| Noteworthy News Articles on Mental Health Topics, March 20-24, 2005 Battling Illness and Social Stigma Amy Whitesall, Ann Arbor News- 3/20/2005 The nightmare is so common, it's almost a cliche -- as much a part of the college experience as used textbooks and ramen noodles. It's exam day in the class that you haven't shown up for since the beginning of the semester and you're not even sure where the exam is, let alone what's on it. Suffering from depression that started his second year at the University of Michigan, Rodolfo Palma-Lulion lived the nightmare. Palma says at one point he enrolled in a physics class that he really liked, took the first test and got one of the best grades in the class. Then he stopped doing the homework. It was part of a cycle he would repeat with one class after another as his then-undiagnosed depression progressively sapped his ability to function. "I started doing badly, and then I stopped showing up to class altogether so that by the day of the exam I didn't know where the exam was," he says. "I spent the entire two hours of the exam running around trying to find out where it was. It was pretty awful." Mental Health Care for Veterans Disputed
As troops return from Iraq and Afghanistan — including thousands with combat-related mental disorders — they enter a Veterans Affairs healthcare system sharply divided about how to care for them. In the last decade, veterans hospitals across the country have sharply reduced the number of inpatient psychiatric beds, replacing them with outpatient programs and homeless services. The new offerings, officials say, cost less and are just as effective. "It used to be with mental illness that once you got it, you never got rid of it," said Dr. Mark Shelhorse, a national VA mental health official. But "mental illness is perceived as a disease now just like hypertension and diabetes. We have medicines to treat it. We know that people recover and lead fully normal lives."
But veterans' advocates and even some VA psychiatrists say the hospitals, including the massive Veterans Affairs Greater Los Angeles Healthcare System, are flirting with disaster. They say the facilities are ill-equipped to deal with veterans who need the most extensive help for psychosis, substance abuse, suicidal impulses and post-traumatic stress disorder. Last year, the Los Angeles hospital closed its psychiatric emergency room, a move that heightened the anger of the VA's critics. "We were too easily swayed in the past by the argument that after a while, PTSD will go away," said Jay Morales, a Vietnam veteran who chairs the mental health consumer advisory council at the Los Angeles hospital. "But there are Vietnam vets walking around today, 30 years after the war ended, having these problems." Dr. William Wirshing, a psychiatrist for 23 years at the Greater Los Angeles VA, agreed. "It's absurd how much they've cut — and it's absurd how much they continue to cut," he said. A decade ago, VA hospitals in Los Angeles had rooms to treat 450 mentally ill patients each day. After a series of cutbacks and consolidations, the main Wadsworth hospital on Wilshire Boulevard can now accommodate only 90 veterans overnight in its psychiatric wards. During the same 10-year period, the overall number of mental health patients treated by the VA Greater Los Angeles increased by about 28%, to 19,734 veterans in 2004. The VA hospital in Los Angeles, the largest veterans hospital in the nation, treats 80,000 veterans annually with a budget of more than $450 million. It includes the hospital, nursing homes, a domiciliary, three main outpatient care sites and 10 community clinics. There are an estimated 510,000 veterans in Los Angeles County alone. VA officials say that despite the cutbacks, the Los Angeles VA hospital offers more mental health services today than ever. Instead of keeping patients in locked wards overnight, the VA offers them outpatient programs and temporary accommodations in partnership with nonprofit groups, officials say. "It's not like we went into a hospital that was fully occupied and we said, 'We don't need this unit anymore,' " said Dr. Andrew Shaner, the hospital's acting director of mental health. "We built programs that kept people relatively well and therefore out of the hospital, and that's why we were able to do it." The question remains: Are the current offerings enough? A report last fall by the U.S. Government Accountability Office cited estimates that 15% of service members stationed in Iraq and Afghanistan would develop post-traumatic stress disorder. As of December, about 1 million troops had spent time in one of the two war zones (about one-third have done more than one tour). The GAO determined that the VA did not have enough information to know if it could meet the increased demand. Shelhorse, the VA's acting deputy consultant for patient care services for mental health, said the agency is monitoring the situation carefully and is pumping millions of dollars into mental health programs. The shift from inpatient to outpatient mental health services has become a controversial issue throughout the VA system. A 1996 federal law prohibits the VA from reducing specialized treatment and rehabilitation for disabled veterans, including mental health services. A VA committee has found that the agency hasn't abided by that law. While VA hospitals may be treating more mentally ill patients, they aren't spending as much money doing so. At the West Los Angeles VA, the amount spent on mental health has decreased from $74 million in fiscal 1997 to $64.4 million in fiscal 2003, according to a national monitoring system. Experts disagree on whether outpatient care can replace inpatient treatment. "I don't think that intensive community treatment can take care of all the people that no longer have the availability of inpatient beds," said Dr. H. Richard Lamb, a psychiatry professor at USC. Lamb said the trend has led to an increase in homeless mentally ill and those in jails. But Dr. Robert