Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, January
1-4, 2005
Teen Suicide and Feelings of Failure
Joel Rubin & Sandra Murillo, Los Angeles Times- 1/1/2005
"Dear Family," Velia Huerta Victorino began her handwritten
letter. "Sorry for what I did, but I had to. No one liked me
anymore. All my friends left me because what people were saying."
At the bottom, Velia drew a heart, signed her name and, in a postscript,
wrote, "I was 15." A few hours later, as her mother slept
nearby, the girl hanged herself from a beam in the living room of
her family's San Bernardino home.
In the 10 weeks since Velia's death,
her mother and sister have angrily blamed the suicide on what they
said were years of bullying by other girls that eventually became
unbearable. But although it is tempting to look for easy answers,
the tragedy like most teen suicides isn't simple to
sort out. Her death, a month after a friend of Velia's hanged himself,
has unsettled the working-class neighborhood in which she lived, prompting
school officials, neighbors and classmates to try to puzzle out what
drove Velia to kill herself and what could prevent similar
tragedies. From conversations with Velia's family and others who knew
her, and from documents in her school file, a portrait emerges of
an isolated, tormented girl who fought often with others and had been
suspended from school several times, once for threatening a teacher.
Velia also had had a troubled home life with a mother who struggled
to help control her daughter's anger.
In 2002, more than 4,200 Americans
aged 10 to 24 committed suicide, making it the third highest cause
of death in that age group. Most, experts say, suffered from depression
or other mental illnesses that left them vulnerable and unable to
cope. Velia may have been no different, according to several experts.
"The combination of mental illness, the perception that you have
a problem that is unsolvable and coping skills that don't work tends
to lead to death," said Joan Asarnow, a UCLA psychologist and
national expert on teen suicide.
Born into a family that dates back
generations in the blue-collar streets of San Bernardino, Velia was
the youngest of five children. When she was little, her parents divorced.
Over the years that followed, the family moved frequently, subsisting
on welfare, child support payments and Social Security. By the time
she turned 12, Velia had attended at least three elementary schools.
As early as second grade, records show, Velia had "behavioral
problems" and was struggling to read and write. Teachers described
a girl who could turn in moments from sweet to angry and who had trouble
making and keeping friends. Her mother, Evangelina Huerta, doesn't
dispute the description. "That was just my Velia," she said,
"like a Jekyll and Hyde. There were times when she was as sweet
as an angel and times when I was like 'God, where did this child come
from?' "
A second-grade teacher commented in
a report, "Velia does a lot of teasing and hitting
. She
needs peace-building skills," and by fourth grade, her records
show, Velia was frequently reprimanded for hitting others and acting
out in class. Throughout elementary and middle school, she consistently
missed more than a month of classes each year.
As she grew into a teenager, Velia's
family continued to disintegrate around her. In 2000, an uncle was
killed in a drive-by shooting, and soon after, her grandmother was
hospitalized with cancer. In 2002, her closest brother, Mario, was
sentenced to seven years in prison for stabbing a friend who had allegedly
attacked Velia's older sister, Angie. "Her brother being sent
away was devastating for her," Huerta said. "It was like
someone being dead." The same year, the family was evicted from
its home after falling more than 15 months behind in rent.
The instability and loss seemed to
take a toll on Velia. She began trying to impress girls by picking
fights and acting tough, according to school assessments and her neighbors.
Her aggression led to frequent confrontations in which she was slapped
in the hallways or jumped by girls after school, friends and her mother
said. The anger management classes she was required to attend did
little to help. In one particularly bad brawl, police were called
to school after Velia hurled a chair at a group of girls, her mother
said.
"It is so easy to look at girls
like Velia and just see a bully," said Rachel Simmons, author
of "Odd Girl Out: The Hidden Culture of Aggression in Girls."
"We forget that inside is a girl who needs help." A study
by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention found that more
than 60% of high school students who attempted suicide also were violent
toward others.
Her mother tried to help but was unsure
what to do. Once, Huerta said, when Velia was in a rage, she took
her daughter outside and challenged her to a fight, hoping it would
help her get out some aggression. "Velia said, 'OK, you hit me
first,' " Huerta recalled. "So I pushed her and she punched
me
. But I allowed it because this is the only way that she could
learn. I said to her, 'Get it out of you. It has to stop now.' "
But it did not stop.
In November 2003 came an even more
serious warning sign. After a teacher discovered Velia scribbling
a list of the "top ten ways to kill yourself and love yourself,"
Velia's mother got a call from the school about it, she said. "I
said, 'She's just writing it. She's not going to do it.' " Velia
was placed under psychiatric evaluation for several days at a Chino
hospital. Asarnow, the UCLA psychologist, emphasized the importance
of such interventions for children contemplating suicide. Adolescents
who have made previous suicide attempts, she noted, are at risk of
trying again to kill themselves.
When Velia returned to her classes,
she was still far from emotionally healthy. In an annual assessment
a month after the hospitalization, school officials wrote that Velia
"claims 'nobody likes me' at school (unable to give any reasons)"
and that "she could not offer any suggestions to make her happy,
other than returning to the hospital. ('They treat me nice.') Her
drawings suggest: inadequacy, rejection, anxiety, low self-esteem,
helplessness, insecurity, and poor interpersonal relations."
But despite such obvious indications
of trouble, weekly counseling sessions that followed the hospitalization
were cut off in February, Velia's father, Rudy Victorino, said. A
psychiatrist had recommended putting Velia on "some sort of medication,"
but her father says he was opposed. "I said to the doctor, 'My
daughter's not like that.' I don't believe in giving kids drugs."
