countries have barred the sale of energy drinks with current levels of caffeine: France, Denmark, Norway and, two months ago, Argentina. In the U.S., however, sales continue to surge. According to estimates that Coca-Cola executives presented to analysts this summer, the additional industrywide profits that will come from energy products in the four years from 2005 through 2008 will total $540 million, compared with $210 million for regular soft drinks, $130 million for bottled water and $290 million for sports drinks. A relative latecomer to the energy drink business, Coke is eager to become a much bigger player. In January, the company introduced Full Throttle, and last week it announced plans to revamp the 1970's brand Tab, which has not been sold in any significant quantities in the last 20 years, as an energy drink aimed at women. It will also start selling a caffeinated version of its Powerade sports drink. This month, PepsiCo, which owns the SoBe No Fear and Adrenaline Rush brands through its 2001 acquisition of the South Beach Beverage Company, will start selling Mountain Dew MDX, an extra-caffeinated version of Mountain Dew. Critics contend that much of the skyrocketing growth of energy drinks comes because consumers are getting physically addicted, either by consuming the concoctions daily or guzzling several at a time to elevate their mood. Roland Griffiths, a professor of behavioral biology at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, says the amount of caffeine necessary to produce dependency and withdrawal symptoms is about 100 milligrams a day. A can of energy drink has 80 to 160 milligrams, depending on the size, though such information is not listed on any cans. An eight-ounce cup of coffee typically has 100 to 150 milligrams. Some energy brands go so far as to promote their addictiveness as a selling point. "Meet your new addiction! 16 oz's of super charged energy with advanced components and a great berry-passion fruit flavor," reads the front page of Pepsi's SoBe No Fear Web site. Cans of Kronik Energy, made by an Arizona company, warn customers, "Caution: May Be Psychologically Addicting," meant as a daring come-on, not a serious warning. Nutritionists say that while it may be fine for adults to have their dose of caffeine, they worry about children becoming hooked. "I suspect that busy, driven teenagers are grabbing one of these energy drinks instead of eating real food, which I would be concerned about," said Lola O'Rourke, a registered dietitian in Seattle and a spokeswoman for the American Dietetic Association. Cans of SoBe, Monster, Rockstar and others carry a voluntary disclaimer, warning that the fizzy liquid inside is "not recommended for children, pregnant women or people sensitive to caffeine." But the definition of "children" is not always clear. Coke and Pepsi say they aim their products at those older than 20. Rodney C. Sacks, chief executive of the Hansen Natural Corporation, which sells the popular Monster brand, says that his product is appropriate for anyone over 13. Tom Pirko, president of Bevmark, an industry consulting firm, says that while the primary consumers of energy drinks are men ages 20 to 30, the category definitely attracts younger users. "We know they skew down to 12 and 13," he said. "You look at the claw of the monster on the can. When do kids start watching monster movies?" In addition to caffeine, other purportedly energy-enhancing ingredients in energy drinks have attracted the attention of European health officials. When France banned Red Bull in 2000, health officials cited uncertainties about the interaction of caffeine, the amino acid taurine, and glucuronolactone, a type of sugar that is produced by human cells and used in metabolism. Beverage companies say energy drinks have been safely consumed around the world for more than a decade and that such concerns are unfounded. But they acknowledge that there have been few studies looking at the particular combinations of these compounds. In addition to taurine and glucuronolactone, energy drinks have other unusual ingredients: guarana, a Brazilian herb that contains caffeine; inositol, a sugar alcohol; D-Ribose, another sugar used in metabolism; carnitine, arginine and creatine, three amino acids; and ginseng, an Asian herb said to have antioxidant benefits. Red Bull, the Austrian company that makes the original energy drink, makes ambitious assertions about its particular blend of these ingredients. The company's Web site boasts that Red Bull "improves performance, especially during times of increased stress or strain," "increases concentration" and "stimulates the metabolism." Other manufacturers, however, are more circumspect in their claims. Mary Merrill, group director for sports and energy drinks at Coca-Cola, says the reason taurine, guarana, carnitine and ginseng are in Full Throttle is because customers want them there. "Energy drinks contain ingredients that consumers have come to expect and want to see," Ms. Merrill said. "We make no claims about any of them. We believe in marketing our brand by focusing on the brand's personality, rather than the ingredients." Mr. Cabrera, the auto mechanic, says he likes it that his can of No Fear has strange-sounding ingredients, listed on the top of the can, but he admits he has no idea what taurine, creatine and arginine are. Kristi Hinck, a spokeswoman for SoBe beverages, says that if consumers are curious about ingredients, they should do research. "We encourage people to do their homework and look it up," she said. "It's part of the whole mystique about energy drinks." Some scientists say this mystique amounts to