Rosenheck, director of the VA's Northeast Program Evaluation Center, said changes in the VA system have not produced those results. Studies, he said, have not shown an increase in jailed veterans after inpatient psychiatric beds have been cut. Nor, he said, have there been significant increases in suicides or veterans showing up at non-VA hospitals for care. "Veterans very much preferred coming in and being in a supportive environment for an extended period of time," Rosenheck said. But "when you look at objective outcomes, we don't see scientific evidence of adverse effects" because of the cutbacks. Even so, veterans' advocates and psychiatrists have been complaining for years about cutbacks at the Greater Los Angeles VA. For many, the final straw came in May when the hospital closed the psychiatric emergency room and shifted mental health emergencies to the main ER. Troubled patients are now cared for by nurses and other staff who, according to the critics, are not adequately trained to handle psychiatric emergencies. Critics point to several instances since the transition in which psychiatric patients were admitted to inpatient wards without any written orders or treated with disrespect by ER nurses who didn't understand their disorders. At least one female patient with PTSD attempted suicide. "This is a dangerous situation," said Guy Mazzeo, a veteran and member of the L.A. mental health consumer advisory council. "None of us" was consulted before the change, he said, referring to advocates for veterans and the VA's outside advisory groups. And none agree with it, he said. The veterans and their doctors have been joined in their criticism by Rep. Henry A. Waxman (D-Los Angeles), whose district includes the VA health center. He asked the VA in January to hire a full-time psychiatrist for the emergency room and arrange for specially trained psychiatric nurses to work there, among other things. The VA declined his requests. "I'm disappointed that the VA has not responded more aggressively," Waxman said in an interview. "With Iraq and Afghanistan war veterans returning, these demands are only going to increase." VA officials say the criticism is unfair. Care in the main ER is more coordinated than the care given in the stand-alone psychiatric emergency room, they say. Patients can get their medical and mental problems treated in one place, instead of having to be shuttled between two. Administrators say ER staff members have received extensive training. And they say that there's no evidence that patients are receiving inferior care. Dr. Dean Norman, the hospital's chief of staff, said the closure of the psychiatric ER made sense because the number of patients using it had been decreasing for years, and the hospital did not have enough staff. "One of our goals is to be good stewards of taxpayer dollars," Norman said. "We didn't make this in a precipitous or reckless fashion. This was well thought out, and we had good reasons for doing this." Benedict Carey, New York Times- 3/22/2005 Sometimes when talking to people, I'll tell them that I've just had a lot of coffee, even though it's not true, because I know I fire off in all directions, and I can talk to you about anything - literature, string theory, rock guitar -- I once worked for Leo Fender -- and one thing I say to people is that, of course, I live near the edge; the view is better." Laurence McKinney, 60, who lives near the edge of Boston, is a business consultant, a Harvard graduate and self-described polymath who has had a career that is every bit as frenzied as his conversational style. Among other ventures, he said, he has started pharmaceutical companies, played in rock bands and helped design electric guitars, and written a book about the neuroscience of spirituality. This month, for the first time, he helped start a Web site for people like himself. They are known as hypomanics. Robin Marantz, Henig, New York Times- 3/22/2005 When the legless man drove up on his own to meet Dr. Michael First for brunch in Brooklyn, it wasn't just to show Dr. First how independent he could be despite his disability. It was to show Dr. First that he had finally done it -- had finally managed to get both his legs amputated, even though they had been perfectly healthy. Dr. First, a professor of psychiatry at Columbia University, had gotten to know this man through his investigations of a bizarre and extremely rare psychiatric condition that he is calling body integrity identity disorder, or B.I.I.D. "This is so completely beyond the realm of normal behavior," he said of the condition, which he estimated afflicts no more than a few thousand people worldwide. "My first thought when I heard about it was, Who would think this could go wrong? Who even thought there was a function that could be broken?" Dr. First is among a small group of psychologists and psychiatrists who are trying to define the disorder, understand its origins and decide whether to include it in the encyclopedic bible of psychiatry, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, or D.S.M., as a full-fledged disease. At the same time, the disorder is turning up as a plot device or documentary subject in a handful of films, plays and television shows. The idea of having extreme elective surgery, even when it involves mutilation or removal of healthy tissue, has met at least some acceptance in cases like sex reassignment, or cosmetic surgery for those who hate their noses or breasts even when those body parts are objectively fine. But an obsessive desire for a limb amputation -- one that drives people to cut off healthy arms and legs -- tests the tolerance of even the most open-minded. Body integrity identity disorder has led people to injure themselves with guns or chain saws in desperate efforts to force surgical amputations. A few have sought out amputations abroad, including one man who died of gangrene after an elective amputation in a clinic in Tijuana, Mexico. The disorder has been known by several names. In 