By the end of last school year, Velia
had been suspended from school for more than 20 days, once for threatening
to hurt a teacher after he took her cellphone away in class. A judge
warned her that if she was suspended again, she would be sent to juvenile
hall. With that threat hanging over her head, Velia seemed to try
to change her ways. A summer school session went well, and she entered
her freshman year at Pacific High School determined to stay out of
trouble, said both her mother and Alyssa Vasquez, a classmate who
had befriended Velia. Other girls still challenged Velia to fight,
but Velia resisted. "I'd be standing right next to her,"
Alyssa said, "And she would say, 'I ain't even going to fight,
I ain't even going to let it go down like that.' She just didn't want
to be like that anymore."
And there was someone new in Velia's
life: 15-year-old Steven Vega Jr., whom she had begun casually dating,
according to her sister. On Sept. 28, less than a month before Velia
killed herself, Steven closed his bedroom door, attached a thick speaker
wire to a belt and hanged himself from his bunk bed. Velia's sister
Angie said that although Velia was upset over Steven's death, she
became even more distraught when rumors spread at school that she
had been the last to see him alive and had encouraged him to commit
suicide.
Copycat suicides in the United States
are not uncommon, especially among teens and young adults imitating
friends or acquaintances who have killed themselves. Researchers have
found that every year in the United States, between 100 and 200 teenagers
die in these "suicide clusters."
On Friday, Oct. 22, Angie left a note
for Mike O'Connor, who runs the peer counseling program at Pacific
High School and works with the school's at-risk students, asking him
to speak to Velia. O'Connor, who said he was unaware of Velia's earlier
hospitalization, called Angie to tell her he would meet with Velia
on Monday. But he never got the chance.
About 6:30 on Sunday evening, Oct.
24, Velia woke from a nap and ate some leftovers with her mother.
Afterward, she called a girl she considered a friend to ask about
a homework assignment. By the time she hung up, Velia was in tears.
She called Alyssa Gonzalez, one of her few friends. "She was
really sad" about the phone call, Alyssa recalled. "She
said that the girl had said that everyone at school thought she was
a joke and that it would be better if she just wasn't around. "Velia
asked me, 'What if I wasn't around? Would they stop talking about
me? Would you miss me?' I told her not to listen to them, that it
was just words. She said she'd see me tomorrow."
Turmoil in peer relationships is common
for teenage girls, UCLA's Asarnow said, but Velia's problems with
her friends do not by themselves explain why she killed herself. Asarnow
speculated that, like 90% of adolescents who kill themselves, Velia
probably suffered from depression or another mental illness that left
her unable to handle the strong, and typical, desire among teenage
girls for friendship. She was also a teenager, and teens are impulsive.
About 9:30 that Sunday evening, Huerta
walked into the kitchen to find her daughter at the table writing
what may well have been her suicide note. (The next day, family members
found drafts of the suicide letter in the trash.) Later, about 11,
the two crawled under the heavy blankets on their mattress and turned
on the television. "Nobody likes me, Mom. I don't have any friends,"
Huerta recalled Velia's saying. "I'm your friend," she replied
before drifting off to sleep.
When he arrived at school Monday morning,
Mike O'Connor was met by Angie, hysterical and screaming, "This
school killed my sister!" O'Connor was stunned. As far as he
knew, Velia had never threatened suicide. Ten days before her death,
Pacific High officials had requested Velia's records from her middle
school, which would have included health reports, but it appears they
were not sent. Other than O'Connor, school and district officials
declined to comment on Velia, citing student privacy laws. "There
are kids who are acutely depressed," O'Connor said. "In
Velia's case, we didn't know. I work with kids that say, 'I'm suicidal.'
I don't leave their side. If I'd have known, I would have done an
intervention."
Velia's father, a devout Roman Catholic
who believes those who commit suicide will not see heaven, spent weeks
after his daughter's death going from priest to priest, finally finding
some comfort from one who told him that "God loves children"
and that he felt Velia's hurt and that he would protect her. He is
still devastated by Velia's death. "I thought I knew my daughter,"
he said, "but I guess I didn't know her that well."
Alzheimer's Prevention: Maintaining the Brain
Bruce Taylor Seeman, Newhouse News Service- 1/2/2004
Can Alzheimer's disease be avoided by exercising the brain? As with
many matters of the mind, the question is tangled in complexity and
uncertainty. But the evidence is growing, researchers say. "The
data doesn't point to one particular activity said Elizabeth Edgerly,
a clinical psychologist and expert who is leading training for the
Alzheimer's Association's "Maintain Your Brain" workshops.
"What it shows is a relationship between those who remain intellectually
active and reduction of risk. We cannot say, `Do a crossword puzzle
every day, and that will help.' What we can say is challenging yourself
in a variety of ways is good for brain cells."
In Chicago this fall, when the Association
rolled out its first-ever community workshop on keeping the brain
healthy, it included tips not only on diet and exercise, but on the
benefits of brain stimulation and social interaction. The association
expected about 20 bank employees to attend the inaugural event. But
the standing-roomonly crowd neared 100. "Fear is a big motivating
factor," said Dr. Samuel Gandy, director of the Farber Institute
for Neurosciences of Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia and
an adviser to the Alzheimer's association. "The disease is so
common. And it's a horror to watch. The person you know in your family
or social circle just fades away."
Indeed, a recent association survey
showed people 55 to 65 worried. more about getting Alzheimer's than
any health problem except heart disease -- more even than cancer.
But only about half those surveyed said they were actually doing something
to keep their brains healthy--whether through diet, exercise, intellectual
stimulation or social activities.
The federal government spends nearly
$700 million a year on Alzheimer's research, much of it aimed at understanding
the pathology that leads to brain erosion and to test drugs that might
slow or halt cognitive decline.
Currently, four drugs are prescribed
for the disease -- three for mild to moderate cases, the fourth for
more advanced patients. There are no drugs for prevention, even for
people with a family history of Alzheimer's. But many believe drugs
will one day feature in this role. "The hope is we would be able
to identify those individuals who are at risk, using neuroimaging
or other biological markers, so that when we do have drugs available
to delay progression or prevent Alzheimer's, we know who is at highest
risk," said Dr. Neil Buckholtz, chief of the Dementias of Aging
Branch of the National Institute on Aging. "That's the long-term
direction."