little more than shrewd marketing of overpriced, caffeinated sugar water. "These are just caffeine delivery systems," said Professor Griffiths at Johns Hopkins. "They're being marketed cleverly to imply they have other ingredients that may be useful to some end." Henk Smit, a researcher in the department of experimental psychology at the University of Bristol in Britain, decided to test the effectiveness of energy drinks. In a study published in the medical journal Nutritional Neuroscience last year, Mr. Smit found that energy drinks were effective at improving mood and performance, but he concluded that caffeine was the crucial component. "Any additional benefits of taurine, glucuronolactone or other ingredients are minimal compared to those of caffeine, and from what I know, are speculative at best for most of these ingredients," he wrote in an e-mail message. Mr. Sacks, the Hansen chief executive, takes issue with these findings. He says Monster is carefully made to deliver a smoother burst of energy than other forms of caffeine. "When you drink coffee you get jittery, agitated and fidgety," he said. "Our experience is that you don't get the same effect with an energy drink." Mr. Sacks says that if his aim were to simply get customers revved up on caffeine, he would have added more of it. "If I wanted to promote sales, I could have doubled the caffeine," he said. "It's a cheap ingredient relative to the others. Why would I spend dollars and dollars per case for these other ingredients when I could just put in 2 more cents and double the caffeine?" It is these other, more expensive ingredients that allow manufacturers to charge $2 to $3 a can when a 20-ounce bottle of soda can be had for $1 to $1.50. And that, says Mr. Pirko of Bevmark, has everything to do with marketing. "You're selling images to people who want to be powerful," he said. "It's a head trip." Paul Roazen, 69, Scholar Who Found Flaws in Freud, Dies Jeremy Pearce, New York Times- 11/23/2005 Paul Roazen, a political scientist and chronicler of the development of psychoanalysis who explored Sigmund Freud's complex relationships with his family, students and adherents, died Nov. 3 at his home in Cambridge, Mass. He was 69. The cause was complications of Crohn's disease, his family said. In the 1975 book "Freud and His Followers" (Knopf), Dr. Roazen pointed out inconsistencies in Freud's analytical practices and drew the ire of orthodox Freudians. Dr. Roazen, who was not a psychiatrist, interviewed about 70 patients and pupils of Freud to sketch a portrait that showed biases, indiscretions and quirks in treating patients that seemed inconsistent with Freud's espoused methods. The book was read as a counterpoint to Ernest Jones's largely admiring three-volume biography of Freud, published in the 1950's and previously taken to be authoritative. Dr. Roazen's book, however, was not considered to be a challenge to Freudian theory in the main. E. James Lieberman, a psychiatrist in private practice in Washington and a biographer of Freud's close colleague Otto Rank, said that Dr. Roazen's work had "opened up a whole field of historiography of psychoanalysis, essentially barren before him, that was anathema to the establishment but later absorbed into the mainstream." In an earlier book, "Brother Animal: The Story of Freud and Tausk" (Knopf, 1969), Dr. Roazen (pronounced ROE-zuhn) looked at the relationship of the master with a student, and later a colleague, Viktor Tausk, who committed suicide in 1919. A more recent book, "How Freud Worked: First-Hand Accounts of Patients" (Jason Aronson, 1995), continued Dr. Roazen's fascination with Freud's breaches of his stated methods and practices. It revealed that Freud had analyzed his daughter, Anna, as well as a friend of Anna's, Eva Rosenfeld, while Eva lived in Freud's household, despite his emphasis on maintaining objective distance between analyst and patient. A review of the book in The New York Times found that the book was, in part, fueled by gossip but acknowledged that Dr. Roazen had established certain patterns and practices in Freud's work. "Freud did not keep his analytic life separate from his personal life," it said. "Everyone Freud analyzed was either translating his writings, acting as an emissary for him, finding him summer homes, keeping company with his daughter or his son, or taking care of him in old age. The analytic world was small and ingrown." Dr. Roazen's chronicles extended to other practitioners and eminent disciples of Freud. He published one book about the psychobiographer and theorist Erik H. Erikson, and another about Helene Deutsch, the Boston psychoanalyst who had been a client of Freud's in Vienna. A professor of social and political science at York University in Toronto, Dr. Roazen also developed psychological portraits of Woodrow Wilson and other political leaders. Paul Roazen was born in Boston. He received his doctorate in political science from Harvard, where he was an assistant professor of government from 1968 to 1971. He then moved to York University and remained there for the rest of his career. He was named a professor of social and political science in 1974. After retiring in 1995, he returned to Cambridge. In 1993, Dr. Roazen was elected a fellow of the Royal Society of Canada. He was made an honorary member of the American Psychoanalytic Association in 2004. Dr. Roazen's marriage to Deborah Heller ended in divorce. He is survived by two sons, Daniel Heller-Roazen, a professor of comparative literature at Princeton, and Jules Roazen of Manhattan; a brother, Dr. Bernard Roazen of San Francisco; and a sister, Sheila Weiss of Westport, Conn. |