1977, Dr. John Money, an expert on sexuality at Johns Hopkins University, named it apotemnophilia (literally, love of amputation). He considered it a form of paraphilia -- that is, a sexual deviation. In 1997, Dr. Richard Bruno of Englewood Hospital in New Jersey proposed the name factitious disability disorder, which he grouped into three types: people who are sexually aroused by amputees ("devotees"), those who use wheelchairs and crutches to make it seem as if they are amputees ("pretenders") and those who want to get amputations themselves ("wannabes"). In Dr. Bruno's taxonomy, those who manage to obtain amputations continue to be known as wannabes. In 2000, Dr. Gregg Furth, a New York child psychologist and one of Dr. Money's co-authors on his 1977 paper, published a book about the disorder, calling it amputee identity disorder. In addition to his professional interest in the subject, Dr. Furth had a personal one: from early childhood, he had wanted to have his right leg amputated above the knee. Dr. Furth wrote the book with Dr. Robert Smith, whom he met while searching for a surgeon who would perform the elective amputation. When Dr. Furth found him in Scotland, Dr. Smith had already done two such operations, and he agreed, after consulting with two psychiatrists, to operate on Dr. Furth. But in 2000 Dr. Smith's hospital, the Falkirk Royal Infirmary in Glasgow, prohibited any further procedures of this type. Dr. Furth never received his amputation. The newest name, body integrity identity disorder, was first used by Dr. First of Columbia in the journal Psychological Medicine in 2004. In that paper, he described the results of a telephone survey of 52 people with the disorder: 9 of them had amputations and the rest yearned for it. He chose the name to distinguish the disorder from paraphilia, psychosis or body dysmorphic disorder (the false belief that a part of your body is ugly or abnormal). To Dr. First, the closest analogy was to gender identity disorder. "When the first sex reassignment was done in the 1950's, it generated the same kind of horror" that voluntary amputation does now, Dr. First said. "Surgeons asked themselves, 'How can I do this thing to someone that's normal?' The dilemma of the surgeon being asked to amputate a healthy limb is similar." Still, the analogy is imperfect. "It's one thing to say someone wants to go from male to female; they're both normal states," Dr. First said. "To want to go from a four-limbed person to an amputee feels more problematic. That idea doesn't compute to regular people." Dr. David Spiegel of Stanford said he believed that body integrity identity disorder sounded closer to either body dysmorphic disorder or anorexia nervosa, though he added that he had not seen any patients with the integrity disorder. The connection to anorexia, he said, is that people with B.I.I.D. "have a clearly mistaken belief about their bodies." "It reminds me a little of anorexia nervosa," Dr. Spiegel added, "where people think they're fat when it's obvious they're not." No one knows for sure what causes the integrity disorder or how it can be treated. Dr. J. Mike Bensler and Dr. Douglas S. Paauw of the University of Washington Medical Center in Seattle, writing in the Southern Medical Journal in 2003, said it was probably both sexual and emotional in nature. The condition is at its heart an "erotic fantasy," they wrote, with two components: "undergoing amputation of a limb, and subsequently overachieving despite a handicap." According to Dr. First, people with body integrity identity disorder are quite specific about how many limbs they want amputated, and where. The most common is the left leg above the knee; the least common is a finger or toe. "Some people actually know the exact spot where they want the amputation," said Dr. First. "Not just above the knee, but four inches above the knee." Anything short of that specific site can be insufficient. One man from Dr. First's sample had a lifelong fixation on being a double leg amputee. After a shotgun accident, he lost his left arm. Amazingly, this did nothing to diminish the intensity of the man's desire to have his legs amputated. In Dr. First's study, just over half of his subjects had encountered amputees at a young age, and from that time on, they were fixated on getting their limbs removed. "It wasn't so much that I wanted to be an amputee as much as I just felt like I was not supposed to have my legs," said Dr. First's brunch companion in a phone interview, which he granted on the condition of anonymity. The man also was a subject in Dr. First's study. "From the earliest days I can remember, as young as 3 or 4 years of age, I enjoyed playing around using croquet sticks as crutches," he said. "I enjoyed thinking about what it would be like to be missing a leg. When we were playing cowboys and Indians, I seemed to be the person who always got wounded in the leg." This man said his amputations cured his disorder. But Dr. Spiegel said most such operations would probably not do away with the underlying problem. "I don't think the answer is fitting in with the obsession or delusion," he said. Dr. Spiegel expressed more faith in psychotherapy, especially something called response prevention and thought-stopping. "It involves training the patient to try and block the thought when it comes up," he said, "and to keep him from trying to act on it." None of the subjects in Dr. First's study reported being helped by therapy or medication, but Dr. First said that might be because they had not received "psychotherapy tailored to this disorder" or "high sustained doses" of medications used to treat related conditions like obsessive-compulsive disorder. He said more research was needed into treatment options and into whether amputation was an acceptable treatment "as a last resort." People who have lost limbs to accidents or disease are often horrified when they learn about healthy people who seek amputations. "It's very difficult for people who have been through