Developing such drugs, however, could
take decades. Because Alzheimer's unfolds so slowly (some are sick
for 15 years before symptoms appear) and because it strikes an organ
of such complexity, it is exceedingly difficult to study. Clinical
trials must be large and expensive to be definitive. And so increased
attention is being paid to everyday behaviors that seem to reduce
risk None is a guarantee. But, said Gandy, "we have some very
tantalizing leads."
Exercise appears to stimulate brain
processes that boost "cognitive functioning," according
to the National Institutes of Health. It apparently also sets in motion
cellular mechanisms that protect the brain from damage and promote
repair. Other variables are under investigation. People with high
blood pressure, high cholesterol or diabetes are at higher risk. Inflammation
may be a factor. And scientists say there is compelling evidence that
invigorating the brain itself may delay or prevent the disease.
Yaakov Stern, a clinical neuropsychology
professor at Columbia University, researches why people with more
advanced education seem to fare better. He and others subscribe to
the concept of "cognitive reserve" -- that those with more
developed minds are somehow able to reach for back-up brain power
to compensate, at least temporarily, for the damage'of Alzheimer's.
"You have two people with the same pathology," Stern explained.
"One can do better than the other, look more intact than the
other. What is that person doing differently inside the brain? If
we understand, it might lead us to remediation therapies." Stern
is scanning the brains of volunteers while they complete a set of
tasks, hoping to detect how the more educated, more exercised mind
operates differently.
Research already completed, meanwhile,
suggests that keeping the mind at work strengthens brains cells and
the connections between them, and may even create nerve cells. Scientists
only recently established the revolutionary finding that brain cells
develop throughout life, not just during the fetal period as once
was believed. Now it's agreed that new neurons grow into adulthood,
at least in some portions of the brain.
German scientists and NIH-funded researchers
at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies in La Jolla, Calif.,
found that mice who lived in "enriched environments" ---
running wheels, plastic tubes, nesting materials -- had more neurons
in the hippocampus portion of their brains and were better at learning
tasks. Another study of older mice showed that increased physical
and mental activity, even when started in middle age, enhanced generation
of new neurons and improved learning and exploratory behavior. And
a 2003 sturdy published in the New England Journal of Medicine showed
the odds of getting dementia were lower in people who regularly read,
played cards or board games, solved crossword puzzles or played a
musical instrument.
The best strategy, according to the
Alzheimer's Association, is to embrace variety in your intellectual
life -- stay curious and involved, attend lectures, volunteer in community
groups. Some of these activities may reduce stress, also regarded
as a risk factor, and exercise parts of the brain vital for socialization.
Spending time with friends, experts say, requires lots of brain work
-- remembering where you saw them last, what they said then, and what
they're saying now. "If you're visting with friends, you're really
trying to focus on this person's life," Edgerly said. "There's
so much going On."
Can This War-Weary Marriage Be Saved?
Christopher Berkey, Associated Press- 1/2/2005
HOPKINSVILLE, Ky.-- When Sgt. Jose Bermudez returned from Iraq,
he came home to a new baby and a troubled marriage. "We were
on the brink of divorce," his wife, Mandy, said as the couple
ate lunch recently with their three children, all under age 3. The
Bermudezes are among 300 couples with the 101st Airborne Division,
based at Fort Campbell, Ky., who have attended "marriage enrichment"
seminars put on by the Army in hopes of saving war-ravaged relationships.
With studies showing divorce rates
as high as 21 percent among couples where one spouse has been sent
off to war, the Army is spending $2 million on various marriage programs,
including vouchers for getaways. "I've been in the Army 20 years
and I've never seen the Army pay for programs like this," said
Lt. Col. Chester Egert, chaplain for the 101st.
One Army program teaches couples about
forgiveness and communication skills. It includes a 40-hour course
with lessons on the dangers of alcohol and tobacco and how to recognize
post-traumatic stress. Soldiers who complete it are rewarded with
promotion points and a weekend retreat with their spouse. "If
you learn those skills, you can make an impact on the number of divorces,
and the number, we think, of reports of physical violence," said
Col. Glen Bloomstrom, director of ministry initiatives for the Chief
of Chaplains. To make the program more popular, commanders are encouraged
to give their soldiers time off to attend. Baby-sitting is often provided.
"What we're trying to do is change the culture, that it's O.K.
to work on your marriage and take some time, and invest in your lifelong
relationship - especially now when we're asking so much of your military
spouses," Colonel Bloomstrom said.
Sergeant Bermudez, 26, said it seemed
as if everyone he knew at Fort Campbell was either getting a divorce
or contemplating one. Many couples want to get things decided because
the division has been alerted it could return to Iraq as early as
midyear. At Fort Campbell and elsewhere, many couples married right
before one spouse left for Iraq. Others, like the Bermudezes, have
been married longer but still have spent little time together.
The Bermudezes met in 2000 and married
six months later. He was later deployed to Kosovo and Iraq. "We
didn't know each other that well," said Mandy Bermudez, 25. "That's
part of the problem." Sergeant Bermudez was in Iraq when their
second child was born, and his wife became pregnant with the third
while he was home on a two-week leave. Mandy Bermudez said another
problem with their marriage was that her husband had trouble adjusting
to the routine she had established for herself while he was in Iraq.
Finding affordable day care has also been a major source of stress,
she said. She said the two joined a church, and "it turned our
marriage around." The couple decided to stay together. "I
can't leave these three kids with her," Sergeant Bermudez said.
"It's worth it to try and work it out."