what they consider to be a devastating life experience to understand why anybody would want to mutilate himself in this way," said Paddy Rossbach, president of the Amputation Coalition of America, an advocacy and support group. "Especially when so many people are having tremendous problems with prosthetic fittings, or access to prostheses, and are living with pain every day of their lives." Mrs. Rossbach, who has been missing a leg since childhood, said that some amputees are angry at people with body integrity identity disorder because they believe that the condition "is really minimizing what they themselves have been through." According to Dr. First, people with the disorder are basically normal. "They have families," he said. "They hold all kinds of jobs, doctors and lawyers and professors. They're not screwed-up people apart from this. You could spend an evening with them and never have the slightest clue." But people with serious mental illnesses, even psychoses, often look normal on the surface, Dr. Spiegel said. Still, the surface can mask some profound problems. "It's often the case that people with this kind of delusion would pass a mental status screen," he said. "They can do abstract thinking, they're not disoriented, they look pretty good to the outside world as long as you don't trip over their delusion." Yet many with the disorder would go to extreme measures to get rid of the limb they consider extraneous. In May 1998, the urge drove one man to a California surgeon who had lost his license more than 20 years earlier for several botched attempts at sex reassignment surgery. At a clinic in Tijuana, the surgeon, John Ronald Brown, 77, cut off the left leg of Philip Bondy, 79, of New York, who had paid him $10,000. Then Mr. Brown sent Mr. Bondy to a motel in a run-down section of San Diego to recover on his own. Two days later, Mr. Bondy was dead of gangrene, and Mr. Brown was charged with second-degree murder. During the trial, newspaper reports said that Mr. Bondy had sought the operation to satisfy a "sexual craving." Mr. Brown was found guilty in October 1999 and sentenced to 15 years to life in prison. Mr. Bondy was not alone in his desperation. Among the body integrity identity disorder sufferers in the documentary "Whole" by Melody Gilbert, broadcast on the Sundance Channel in May 2003, is a Florida man who shot his own leg so it would be amputated in the emergency room, and a man from Liverpool, England, who packed his leg in dry ice for the same reason. The man who froze his leg referred to the resulting amputation as "body correction surgery." The condition is slowly making its way into popular culture. At the New York International Fringe Festival last summer, an award for best overall production went to "Armless," a play about a middle-aged suburbanite with the disorder. The playwright, Kyle Jarrow, said his goal was to explore "the line between gross and spooky and funny and poignant." In November, an episode of "CSI: New York" featured a man with the disorder who bled to death after he tried to saw off his leg. And last month, a screening was held in the East Village of "Pretender's Dance," a short film by Tom Keefe about a young choreographer and her boyfriend who wanted amputation. Dr. Smith, the Scottish surgeon who removed the legs of two men before his hospital forced him to stop, is trying to get the disorder formally recognized so that the amputations can be covered by the National Health Service. "The Hippocratic oath says first do your patients no harm," he said in the film "Whole." But maybe the real harm, he said, is to refuse to treat such a patient, "leaving him in a state of permanent mental torment," when all it would take for him "to live a satisfied and happy life" would be to amputate. Dr. Smith's American co-author, Dr. Furth, is trying to get body integrity identity disorder added to the D.S.M., the textbook compiled by the American Psychiatric Association that lists all mental disorders considered distinct, pathological and worthy of reimbursement by health insurance companies. Dr. First of Columbia is on the board of editors for the next edition of the textbook. Even though he is one of the few psychiatrists who studies the disorder, he still has not decided whether it should be included. Putting the disorder into the manual could generate research interest into its origin and possible treatment, he said. But, he added, "the D.S.M. already is a very big book." "And as far as clinical utility," Dr. First said, "the thicker it gets, the less useful it gets." And while the disorder is genuine, he said, he has to recognize that it may be too rare for mention in a book that is already buckling under the weight of its inclusiveness. Anahad O'Connor, New York Times- 3/22/2005 For many psychiatric disorders, drug therapy has become the norm. But phobias -- irrational fears that can paralyze and disrupt people's lives -- have been largely resistant to chemical intervention, and behavioral therapies have remained the treatment of choice. Recently, however, a tuberculosis drug with surprising effects on the brain has given psychiatrists hope that a new approach to phobias and other severe anxiety disorders may be in the offing. The drug, D-cycloserine, an antibiotic, does nothing to soothe panic or calm nerves. Instead, it increases learning and memory, and may help people overcome their fears faster in psychotherapy, which can be costly and take years. Gov't to Cover Smoking Cessation Programs Associated Press, 3/22/2005 WASHINGTON -- You're never too old to quit smoking, government officials said Tuesday, announcing that Medicare will immediately start covering the cost of counseling for certain beneficiaries who want to quit tobacco. Medicare's new smoking cessation program ``has great potential to save and improve lives for millions of seniors,'' said Mark McClellan, administrator for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Not every Medicare beneficiary qualifies for the new benefit -- only those who have an illness caused by tobacco use or complicated by tobacco use. Jodi Wilgoren, New York Times- 3/23/2005 He is said to have worn a trench coat and listened to Marilyn Manson, the Goth icon. He expressed his admiration for Hitler on a neo-Nazi Web site. And in the midst of a murderous rampage at his high school, Jeff Weise asked a classmate if he believed in God, then shot him, one student recounted in a local newspaper. As details begin to emerge about Mr. Weise's shooting spree on an Indian reservation in northern Minnesota, there are eerie echoes of the nation's most infamous school tragedy, six years ago at Columbine High School near Littleton, Colo. At Columbine, the killers, Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, belonged to the "Trench Coat Mafia" and loved all things Goth. They sometimes did a Nazi salute while bowling and planned their attack for Hitler's birthday. Before killing one student, witnesses said, one of them held a gun to her temple and asked if she believed in God. "My heart just sank, like 'Oh, my God,' I thought of that day," Tom Mauser, whose son, Daniel, was among the 15 people killed at Columbine, recalled of his reaction upon first learning of the Minnesota massacre. "We just kind of knew there was a good chance it was going to happen again." Describing Mr. Weise's black, spiky hair and black Goth clothes, Ashley Morrison, a fellow student at Red Lake High School, told The Associated Press, "He looks like one of those guys at the Littleton school." Beyond these particular similarities, experts on school shootings said Mr. Weise appears to fit squarely into a pattern of disaffected youth who struggle to fit in at homogenous schools in rural or suburban areas, then erupt in violence to seek attention, enact revenge and gain power over people who have taunted them. They interpret his Internet postings as an outcast's quest to belong to something larger, another common thread in school shootings. Reports of Mr. Weise drawing gory pictures in class were classic warning signs of what was to come, they say. "It typically happens in small, remote towns because the protagonist is a boy who is socially incapable in many ways," said Katherine Newman, a sociologist at Princeton University and the editor of "Rampage: The Social Roots of School Shootings," published last year. "This is someone who is a failed joiner, who is repeatedly trying to gain access to peer groups that reject him." While the Columbine killers came from stable families in a well-off suburb, Mr. Weise, who the authorities said was 16, lived on a reservation where 40 percent of the people are poor, and without his parents. His race belies any pattern: 27 of the 28 school gunmen from 1992 to 2002 were white, said Michael Kimmel, a sociologist at the State University of New York, Stony Brook, who studied them. In 34 postings to www.nazi.org, a forum operated by the Libertarian National Socialist Green Party, that the authorities said Tuesday they were investigating for hints to motive, someone identifying himself as Jeff Weise, a high school student on the Red Lake Indian Reservation, expressed frustration at the lack of racial purity and pride among his people. Calling himself "NativeNazi" or "Todesengel," German for "angel of death," Mr. Weise said he had found few sympathizers for his racial views and had sometimes been persecuted for them. "I already had a fist fight with a communist not too long ago over me being what I am (I also won), but it was worth it," he wrote on May 26 at 2:27 a.m. In another post, Mr. Weise complained that "less than 1 percent of all the people on the reservation can speak their own language," and said that his peers eschewed their culture to emulate rappers. He said his parents were American Indians, but that he had German, Irish and French-Canadian ancestry as well, and that when he had spoken of the need for his tribe to have "more pure bloods" he was called a racist. Mr. Weise also frequently contributed to stories about zombies on an Internet forum called "Rise of the Dead," according to The Associated Press. Parston Graves Jr., a Red Lake student, told The A.P. that Mr. Weise had displayed a sketch of a guitar-strumming skeleton captioned, "March to the death song 'til your boots fill with blood," in class, and had shown off his drawings of people shooting each other. Paul Viollis, author of the 2001 book "Avoiding Violence in Our Schools," said "the Nazi issue is a collateral issue," a way for someone not on the football team or in the popular clique to find an identity. "This individual found some type of solace," he said. People who monitor neo-Nazi groups said the Libertarian forum frequented by Mr. Weise is a little-known Internet-only organization with no known links to violence, whose niche is to welcome people of all races who oppose race-mixing. As for the unlikely prospect of an American Indian Nazi, Mark Potok of the Southern Poverty Law Center, said African-Americans, Jews and gays have all been members of racial hate groups. "Kids like this feel extremely powerless, and they want to associate with the oppressor, not the oppressed," he said. "That's where you get this bizarre phenomenon of people joining movements that aim to exterminate them, or people like them." In an article posted Tuesday on www.nazi.org, the group "refused to wring hands" over the shootings, instead saying, "Such events are to be expected when thinking people are crammed into an unthinking, irrational, modern society." Signs of Danger Were Missed in a Troubled Teenager's Life Monica Davey & Jodi Wilgoren, New York Times- 3/24/2005 BEMIDJI, Minn., March 23 - Looking back at all the pieces, some who knew Jeff Weise say they wonder why someone did not see his eruption coming months, or even years, ago. There was the threat Mr. Weise, 16, once made on his own life, sending him away from his home on the Red Lake Indian Reservation for psychiatric treatment. There were the pictures