The Army's recent foray into marriage
counseling was started in the late 1990's by a chaplain in Hawaii
working with a unit with a high number of divorces. In 2001, laws
were changed to allow the Army to pay for lodging and meals for the
retreats. The effort is similar to another series of Army programs
to help returning soldiers reconnect emotionally with spouses and
children. Those programs began after four wives at Fort Bragg, N.C.,
were killed in 2002, and their husbands were suspected.
Colonel Egert said the Army's effort
did not just make for stronger families -- it made for better soldiers.
"Soldiers will come apart in Afghanistan and Iraq," he said.
"They'll absolutely collapse if they think their wife is going
to leave them or their husband is going to leave them. I've seen soldiers
hospitalized because they absolutely had a nervous breakdown because
they were worried about their families." Added Colonel Bloomstrom,
"You are really giving something that the couples know they need,
at a time they may be receptive to hear it."
Alcohol Deaths Spur Change on Reservation
Associated Press, 1/2/2005
MISSOULA -- The Flathead Indian Reservation is shifting its focus
to children and retooling tribal policies following the drinking deaths
of four boys in a six-month period. The deaths, starting in late 2003,
stunned the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, but inspired
a gritty resolve to help children deal with alcohol without underestimating
the power of generations of alcohol abuse. ``It seems like we've got
some good things going, but I think we can't forget that we are fighting
something that has been a problem for our people for hundreds of years,''
said Tony Incashola, head of the Salish Cultural Committee. ``Sometimes
there's a sense of 'Hey, what can we really do?' but you can't let
that stop you from trying.''
Tyler Benoist died first. The 14-year-old
spent the night drinking with friends in November 2003 and was found
dead of smoke inhalation in a burned trailer in Pablo. Authorities
said he had passed out with a blood-alcohol level of 0.233. Three
months later, Tyler's 11-year-old brother, Justin, and another boy,
Frankie Nicolai, vanished from Ronan Middle School. A friend found
their bodies three days later. Tests concluded alcohol poisoning killed
Frankie, whose blood-alcohol level was 0.50 percent, more than six
times the drunken-driving threshold in Montana. Justin, whose blood
alcohol was 0.20 percent, died from a combination of alcohol poisoning
and hypothermia. No one was charged in the case. In May, 15-year-old
Joey DuMontier drank most of a fifth of whiskey and died in a chair
at a home northeast of Ronan. Sentencing is scheduled Jan. 22 for
Richard Lopez, 21, of Ronan who pleaded guilty to providing at least
some of the alcohol.
Tribal leaders knew something had to
be done. For a while, the response appeared mostly symbolic through
rallies, walks and get-togethers held to generate ideas and allow
the public to grieve. ``I think all the rallies and events were a
way for people to feel like they were doing something,'' Incashola
said. ``A rally is a way, on one hand, to show support, but it's also
a way to say 'Well, what else can we do?' This was so big that people
had a very difficult time imagining how we could really respond to
it.'' In recent months, the tribal council has stepped up, appointing
a team to identify ways the government can better respond to children's
needs and outlining tribal policy regarding children in a tribal children's
code. The tribes also recently took part in a training program that
should ultimately lead to formation of a drug court. The court would
be family oriented, with neither children nor adults treated in isolation.
``You're dealing with the family as a unit, so the whole system is
essentially gathered around the family,'' said Teresa Wall-McDonald,
who heads the tribes' Department of Human Resources and Development.
Tribal elders have also become more
involved by connecting with tribal programs that deal with children.
``They're coming at this from the perspective of making sure that
we find ways to connect with the positive values of the past,'' Incashola
said. ``A lot of elders have felt helpless and hopeless about passing
down the value of family, so there's a real push there to see if we
can do something about that.''
Despite the changes, grief is never
far away on the reservation in northwestern Montana, he said. ``When
you lose young people, I think it's something you never quite get
over,'' Incashola said. ``There will always be something that makes
you remember what happened. Those are wounds that never quite heal,
but they also make you remember what you ought to be doing to make
sure the same thing doesn't happen again.''
Information from: Missoulian, www.missoulian.com
W.Va. Faces Mental Health Care Crisis
Associated Press, 1/2/2005
CHARLESTON, W.Va. -- West Virginia hospitals spend more on patients
suffering from psychosis than on any other diagnosis and almost doubled
their mental health spending over four years. The increased spending,
shortage of beds at state-run psychiatric hospitals and the fifth-highest
suicide rate in the country indicate a mental health crisis in West
Virginia, according to an investigation by the Sunday Gazette-Mail
of Charleston.
Mental health care problems are difficult
to solve because of the stigma surrounding mental illness, said Eugenie
Taylor, acting commissioner at the state Bureau of Health and Health
Facilities. ``If this was any other disease, there would be a groundswell
of support for change,'' she said. State hospitals in 2003 spent $101
million treating psychosis, up from $52 million four years earlier,
according to the state Health Care Authority.
The state Supreme Court reports that
the number of ``mental hygiene petitions'' -- which are requested
by police, social workers and family members to commit people to mental
hospitals -- has increased by 45 percent between 1999 and 2003. Meanwhile,
the number of mentally ill people in regional jails has almost doubled
in four years, from 5,862 in 2000 to an estimated 11,000 in 2004.
More than one in four inmates received mental health services last
year, up from one in five in 2000, and the number of mentally ill
inmates is growing faster than the total population. Both state-run
psychiatric hospitals had empty beds four years ago, but by last year
they had become so overcrowded that more than 1,000 patients had to
be sent to private facilities at a cost of $3.5 million. A record
290 West Virginians committed suicide in 2001, while another 277 took
their own lives in 2002. Those totals were up from 224 suicides in
1998, according to the state Bureau for Public Health.
A recent report by the state Department
of Health and Human Resources says mental health providers spent $90
million more than they should have during the 1990s. When federal
officials demanded a payback, former DHHR Secretary Joan Ohl arranged
to have the debt forgiven in exchange for the state turning over mental
health payments to a managed care company to cut costs. Because of
that deal, the state's community mental health centers lost 40 percent
of their Medicaid funding in just two years, according to the report.