of bloodied bodies and guns he drew and shared freely with classmates. There was the story he apparently wrote about a shooting spree at a school in a small town. "The clues were all there," said Kim DesJarlait, Mr. Weise's stepaunt, who lives in Minneapolis. "Everything was laid out, right there, for the school or the authorities in Red Lake to see it coming. I don't want to blame Red Lake, but did they not put two and two together? This kid was crying out, and those guys chose to ignore it. They need to start focusing on their kids." Others, including the principal of the high school where, on Monday, Mr. Weise killed five students, a security guard, a teacher and then himself, defended their handling of the teenager, saying that the authorities had seen all there was -- at the time -- to see, and had actually been struggling madly to help a boy through his difficult youth. "We may need people to be more aware," the principal of Red Lake High School, Chris Dunshee, acknowledged on Wednesday, after teachers and school board officials met privately for the first time for counseling. "But I think most of us felt like this was a troubled young man, and someone whose problems we felt like we were addressing." Beyond the outward signs of stress, however, there was another indication, far darker and more explicit, that people on the reservation said they had never seen or heard of: Mr. Weise's vast Internet life. Though many here said Mr. Weise spent a lot of time on his computer, many said they themselves did not have access to a computer, and all said they had never seen the alarming postings submitted under Mr. Weise's name. A loner in real life, Mr. Weise, who also killed his grandfather and his grandfather's companion and wounded seven people on Monday, found a community of sorts in cyberspace, confiding his problems with depression, loneliness and abuse to people who cheered his macabre short stories and drawings and sympathized with his racial ideologies. On Wednesday, some of his Internet pen pals lamented that there had been warning signs they missed, including a gory zombie tale Mr. Weise apparently wrote about a school shooting that mentioned Columbine, an animated film he posted in which a killer committed suicide, and an eerie message that, in retrospect, seems to foreshadow his fate. Things are "kind of rocky right now so I might disappear unexpectedly," Mr. Weise wrote Feb. 6 on a Web forum where members collaborate to write fiction. Last October, he posted an animated film on newgrounds.com. In it, a man shoots people with a rifle, unleashing flashes of red blood across a simple black and white drawing, then tosses a hand grenade into a police car, puts a pistol in his mouth and commits suicide. When another member of the site wrote, "Was that like a warning message? Hmm dude you need help badly," Mr. Weise, posting under the name Regret, responded: "You obviously can't tell the difference between fantasy and reality," adding, "Don't try judging my mental health based upon a simple animation, capisce?" In a Yahoo profile last updated in June 2004, Mr. Weise used the moniker verlassen4_20, combining Hitler's birthday (April 20) with a German word meaning "forsaken" or "abandoned," said his nickname was Totenkopf, German for "death's head" or "skull," and included a doctored picture of himself with a monster's teeth and empty eyes. Under "latest news" he said he was on antidepressants, seeing a therapist and had "a brand new pair of cuts on my wrists"; his favorite quote, which he attributed to Hitler, was "The law of existence requires uninterrupted killing ... So that the better may live." On one Web site, Mr. Weise said last year that he had been accused of threatening to "shoot up" the school last April 20, the fifth anniversary of the Columbine shootings in Colorado, but that he had been cleared. On Wednesday, Mr. Dunshee declined to say whether Mr. Weise was suspected of such a threat. "That will come out in the investigation," he said. It is difficult, if not impossible, to verify Mr. Weise's authorship of these Internet postings without reviewing his computer; the Federal Bureau of Investigation said it would investigate them. The postings are linked to a profile on www.nazi.org in which he introduced himself by name and said he was a high school student on the Red Lake Indian Reservation. Several people who communicated with him on the sites confirmed that the posts were made long before Monday's massacre. A spokeswoman for Yahoo said the company's privacy policy prevented her from discussing the account; operators of the other sites either refused to authenticate the postings or did not respond to inquiries. The administrator of one forum, who asked that it not be named for fear the site would be crashed by overwhelming traffic, shared several private messages Mr. Weise sent in which he said his mother drank excessively and abused him before the car accident that rendered her brain-damaged and confined to a nursing home. "I have friends, but I'm basically a loner inside a group of loners," Mr. Weise wrote, according to the administrator. "I'm excluded from anything and everything they do. I'm never invited. I don't even know why they consider me a friend or I them." In another message, Mr. Weise wrote that his mother "would hit me with anything she could get her hands on," and "would tell me I was a mistake, and she would say so many things that its hard to deal with them or think of them without crying." Most troubling, perhaps, was the story of a shooting spree he posted on a site called Writer's Coven in December 2003. In it, he wrote of a character dressed all in black, a teacher with a Hitleresque moustache, and complaints about how the shooting at Columbine High had led to increased security on campus. As in Monday's rampage, one of the victims at his fictional school was the security guard -- "or what was left of him," the story said, his throat having "been ripped out, replaced by a bloody mass of torn tissue." It went on: "In the distance, somewhere else in the school, the sound of a blood curdling scream echoed through the hallways." But in Mr. Weise's real school, Red Lake High, and among those who knew his family, the only true danger people said they had sensed was for Mr. Weise's future and his happiness. The high school students, who will not be allowed to return to the bullet-ridden school for at least a few more days, were expected to gather for counseling on Thursday for the first time since Monday's deaths. "There were a lot of signs of real trouble," said T'Anna Hanson, 21, who knew Mr. Weise and was the cousin of one victim. "He was confined to a computer all the time, and he had said last year that he was going to kill himself. But somehow I was never scared of him. I don't know why not. He never really showed that it could be directed this way." Some students said Mr. Weise had shown them elaborate, disturbing drawings he made in his notebook, some of them depicting people with bullet holes in their heads, of half-living people with blank stares, of skeletons. None of the students interviewed said they reported the drawings to school officials. They said they had viewed them as the odd but harmless doodlings of a strange boy. "He was different, you could say, out of place around here," said Patrick Tahahwah, 23, who knew Mr. Weise. Katherine S. Newman, a professor at Princeton University, who edited the book "Rampage: The Social Roots of School Shootings" in 2004, said Mr. Weise showed indications nearly identical to earlier gunmen: his comments, his drawings, his social life. "They were classic signs of a pathway leading to a shooting -- the kid was literally giving off warnings," Professor Newman said. But she cautioned against blaming school officials or others for not recognizing that, saying, "It is exceedingly difficult to see these kids coming, to put it together and see the pattern." Mr. Weise, who wore eye makeup and a black trench coat that fell to the ground over his 6-foot, 250-pound frame, had been told recently not to study at school, but to study privately with a teacher at home. The reason, the principal said, was to offer Mr. Weise the extra help he needed, given what the principal described only as his "issues." Mr. Weise, who had been held back in school, was teased because he was larger than most of the other sophomores, because he dressed in Goth style and wandered around by himself, and, Mr. Tahahwah said, because of his parents' fates. Everyone at Red Lake knew about that. In July 1997, Mr. Weise's father, Daryl Lussier Jr., killed himself in a standoff with the police on the Red Lake reservation, the tribe's home in far northern Minnesota, about 30 miles from Bemidji, the nearest city. In March 1999, his mother, Joanne, suffered a brain injury when the car she was riding in struck a tractor-trailer on a highway in Minneapolis, Ms. DesJarlait said. The driver, a cousin of his mother, had been drinking and was killed. After the accident, Ms. DesJarlait said, Mr. Weise, who had lived most of his life in Minneapolis with his mother, was sent back to Red Lake to live with his grandparents. He did not want to go, family members said. Though she knew Mr. Weise had had a difficult adolescence, Ms. DesJarlait said she still finds it hard to reconcile Monday's shootings with the stepnephew she remembered from his younger years. While he was growing up in Minneapolis, she said, Mr. Weise was a sweet boy who liked to go to movies, play outside, go to restaurants, and have friends over for sleepovers. Now, Ms. DesJarlait said, the family is left to explain what happened -- something she said she has no answers to -- to Mr. Weise's half brother, 7, and half sister, 8. "They know that he killed himself, but they don't understand about the others -- about the size of it," she said. "I guess I don't either. I don't how know it came to this." But in a blog Mr. Weise apparently kept on livejournal.com, he seemed to explain his swirl downward. "Right about now I feel as low as I ever have," the January posting said. "I'm starting to regret sticking around. I should've taken the razor blade express last time around. Well, whatever, man. Maybe they've got another shuttle comin' around sometime soon." A Study Ties Loss of a Child to Mental Ills Benedict Carey, New York Times- 3/24/2005 The death of a child not only alters a family forever but also sharply increases the risk that parents will later be hospitalized for a mental illness, researchers are reporting in the largest study to date of parent bereavement and mental health. The risk is greatest during the first year after the child's death but remains elevated even five years afterward, the researchers found, and includes higher rates of schizophrenia, depression and abuse of drugs and alcohol. The overall rate of psychiatric hospitalization among bereaved parents in the study was less than 3 percent over five years, but, experts noted, doctors do not usually admit patients for mental illness unless their condition is urgent. The paper appears in the current issue of The New England Journal of Medicine. "This is a very important study, because bereavement traditionally has been way underrecognized and undertreated in medicine and psychiatry," said Dr. M. Katherine Shear, director of the Bereavement and Grief Program at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, who was not involved in the research. After Drug Scare, No Easy Answers for Depressed Kids Shari Roan, Los Angeles Times- 3/21/2005 When Janna Tennant's 13-year-old son was hospitalized for depression last spring, the news media already were rife with stories about a possible link between antidepressant use in youths and an increased risk of suicide. "I remember questioning the psychiatrist at the time about the safety of starting him on Zoloft," an antidepressant, says Tennant, who lives in Mission Viejo. "The doctors didn't think it would be a problem whatsoever." For a time, the