As a result, the number of group home beds dropped from 203 to 84,
and caseworkers could not visit clients at home as often, according
to a DHHR memo. They had less time to help clients pay their bills
or the rent, and inpatient programs to treat substance abuse were
cut or eliminated. State officials have responded by replacing some
lost Medicaid money with state funds over the last two years, and
have appointed an ``overbedding task force'' to address crowding at
the state psychiatric hospitals, Taylor said.
On the Net:
Bureau of Health and Health Facilities: www.wvdhhr.org/bhhf
Bureau of Public Health: www.wvdhhr.org/bph
The Spotlight at the End of the Tunnel
Daniel J. Wakin, New York Times- 1/3/2005
Twice, she insisted on elective sinus surgery just to obtain more
painkillers. Once, she pretended that a flood had ruined her medication
so she could get a prescription refilled. There were times when she
was so stoned on Percocet that she had no memory of actually singing,
a self-described "junkie" whom the Metropolitan Opera banished
from its stage. Andrea Gruber's tales of addiction pour out like the
rich, deep tones of her soprano voice, which again will be heard in
the title role of "Turandot" at the Met starting tonight.
"Try being a functioning junkie at the Metropolitan Opera,"
Ms. Gruber, 39, said in an interview at the opera house. "I felt
like such a fraud." Often, she would time a large dose for right
before a major aria or duet toward the end of a performance, trying
to achieve maximum numbness when the applause came. "I felt unworthy,"
Ms. Gruber said.
With the precision of a recovering
addict, she explained that she had been free of dependence on painkillers
and tranquilizers for eight and a half years. Finally settling into
the major operatic career that was predicted for her nearly two decades
ago, she said the time had come for her to talk about her descent
into addiction and her climb back out.
Why now? Her past would arise anyway
with the interviews that come with success, she said. Going public
fulfills the need of the recovering addict to proclaim sobriety and
make amends. Maybe it will help other people, whether addicted to
alcohol or drugs. Hence, Ms. Gruber said, she is discussing her drug
problems for the first time in the United States, starting with an
article in the current Opera News, which is published by the Metropolitan
Opera Guild. She rehearsed the part in interviews a year ago with
several Italian publications. "I believe it's important for people
to know that there are people in all walks of life who come from hell
and fight their way out," she said.
Ms. Gruber, who lives on the Upper
West Side, said she knew that some people would consider her speaking
out a publicity ploy, or a gimmick to draw a wider audience to what
some consider an elite art form. "Fine, I'm a big girl,"
she said. And she said she recognized the risk of being known as opera's
recovering addict. "I don't want to be a cliché,"
she said. "But I will show you my tattoo," she added without
missing a beat. She turned around, raised her shirt, and there it
was on her lower back, the first five notes and words of "In
questa reggia," Turandot's aria from Act II. It is one of Ms.
Gruber's signature roles.
The gesture was in keeping with her
earthy and sometimes profane manner. Her eyes crease when she smiles,
and the laugh is a big, soprano laugh. Beyond opera, her musical tastes
run to a bad-girl mix of Janis Joplin, Eminem and 50 Cent. At 5-foot-71/2,
Ms. Gruber weighs a relatively svelte 180 pounds, down about 140 from
her peak before gastric bypass surgery - another potentially touchy
subject, in a world of heavyset performers, that Ms. Gruber seems
to relish discussing.
Her addict past appears to be fairly
unusual in the opera world, Ms. Gruber and several opera house executives
said, although there are singers who have struggled with alcoholism.
They reason that drug addiction is rare in opera, unlike in the pop
music world, because the physical and mental toll would render singers
unable to perform. And maybe classical singers are just "squarer,"
Ms. Gruber said. But her story does shed light on the pressures of
building a significant opera career; on the hunger for big, new voices;
on the conflicts between overweight singers and opera management.
Ms. Gruber's life was troubled from
early on. She was born and grew up on West End Avenue near 103rd Street
on the Upper West Side, the daughter of two history professors. She
attended the private Bank Street School until she was asked to leave
after seventh grade. She said she began smoking marijuana about the
age of 11. At the Putney School in Vermont, she tripped on acid her
first week as a freshman. But it was also at Putney, as a talented
but unmotivated flutist, that she began studying voice at 16. "The
only constants in my life were trouble and drugs and music,"
she said.
She managed to win a place at the Manhattan
School of Music, where her drug use continued. "I was the kid
who was freebasing cocaine in the bathroom during the middle of vocal
lit class," Ms. Gruber said. She said she also used heroin in
her teenage years. Midway through her time in music school, she did
her first of three stints in rehab, at Phoenix House in Manhattan,
and left nonprescription drugs behind.
But after a root canal, she was given
a prescription for Percocet and began a decade of abusing prescription
medication, with her habit reaching dozens of pills a day. Ms. Gruber
said that she used her skills as an actress to manipulate doctors
into prescribing the drugs. "I'm talking about just junkie scams,"
she said -- like the supposed flood and the sinus surgeries.
Still, she won a coveted place in the
Young Artists program at the Met in 1989, and that year, precociously,
she was asked to perform as the Third Norn from "Götterdämmerung"
for a Met recording. "That was how good and promising she was
at the very beginning," said Jonathan Friend, then and now the
Met's artistic administrator. "The voice was big, rich, and the
top was not a problem for her." Her stage debut at the Met came
in that role the next year. Critics and opera aficionados began calling
her a bright new light on the vocal scene. Her first starring role
at the house was in "Ballo in Maschera" in late 1990, with
Luciano Pavarotti. The performance won critical praise. "I was
stoned out of my gourd on Percocet," Ms. Gruber said. Her deficiencies
were obvious enough to prompt James Levine, the Met's music director,
to ask her not to sing the next performance. "I was a mess,"
she said. "I had no business singing 'Ballo in Maschera' onstage
at the Met."
Her career sputtered along, with a
few successes mixed with cancellations. She had trouble memorizing
dialogue and missed rehearsals. Her vocal cords would swell when,
numbed by the drugs, she would push her vocal mechanism. Cortisone
shots would bring down the swelling, and the cycle would continue.
She said she felt lucky not to have damaged her voice, although Mr.
Friend said he would be "exceptionally surprised" if she
had not done at least some harm. "Somehow I managed to function
well enough not to get fired while I was singing," Ms. Gruber
said. "I was just not rehired."
Then came a disastrous Met performance
of "Aida" in 1995. She recalled that at one point when she
was unable to hit a note, the Met orchestra's concertmaster at the
time, Raymond Gniewek, looked up at her and just shook his head. The
Met -- her hometown opera house, where her career began and was nurtured
-- cut its ties and bought out her contract. "Joe wants you out,"
she said her representative told her, meaning Joseph Volpe, the house's
general manager. Mr. Volpe said he did not now remember what her problem
was. "She wasn't singing well," he said. "I decided
we shouldn't continue having her perform." Mr. Friend, too, said
that the nature of her problems were unclear and that the Met did
not have the responsibility to intervene. "The fact is, the Met
is not her voice teacher, her parents, her boyfriend, her whatever,"
he said. "We have a relationship with her, but our obligation
is to the institution." Mr. Friend added that he was heartbroken
by her decline and what seemed at the time as her failure to fulfill
her early promise.
In the mid-90's, Ms. Gruber receded
into relative obscurity on the opera scene. "Put it this way:
I was not the shining star for the future," she said. Only Speight
Jenkins, the general director of the Seattle Opera, maintained faith,
casting her in three operas during the decade. "I believe that
Andrea had the capacity to come through it because she was so strong
willed," Mr. Jenkins said.
In 1996, she was hospitalized in Vienna
with a blood clot in her leg. There, while doctors were trying to
control her withdrawal symptoms, she was so desperate for drugs that
she reached into the toilet to retrieve pills she had just vomited
up. Her next stop was the Hazelden clinic in Minnesota, where she
began a year and a half of withdrawal and recovery.
As she recuperated, her weight ballooned.
Because of her girth, Ms. Gruber said, she was told she would not
be asked back to the Vienna State Opera and was dismissed from the
Salzburg Festival. She bears grudges to this day. "I was sober,
I got my life together, and all of a sudden I was too fat," she
said with disgust.
Her career rehabilitation took a major
step forward in 1999, when Mr. Friend heard her sing well in San Francisco
and took a chance, engaging her for several performances in "Nabucco"
at the Met in 2001. She was hired to sing "Turandot" at
the house in the fall of 2002, a triumphant return that brought cheers
from the chorus. A well-reviewed "Nabucco" came the next
year.
Ms. Gruber lives next door to a firehouse,
Ladder 25, and felt the loss of firefighters at close quarters on
Sept. 11, 2001. Like many others, she experienced a "life is
short" moment, and she decided to have gastric bypass surgery.
"I said, I don't want to spend a second thinking what it's like
to live in this body," she said. "It changed my life. I
can feel my mechanism. I can run around the stage like a monster.
I can sing things in one long breath rather than three or four."
Now, with a boyfriend in West Virginia
(a relationship that blossomed during a six-week e-mail courtship),
her beloved golden retriever, Max, at home and engagements through
2008 at the Met, Ms. Gruber professes to be happy. Striding through
the opera house's basement after a laughter-filled "Turandot"
rehearsal one day recently, she heard repeated variations of "It's
great to have you back!" Security guards greeted her by first
name. She walked out to 65th Street and yelled out to the traffic:
"Mamma need a taxi! Take me home!"
Meditation Gives Brain a Charge, Study Finds
Marc Kaufman, Washington Post- 1/3/2005
Brain research is beginning to produce concrete evidence for something
that Buddhist practitioners of meditation have maintained for centuries:
Mental discipline and meditative practice can change the workings
of the brain and allow people to achieve different levels of awareness.
Those transformed states have traditionally
been understood in transcendent terms, as something outside the world
of physical measurement and objective evaluation. But over the past
few years, researchers at the University of Wisconsin working with
Tibetan monks have been able to translate those mental experiences
into the scientific language of high-frequency gamma waves and brain
synchrony, or coordination. And they have pinpointed the left prefrontal
cortex, an area just behind the left forehead, as the place where
brain activity associated with meditation is especially intense. "What
we found is that the longtime practitioners showed brain activation
on a scale we have never seen before," said Richard Davidson,
a neuroscientist at the university's new $10 million W.M. Keck Laboratory
for Functional Brain Imaging and Behavior. "Their mental practice
is having an effect on the brain in the same way golf or tennis practice
will enhance performance." It demonstrates, he said, that the
brain is capable of being trained and physically modified in ways
few people can imagine.
Scientists used to believe the opposite
-- that connections among brain nerve cells were fixed early in life
and did not change in adulthood. But that assumption was disproved
over the past decade with the help of advances in brain imaging and
other techniques, and in its place, scientists have embraced the concept
of ongoing brain development and "neuroplasticity." Davidson
says his newest results from the meditation study, published in the
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in November, take
the concept of neuroplasticity a step further by showing that mental
training through meditation (and presumably other disciplines) can
itself change the inner workings and circuitry of the brain.
The new findings are the result of
a long, if unlikely, collaboration between Davidson and Tibet's Dalai
Lama, the world's best-known practitioner of Buddhism. The Dalai Lama
first invited Davidson to his home in Dharamsala, India, in 1992 after
learning about Davidson's innovative research into the neuroscience
of emotions. The Tibetans have a centuries-old tradition of intensive
meditation and, from the start, the Dalai Lama was interested in having
Davidson scientifically explore the workings of his monks' meditating
minds. Three years ago, the Dalai Lama spent two days visiting Davidson's
lab.