teenager's mood disorder appeared to improve. But after he stopped taking the medication for five days, then resumed it, he became irritable, aggressive and stubborn, Tennant says. She took him off the medication and instead sent her son to counseling, encouraging him to exercise more and eat a healthier diet. The experience not only made her question her doctor's advice, she says, but also "gave me pause about the safety of the drugs." Like Tennant, a growing number of parents, and some doctors, appear increasingly uneasy with antidepressants for treating childhood depression. Six months ago, the Food and Drug Administration voted to affix a black box warning — the most stringent safety warning — to SSRI antidepressants prescribed for children based on studies linking the drugs to a slight increase in suicidal behavior. SSRIs (or serotonin reuptake inhibitors) are a class of medications that include Prozac, Zoloft, Paxil and others. The number of prescriptions for antidepressants for children younger than 18 dropped 10% last year, according to data from Medco Health Solutions, a national firm that manages pharmacy benefit programs for employers. The decline is striking considering that antidepressant use by children had been rising sharply. From 1998 to 2002, prescriptions for kids had increased by 49%. Some health officials express concern that the public has overreacted to the FDA decision and that some children who might benefit from antidepressants will not use them. Several mental health organizations have been revamping their websites and publishing brochures and guides to help families sort out the facts on treatment for childhood depression. "Parents and physicians are being particularly cautious about the use of these medications, which in many cases is entirely appropriate," says Dr. David Fassler, a child and adolescent psychiatrist in Burlington, Vt., and a spokesman for the American Psychiatric Assn. "But I do worry that some parents may be frightened and confused by the numerous media reports and may be reluctant to seek help for their children with psychiatric disorders. There are very significant risks of not treating an illness like depression." The FDA action came after health officials last September held a two-day hearing to examine evidence from clinical trials involving more than 4,000 children who took either an antidepressant or a placebo. The analysis showed no suicides in either group. Two out of 100 kids on placebo demonstrated suicidal thinking, compared with 4 out of 100 kids taking antidepressants. Following an advisory panel recommendation, the FDA ordered the black box warning in October. Some panel members voted against the warning, however, noting that the studies followed the subjects for a relatively short period and only included children in clinical trials. "They put a stop sign in front of the decision to use SSRIs," says Dr. Ken Duckworth, medical director for the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill. "Pediatricians are more anxious about prescribing them, and families are thinking twice about going there." It's understandable why parents might be confused about the antidepressant issue. Few long-term studies have been done attesting to the safety and effectiveness of SSRI antidepressants for children younger than 18. It is also difficult to weigh the benefits of drug therapy against the highly publicized risk of suicidal thinking. Prozac is the only drug approved for childhood depression, although other SSRIs are routinely prescribed for kids. "Families end up in a terrible quandary having to do the risk-benefit analysis themselves in the absence of so little data," says Gail Griffith, a Washington, D.C., mother whose son, Will, attempted suicide while taking antidepressants in 2001. "I believe the drugs are both effective and valuable," says Griffith, who was a parent representative to the FDA advisory board. "But I will never know whether or not they caused or increased his suicidal thinking. I'm lucky he survived." Griffith's son gradually regained his health on a combination of therapies that included antidepressants. Some health experts contend that the drop in antidepressant use by children could represent a more thoughtful approach to medications, some of which may have been prescribed cavalierly to children who were not properly diagnosed or monitored carefully thereafter. The decline in prescriptions "shows that when physicians and parents are informed with accurate information they make informed decisions," says Vera Hassner Sharav of the Alliance for Human Research Protection, a group that works to protect human research subjects. The group is not anti-medication or anti-psychiatry, she says. "But you would like to see evidence that these drugs have been shown to be beneficial in children." The black box warning could be useful if it leads to more careful diagnosing of children, says Sheila McDonald, board vice president of the Child & Adolescent Bipolar Foundation, an advocacy group that lobbied for the warning. Antidepressants prescribed to a child who has bipolar disorder, but who has been improperly diagnosed with depression, can worsen the disease. With bipolar disorder, depression alternates with bouts of mania. The debate has also left pediatricians and other primary care doctors in a quandary, says Dr. Anette Johnson, an Orange County pediatrician. Because of a nationwide shortage of child and adolescent psychiatrists, many families must seek help from their primary care provider. Those doctors typically don't have enough time or expertise for mental health care, she says. And some health insurance plans only cover medications, while restricting psychotherapy. "Ten minutes isn't long enough to make a fair and honest assessment of whether a teen is bipolar or depressed or is in early psychosis," she says. "It's hard to expect primary care providers to be psychiatrists. And as soon as you have this black box warning, most pediatricians will defer."
|