The Dalai Lama ultimately dispatched
eight of his most accomplished practitioners to Davidson's lab to
have them hooked up for electroencephalograph (EEG) testing and brain
scanning. The Buddhist practitioners in the experiment had undergone
training in the Tibetan Nyingmapa and Kagyupa traditions of meditation
for an estimated 10,000 to 50,000 hours, over time periods of 15 to
40 years. As a control, 10 student volunteers with no previous meditation
experience were also tested after one week of training.
The monks and volunteers were fitted
with a net of 256 electrical sensors and asked to meditate for short
periods. Thinking and other mental activity are known to produce slight,
but detectable, bursts of electrical activity as large groupings of
neurons send messages to each other, and that's what the sensors picked
up. Davidson was especially interested in measuring gamma waves, some
of the highest-frequency and most important electrical brain impulses.
Both groups were asked to meditate,
specifically on unconditional compassion. Buddhist teaching describes
that state, which is at the heart of the Dalai Lama's teaching, as
the "unrestricted readiness and availability to help living beings."
The researchers chose that focus because it does not require concentrating
on particular objects, memories or images, and cultivates instead
a transformed state of being.
Davidson said that the results unambiguously
showed that meditation activated the trained minds of the monks in
significantly different ways from those of the volunteers. Most important,
the electrodes picked up much greater activation of fast-moving and
unusually powerful gamma waves in the monks, and found that the movement
of the waves through the brain was far better organized and coordinated
than in the students. The meditation novices showed only a slight
increase in gamma wave activity while meditating, but some of the
monks produced gamma wave activity more powerful than any previously
reported in a healthy person, Davidson said. The monks who had spent
the most years meditating had the highest levels of gamma waves, he
added. This "dose response" -- where higher levels of a
drug or activity have greater effect than lower levels -- is what
researchers look for to assess cause and effect.
In previous studies, mental activities
such as focus, memory, learning and consciousness were associated
with the kind of enhanced neural coordination found in the monks.
The intense gamma waves found in the monks have also been associated
with knitting together disparate brain circuits, and so are connected
to higher mental activity and heightened awareness, as well.
Davidson's research is consistent with
his earlier work that pinpointed the left prefrontal cortex as a brain
region associated with happiness and positive thoughts and emotions.
Using functional magnetic resonance imagining (fMRI) on the meditating
monks, Davidson found that their brain activity -- as measured by
the EEG -- was especially high in this area.
Davidson concludes from the research
that meditation not only changes the workings of the brain in the
short term, but also quite possibly produces permanent changes. That
finding, he said, is based on the fact that the monks had considerably
more gamma wave activity than the control group even before they started
meditating. A researcher at the University of Massachusetts, Jon Kabat-Zinn,
came to a similar conclusion several years ago.
Researchers at Harvard and Princeton
universities are now testing some of the same monks on different aspects
of their meditation practice: their ability to visualize images and
control their thinking. Davidson is also planning further research.
"What we found is that the trained mind, or brain, is physically
different from the untrained one," he said. In time, "we'll
be able to better understand the potential importance of this kind
of mental training and increase the likelihood that it will be taken
seriously."
Perceptions: Drunk, and Out of Your Depth
Eric Nagourney, New York Times- 1/4/2005
People who drink and drive may be at higher risk for accidents in
part because the alcohol makes it harder to perceive depth, new research
has found. The study, which appears in the current issue of Psychological
Science, explored depth perception that is tied to movement, called
motion parallax, not the better-known kind of depth perception that
people enjoy because of binocular vision. The researchers, led by
Dr. Mark Nawrot of North Dakota State University, were trying to understand
how small eye movements are related to motion parallax.
Fifteen volunteers were asked to take
part in a series of computer tasks while a tracker mounted to their
heads followed their eye movements. They were then asked to drink
enough vodka to bring them near the blood-alcohol level generally
considered a sign of intoxication, and given the tests again. The
volunteers had much more difficulty performing tests involving motion
parallax the second time. The type of depth perception being studied
helps drivers judge their distance from obstacles, the report said.
"In cases when we're driving,
this motion parallax is what's so important in kind of giving us the
spatial layout," Dr. Nawrot said. Knowing this, the researchers
did not allow their volunteers to drive home. "We let their blood
alcohol decline to a sufficient value, and then we called a taxi,"
Dr. Nawrot said.
After Food and Shelter, Help in Coping With Unbearable Loss
Benedict Carey, New York Times- 1/4/2005
Providing psychological services for millions who have lost family
members, homes and communities in Sri Lanka, Indonesia and other countries
will become critical in the coming weeks, officials from the World
Health Organization, Unicef, and other relief agencies say. The scope
of the emotional fallout will be impossible to predict. The first
priority, the officials said, is to deliver food, shelter and drinking
water. But the United Nations has already set up a network for counseling
in Sri Lanka and, on Friday, sent mental health workers to the Maldives.
Any natural disaster takes a steep
emotional toll, the experts said, but this one is distinguished by
its sheer size and scale. Studies of earthquakes, fires, hurricanes
and other disasters that have devastated communities find that a majority
of survivors eventually learn to live with awful memories and to work
through their grief. But a significant number suffer either chronic
mental distress or a more immediate emotional numbness that can isolate
them from others. "At this point we have to be very careful not
to label as a mental health problem this natural psychological response
to being displaced in a split second, to seeing that everything you
had now no longer exists," said Dr. Rachel Yehuda, director of
the traumatic stress program at Mount Sinai School of Medicine and
the Bronx Veterans Affairs Hospital. Those who are deeply scarred
emotionally will need long-term care, she said, not a few hours or
days of emergency care by grief counselors or other mental health
workers.
After suffering a violent injury, or
witnessing a catastrophe, some 5 percent to 10 percent of people suffer
from lingering nightmares, moodiness, nervous exhaustion and other
symptoms of post-traumatic stress syndrome, researchers say. These
symptoms are considered worrisome if they become chronic; they can
appear months or even years after the crisis. Yet the rates of severe
traumatic reactions can be much higher among people sitting directly
in the impact zone of a seemingly apocalyptic event. After a 1988
earthquake that leveled the Armenian town of Spitak, killing half
its schoolchildren, researchers from the University of California,
Los Angeles, found that more than half the town's children suffered
from post-traumatic stress and depression. The rate was less than
half that in Gumri, some 30 miles away, and was negligible in Yerevan,
the capital, 50 miles away. "It's very clear, the more extreme
the experience, the higher the risk of severe psychological reactions,"
said Dr. Alan Steinberg, one of the study's authors. "Those people
who were on the beach in this case, or close, are going to be at highest
risk" of chronic emotional distress.
Even in areas farther inland, psychiatrists
say, the grieving among people who have lost homes and family members
may be complicated by the trauma and violence. When the final memory
of a lost loved one is violent, or suffused with guilt or helpless
rage, experts say, it interferes with the natural ability to mourn
loss, leaving people numb, at risk for serious depression, and cut
off from others around them. "If there's a signature image of
this catastrophe, it's the loss of children, the parents right there
struggling for their own lives but unable to protect or save their
children," said Dr. Robert Pynoos, co-director of the National
Center for Child Traumatic Stress, and a professor of psychiatry at
the University of California's Neuropsychiatric Institute in Los Angeles.
The risk that this prolonged grief can cause depression is greater
still, experts say, when the death of a loved one is not confirmed,
or the body is swept into a mass grave without being identified -
as has occurred in some areas hit by the tsunami.
In such circumstances, when the normal
cultural rituals surrounding death are disrupted, wild rumors often
circulate, experts say. In 1985, volcanic ash and rubble killed some
80 percent of the inhabitants of the Armero, Colombia, sweeping away
the bodies. For months afterward, there were stories and "sightings"
of some of the dead wandering in far-off places. Only after the corpses
were found two years later and proper ceremonies were conducted, did
the survivors accept their loss, according to a World Health Organization
report.
In 2001, a fire in Lima, Peru, killed
some 270 people, charring many bodies beyond recognition and depriving
families of identifiable remains to bury and mourn. In the resulting
confusion, rumors circulated that relief workers were stealing cadavers
for medical experimentation, or selling harvested body parts, the
W.H.O. report said.
In the weeks and months to come, experts
say, relief workers can help dispel such rumors, as well as identify
survivors who are at risk of prolonged depression or traumatic stress.
The health organization has issued guidelines for relief workers on
how to deal with traumatized victims, and a group affiliated with
the University of Oslo is planning a program to provide information
on counseling to teachers and others in the areas hardest hit by the
disaster.
Bipolar Alcoholics Helped by Seizure Drug
Associated Press, 1/4/2005
PITTSBURGH -- A drug used to control seizures can help people with
bipolar disorder and alcoholism stop or reduce drinking, University
of Pittsburgh Medical Center researchers reported. The drug, valproate,
is already used to treat bipolar disorder, also known as manic depression,
which is marked by episodes of depression and mania.
More than 2 million adults, or 1 percent
of the adult population, have bipolar disorder, according to the National
Institutes of Mental Health, which funded the study along with the
National Institute of Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. Many people with
bipolar disorder also abuse alcohol or other drugs. ``Having the combination
(bipolar disorder and alcoholism) really complicates the treatment
for both of them,'' said Dr. Ihsan Salloum, the study's lead author
and an associate professor of psychiatry at the University of Pittsburgh
School of Medicine.
People with bipolar disorder who drink
may not stick with their bipolar medication and drinking can complicate
it, leading to both increased episodes and increased severity, Salloum
said. That can lead to increased hospitalizations and use of costly
psychiatric services. Also, people with bipolar disorder and alcoholism
are more likely to commit suicide, he said.
The study, which Salloum said is the
first to examine both disorders and how to treat them together, appears
in the January edition of Archives of General Psychiatry, published
Monday. Researchers followed 54 patients diagnosed with both disorders
for six months. Patients were given their standard treatment, usually
a combination of lithium (a common bipolar disorder treatment) and
counseling plus valproate or a placebo.
Of those taking valproate, 44 percent
reported heavy drinking days -- defined as five or more drinks daily
for men and four or more for women -- compared with 68 percent in
the placebo group. And the valproate group had about half as many
drinks on heavy drinking days than those in the placebo group. The
study also found that those taking valproate were able to stay away
from heavy alcohol use for about a month longer than the placebo group.
It also found that the valproate group had fewer heavy drinking days
than the placebo group.
Some doctors prescribing valproate
to treat bipolar patients who are also alcoholics have noticed its
effect on drinking and Salloum's findings back that up, said Dr. Kathleen
Brady, a Medical University of South Carolina psychiatry professor
who has studied valproate and who peer-reviewed the study. ``I think
it was a really well-done study and I think the findings are important,''
she said. ``This is going to help people who treat bipolar disorders
with alcohol dependency.'' Brady said the results were modest, but
``clearly demonstrated that valproate added to lithium had better
outcomes'' than lithium alone. Salloum acknowledged the relatively
small study size, adding that it can be difficult to recruit and retain
such patients. He said he hopes others will replicate the study.
Dr. Mark A. Frye, an associate professor
of psychiatry at UCLA and director of its bipolar disorder research
program, said he was familiar with Salloum's study, but didn't review
it. He also called the findings important, saying that studies routinely
exclude one disorder or the other. As for the small size, he said
studies that are the first of their kind are important because they
establish findings, which can then be further evaluated.
On the Net:
University of Pittsburgh Medical Center: www.upmc.com
Archives of General Psychiatry: www.archgenpsychiatry.com
|